
Marsha Timothy
Murni

After being abducted and taken to a desolate house, a girl sets out to rescue her friend and escape from their malicious kidnapper.
Official
I’ve seen horror films that rely on jump scares, gore, or psychological mind games. I’ve seen films that use silence as a weapon—A Quiet Place taught us that much. But Monster (2023) takes the concept further than most: it doesn’t just weaponize silence.
It erases dialogue entirely. No words. No explanations.
Just two children, a locked door, and the unspoken terror of what lies beyond it.
That choice is either brilliant or maddening, and I’m still not sure which.

Rako Prijanto’s film is a remake of The Boy Behind the Door (2020), but where the original leaned on sharp, claustrophobic dialogue to ratchet up tension, this version strips everything away. The result is a film that feels like a dare: Can you handle 84 minutes of pure, unrelenting dread without a single line of exposition? The answer, for me, was yes—but not without frustration.
The premise is simple: Alana (Anantya Kirana) and Rabin (Sulthan Hamonangan) are kidnapped and locked in a remote house. Their captors, played with chilling physicality by Marsha Timothy and Alex Abbad, are more force of nature than human beings. The kids must escape, but how do you plot an escape when you can’t even whisper a plan?
That’s the film’s central tension, and for long stretches, it works. The lack of dialogue forces you to pay attention to everything else—the way Alana’s fingers tremble as she reaches for a doorknob, the way Rabin’s breath hitches when he hears footsteps outside. The performances are remarkable, especially from the young leads.
Kirana and Hamonangan convey terror, determination, and even fleeting moments of hope without ever uttering a word. Their faces are the film’s most powerful special effect.
But silence, like any tool, can be overused. There are moments when the absence of dialogue feels less like a bold artistic choice and more like a narrative cop-out. When Alana and Rabin are separated, their desperate attempts to communicate through gestures and expressions are heartbreaking.
But when they’re together, the silence starts to chafe. Why wouldn’t they at least try to whisper? Why wouldn’t they scream when no one’s around?
The film never answers these questions, and that’s where the experiment starts to feel less like a statement and more like a gimmick.
If the visuals are the film’s strength, the sound design is its most divisive element. The score is a constant, droning presence—sometimes effective, sometimes intrusive. There’s a scene early on where Alana and Rabin are hiding in a closet, their breath shallow, their hearts pounding. The music swells, and for a moment, it’s unbearably tense. But then it keeps swelling. And swelling. And suddenly, the tension tips into melodrama. It’s as if the film is telling you how to feel, rather than letting the silence do the work.
The South China Morning Post called Monster a film that “goes the A Quiet Place route but fails miserably,” and while I wouldn’t go that far, I see the point. A Quiet Place used silence as a survival mechanism—its characters had to stay quiet, or they’d die. Monster’s silence feels arbitrary by comparison. There’s no in-world reason for it, no rule forcing the characters to stay mute.
It’s just… there. And after a while, that arbitrariness starts to wear on you.

There’s one moment that stuck with me long after the credits rolled. Alana, alone in a room, finds a small, sharp object—a potential weapon, or maybe just a tool for escape. She picks it up, turns it over in her hands, and for a few seconds, the camera lingers on her face. There’s no music. No dialogue. Just her expression: fear, calculation, resolve. It’s a tiny moment, but it’s the kind of quiet beat that horror films often rush past in favor of the next scare. Here, it’s given room to breathe.
That’s the paradox of Monster. When it works, it’s because it forces you to sit with the horror, to feel it in a way that most films don’t allow. But when it doesn’t work, it’s because the silence starts to feel like a cage—not just for the characters, but for the audience.
I admire Monster for its ambition. It’s a film that takes risks, and even when those risks don’t pay off, they make it more interesting than most of the cookie-cutter horror that clogs up streaming queues. The performances are strong, the cinematography is effective, and there are moments of genuine tension that will leave you holding your breath.
But the lack of dialogue is a double-edged sword. It elevates the film in some scenes and undermines it in others. By the end, I was left with a question: Was the silence a necessary part of the story, or just a stylistic flourish? I’m not sure the film ever answers that.
What I am sure of is this: Monster isn’t an easy watch. It’s not a film you put on to unwind after a long day. It’s a film that demands your attention, that forces you to engage with its silence rather than just let it wash over you.
And in a genre that often prioritizes shock over substance, that’s something worth paying attention to.
Even if it doesn’t always work.

Rako Prijanto’s Monster (2023) is already turning heads—not for what it says, but for what it doesn’t. The Indonesian horror-thriller, a remake of the 2020 film The Boy Behind the Door, takes a bold gamble: it unfolds entirely without dialogue. That’s right—no spoken lines, no monologues, not even a whispered plea for help. Just two friends, Alana and Rabin, latestnetflix.com argues, fighting for their lives against a relentless predator.
The decision to strip Monster of dialogue is the kind of creative risk that could either redefine tension or leave audiences scratching their heads. According to snippets from Wikipedia and Wikiwand, the screenplay was penned by Alim Sudio, who presumably relied on visual storytelling, sound design, and raw performances to carry the narrative. The film stars Anantya Kirana and Sulthan Hamonangan as the kidnapped duo, with Marsha Timothy and Alex Abbad rounding out the cast.
But why go silent? Horror has a long history of using minimalism to amplify fear—think A Quiet Place (2018) or The Blair Witch Project (1999). Yet those films still used some dialogue. Monster’s approach is more extreme, leaning entirely on atmosphere, cinematography, and the actors’ ability to convey terror through expressions and body language. If the snippets are any indication, this could be a masterclass in suspense—or a test of how much audiences are willing to endure without a single line of exposition.
Monster isn’t an original story. It’s a remake of The Boy Behind the Door (2020), a critically praised horror-thriller about two boys trapped in a house with a kidnapper. The original film relied on sharp dialogue and psychological tension, making Monster’s silent approach even more intriguing. Did Prijanto and Sudio believe the story could stand on its own without words, or was this a deliberate subversion of the source material? The evidence doesn’t say, but the choice raises questions about how much of the original’s DNA remains.
The cast and crew are tight-lipped about the film’s production, at least based on the available snippets. IMDb lists the full credits, but there’s no word on filming challenges, on-set accidents, or whether the actors had to develop a new kind of physical acting language to compensate for the lack of dialogue. Rumors about reshoots or creative disagreements? None in the evidence. For now, Monster remains a mystery wrapped in a silent scream.
Horror fans love a gimmick, but silence is a high-stakes one. If Monster succeeds, it could inspire a wave of dialogue-free thrillers. If it flops, it might be remembered as a noble experiment that missed the mark. Either way, Prijanto’s film is already a talking point—ironic, given that no one in it says a word.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.