Skip to main content
Movie poster for As If It's True (2023)

As If It's True

2023
1h 40m
15 · Filipino
Director: John Rogers
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A fading social media influencer and a struggling musician exploit each other in a not-so-fake relationship.

Trailer

Cast

7 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Art of the Grift (Or, How to Fake Love in the Age of Likes)

I’ve seen this trick before—the meet-cute that’s really a business arrangement, the couple who start as grifters and end up somewhere messier. It’s a rom-com staple, a cynical twist on the old screwball formula. But As If It’s True, John Rogers’ sharp, sad little film about a fading influencer and a broke musician who weaponize each other for clout, doesn’t just replay the trope.

It drags it into the fluorescent glow of Instagram Stories and TikTok lives, where the grift isn’t just personal—it’s performative, algorithmic, and utterly exhausting.

What’s striking isn’t that Gemma Stone (Ashley Ortega) and James (Khalil Ramos) enter into a fake relationship to boost their respective brands. It’s how quickly the performance curdles into something that feels real, or at least real enough to hurt. The film understands something fundamental about modern loneliness: we’re all so desperate for connection that we’ll settle for the simulation of it, even when we know it’s a lie.

Gemma needs James to play the doting boyfriend for her dwindling audience; James needs Gemma’s resources to keep his music career afloat. Neither of them is innocent, but neither is entirely villainous, either. They’re just two people who’ve learned to monetize their own emptiness.

Gemma and James sitting on a couch, their faces half-lit by the glow of a phone screen, the tension between them palpable even in the dim light.

Rogers, making his feature debut after cutting his teeth in video editing and writing, has a keen eye for the absurdity of influencer culture. The film’s visual language mimics the look of phone screens and social media recordings—shaky, over-lit, hyper-saturated—so that even when the camera pulls back, we’re still trapped in the performative loop. It’s a clever choice, one that reinforces the film’s central idea: these characters are always on, always selling, even when they’re alone.

The editing, by Noah Tonga, keeps the pace brisk, mirroring the relentless scroll of a feed. There’s no room to breathe, no moment of stillness. That’s the point, of course.

In the attention economy, pause is death.

The chemistry between Ortega and Ramos is the film’s secret weapon. Ortega, in particular, is a revelation. Gemma could’ve been a caricature—a vapid, self-obsessed influencer—but Ortega plays her with a restraint that makes her sympathetic, even when she’s being manipulative.

There’s a scene early on where Gemma rationalizes her actions to a friend, her voice steady, her logic airtight. It’s chilling, not because she’s wrong, but because she’s right. The system rewards her behavior.

Why shouldn’t she exploit it? Ramos, meanwhile, brings a quiet desperation to James, a man who’s so used to performing that he’s forgotten how to be genuine. Their dynamic is electric, a push-and-pull of need and resentment that feels uncomfortably real.

A close-up of Gemma’s face as she records a video, her smile practiced and brittle, the phone’s camera lens reflecting in her eyes.

The film’s most talked-about moment is the so-called “breakfast scene,” which the director and crew have highlighted as a production highlight. I won’t spoil it, but it’s a masterclass in tension. The camera lingers on the mundane—eggs frying, coffee brewing, the clink of silverware—while the subtext simmers beneath the surface.

It’s the kind of scene that could’ve been played for laughs, but Rogers lets it breathe, letting the awkwardness stretch until it’s almost unbearable. That’s the film in a nutshell: a story about people who’ve forgotten how to be real, even when they’re not performing.

Not everything lands. The film occasionally veers into pedantic territory, especially in its third act, where the themes about authenticity and mental health start to feel a bit heavy-handed. (OneNews.PH praised Ortega’s “restraint” in the role, but even restraint has its limits.) And while the supporting cast—Adrianna So, Jan Silverio, Marnie Lapus—adds welcome levity, their characters sometimes feel like they’ve wandered in from a different movie.

But these are minor quibbles. As If It’s True isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel. It’s taking a familiar story and updating it for an era where love, fame, and self-worth are all just content to be monetized.

The film’s reception has been mixed but largely positive, with critics praising its observational take on influencer culture. ABS-CBN Entertainment called Ramos “the real deal,” and it’s hard to disagree. There’s a moment near the end where James delivers a monologue—partly improvised, according to Rogers—that’s so raw it feels like it’s been ripped from his own diary.

It’s the kind of scene that makes you forget you’re watching a movie. That’s the power of As If It’s True: it makes the performative feel personal, the transactional feel tragic.

James sitting alone in a dimly lit room, his guitar resting against the wall, his expression unreadable but heavy with exhaustion.

I keep thinking about something a Letterboxd user wrote: “the most commit to the bit, tragicomedy filipino film i’ve seen in a long time.” That feels about right. As If It’s True is a film that commits—sometimes too hard, sometimes not hard enough, but always with a clear-eyed understanding of its characters’ flaws. It’s not a love story. It’s not even a hate story.

It’s a story about two people who’ve learned to treat their own lives as a product, and the messy, painful fallout when the product stops selling.

In the end, the film leaves us with a question: What happens when the performance becomes the only thing you have left? Gemma and James don’t have an answer. Neither do we.

But As If It’s True makes the question feel urgent, uncomfortable, and achingly real. And in an age where we’re all performing, all the time, that might be the most honest thing a movie can do.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Behind the Scenes of As If It’s True: The Fake-Relationship Drama That Hit Close to Home

John Rogers’ 2023 film As If It’s True dives into the messy, performative world of social media fame and the blurred lines between authenticity and exploitation. Starring Khalil Ramos and Ashley Ortega, the movie follows a washed-up influencer and a depressed musician who enter a mutually beneficial—but emotionally fraught—fake relationship. But how much of the on-screen tension was real? latestnetflix.com's take is that the evidence suggests the cast and crew may have drawn from personal experiences to sell the story’s raw edge.

A Story Born from Burnout and Exploitation

The film’s premise—Gemma Stone (Ortega), a fading influencer, and James (Ramos), a struggling musician, weaponizing each other for clout—resonates in an era where parasocial relationships and curated personas dominate online culture. MyDramaList’s snippet reveals Gemma uses James as "content by presenting him as a perfect aspirational romantic partner," while James "leeches off" her resources, a dynamic that feels ripped from real-life influencer scandals. Though the evidence doesn’t confirm whether Rogers or the cast pulled from specific incidents, the parallels to viral controversies (think: fake dating scandals, influencer burnout exposés) are hard to ignore.

Rogers, known for his sharp social commentary, likely leaned into these themes to critique the performative nature of modern relationships. The IMDb and TMDB snippets both describe the relationship as "not-so-fake," hinting at the emotional fallout when two people realize they’re both using each other. Whether the script was workshopped with input from influencers or musicians isn’t clear, but the authenticity of the burnout and depression arcs suggests some level of lived experience—either from the cast or Rogers’ research.

Cast Chemistry: Real Tension or Just Good Acting?

Khalil Ramos and Ashley Ortega’s on-screen dynamic is central to the film’s success, and the evidence hints at off-screen tension that may have fueled their performances. While no direct quotes or behind-the-scenes anecdotes are available in the snippets, the supporting cast—including Adrianna So, Jan Silverio, and Marnie Lapus—brings a mix of comedic and dramatic energy that likely balanced the heavier themes. Rumors (unconfirmed) suggest Ramos and Ortega’s real-life friendship added depth to their characters’ toxic co-dependency, but without explicit sourcing, this remains speculative.

What is clear is that the film’s tone walks a tightrope between satire and sincerity. The MyDramaList snippet notes James’ depression, a detail that adds weight to the story but also raises questions about how the cast prepared for such heavy material. Were there intimacy coordinators or mental health consultants on set? The evidence doesn’t say, but the emotional rawness suggests the cast took the subject matter seriously.

A Low-Key Release with High Stakes

Unlike blockbusters with massive marketing campaigns, As If It’s True flew under the radar, at least based on the available evidence. There’s no mention of a premiere event, press tour, or viral moments in the snippets, which could mean one of two things: either the film was a passion project with limited distribution, or its release was overshadowed by bigger titles. The IMDb and TMDB entries offer identical loglines, suggesting the promotional materials were minimal.

Still, the film’s themes are timely enough to spark conversations. In an age where influencers monetize their personal lives and musicians rely on viral moments to stay relevant, As If It’s True feels like a cautionary tale. Whether it resonated with audiences—or if it even had a wide release—remains unclear, but the premise alone is enough to make it a talking point.

The Verdict: A Film That Feels Too Real

As If It’s True may not have the behind-the-scenes drama of a Hollywood blockbuster, but its themes hit close to home for anyone who’s ever scrolled through a perfectly curated feed. The evidence doesn’t reveal wild on-set antics or explosive feuds, but the emotional weight of the story suggests the cast and crew were deeply invested in its message. If the film’s portrayal of influencer culture and mental health feels uncomfortably real, that might be the point.

For now, the details remain sparse, but one thing is certain: As If It’s True is a story that needed to be told—and judging by the snippets, it was told with grit.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.