
Billy Bob Thornton
Morris Buttermaker

“Baseball has rules. Meet the exceptions.”
Morris Buttermaker is a burned-out minor league baseball player who loves to drink and can't keep his hands to himself. His long-suffering lawyer arranges for him to manage a local Little League team, and Buttermaker soon finds himself the head of a rag-tag group of misfit players. Through unconventional team-building exercises and his offbeat coaching style, Buttermaker helps his hapless Bears prepare to meet their rivals, the Yankees.
Official
The original Bad News Bears (1976) let a team of misfits be foul-mouthed and unapologetically chaotic, and it felt like a secret handshake. It didn't just poke at the saccharine underdog tropes of Little League movies; it set them on fire. So when Richard Linklater's 2005 remake arrived, it was fair to brace for disappointment.
Not because remakes are inherently bad, but because the original's grime felt untouchable. Could a film this irreverent survive being scrubbed clean for a new era?
Linklater, who has spent his career on the quiet rebellions of everyday life, from the teenagers of Dazed and Confused to the philosophical meanderings of Before Sunrise, seems an odd fit for a sports comedy. Then again, his films often follow outsiders stumbling toward something like grace, and Bad News Bears is a story about redemption through failure. The problem is the execution.
This remake wants to have its beer and drink it too: crude enough to feel edgy, sentimental enough to pass as family-friendly. It stumbles between tones like a drunk navigating a basepath.

Billy Bob Thornton's Morris Buttermaker is, predictably, the anchor. Thornton has made a career of men who are equal parts charismatic and catastrophically flawed, and Buttermaker, a washed-up former major-league pitcher turned alcoholic exterminator, paid to coach the Bears, is no exception. Thornton inhabits him, slouched in the dugout, squinting at the world through a haze of cheap beer and regret.
When he's introduced to the team, his whole demeanor screams, What fresh hell is this? Thornton could sleepwalk through scenes like that and still make them compelling. The film around him struggles to keep up.
The kids are a mixed bag. Sammi Kane Kraft, as Amanda Whurlitzer, the team's lone girl and best pitcher, has a natural charisma that cuts through the juvenile humor. She's the closest thing the Bears have to a moral center, though the script gives her little beyond glaring at teammates and throwing fastballs.
The rest of the team is a parade of stereotypes: the kid who eats constantly, the hyperactive wiseass, the shy one who never speaks. The original leaned on archetypes too, but here they feel like placeholders. The raunchy gags (a kid hit in the groin by a baseball, another chugging beer) land with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer, and it's hard to tell whether we're laughing with these kids or at them.

The tonal whiplash is the biggest hurdle. One minute it's a crude comedy about kids saying things no actual Little Leaguer would; the next it's a heartfelt underdog story about teamwork and self-worth. Linklater's signature naturalism, his gift for lived-in, spontaneous dialogue, is mostly absent.
The script by Glenn Ficarra and John Requa (who also wrote Bad Santa) often seems to be forcing the original's anarchic energy into a conventional mold. It isn't raunchy enough to commit to its crassness, nor sentimental enough to sell its emotional beats.
Some moments work. The best comes late, in the championship game against the Yankees (of course the rival team is the Yankees). Buttermaker, realizing he's become as win-obsessed as the coach across the field, puts his benchwarmers in, and Thornton sells the turn with weary authenticity.
The Bears don't transform into a well-oiled machine, and they don't pull off a last-minute miracle. They lose. It's a small victory for realism, even if the rest of the film doesn't know what to do with it.

The reception reflected the unevenness: Thornton was widely singled out, while the humor struck many as dated and the heart as forced. The film isn't bad so much as confused, trying to be a raunchy comedy, a sentimental sports flick, and a character study at once.
The 2005 Bad News Bears feels like a relic of a time when Hollywood remade anything with a whiff of nostalgia. The original's charm lay in its unapologetic messiness, its willingness to let its characters be unlikeable. This version, for all its attempts to modernize the story, plays it safe.
It isn't offensive, just forgettable.
"A decent but forgettable remake that struggles to capture the charm of the original, despite Billy Bob Thornton’s solid performance."
Billy Bob Thornton’s gruff but endearing coach gives the film some authenticity. The remake lacks the heart and humor of the 1976 classic, though, often coming across as too polished or sanitized. The young cast is hit-or-miss, with a few standout moments but little to make the characters memorable.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Richard Linklater’s 2005 remake of The Bad News Bears swapped the original’s slapstick charm for a grittier, more cynical tone—one that mirrored its star, Billy Bob Thornton. The film, a loose update of the 1976 Walter Matthau classic, followed a ragtag Little League team coached by Thornton’s hard-drinking, foul-mouthed Morris Buttermaker. While the remake didn’t set the box office on fire, it carved out its own niche, latestnetflix.com argues, thanks in part to Thornton’s unapologetic performance and Linklater’s knack for naturalistic storytelling.
Billy Bob Thornton didn’t just play Morris Buttermaker—he was Buttermaker. The actor, known for his darkly comedic roles in films like Sling Blade and Bad Santa, brought a raw, unfiltered energy to the character. In interviews, Thornton hinted that the role resonated with his own experiences growing up in rural Arkansas, where sports and rough-around-the-edges mentors were part of the fabric of life. His portrayal leaned into the character’s flaws—alcoholism, laziness, and a refusal to sugarcoat the game—making Buttermaker a far cry from Walter Matthau’s lovable curmudgeon in the original.
The film’s tone reflected Thornton’s influence. Linklater, best known for dialogue-driven films like Dazed and Confused and Before Sunrise, embraced a more grounded, less sentimental approach to the story. The result was a baseball movie that felt less like a family comedy and more like a character study of failure and redemption.
The young actors who played the Bears—Sammi Kane Kraft, Ridge Canipe, Brandon Craggs, and the rest—delivered surprisingly sharp performances, holding their own against Thornton and Greg Kinnear (who played the rival coach, Roy Bullock). But their post-Bears careers took wildly different paths.
The film’s child actors were never groomed for stardom, but their chemistry on screen was undeniable. In retrospect, their performances feel like a snapshot of a moment when they were just kids playing a game—both on and off the field.
The 2005 Bad News Bears was always going to be compared to the 1976 original, and the comparisons weren’t always kind. Critics and audiences were split: some appreciated the darker, more realistic take, while others missed the original’s heart and humor. Rotten Tomatoes gave it a lukewarm 48% score, with reviews noting that Thornton’s Buttermaker was compelling but the film lacked the warmth of its predecessor.
That said, the remake found its defenders. Linklater’s direction and Thornton’s performance gave it a cult following over time, with some arguing it was a more honest portrayal of childhood and competition. The film’s rating on SensCritique (5.7/10) suggests it’s a polarizing but enduring entry in the sports-comedy genre.
Nearly 20 years later, the 2005 Bad News Bears remains a curiosity—a remake that dared to be different. It wasn’t a box office smash, nor did it spawn a franchise, but it carved out its own identity. Thornton’s Buttermaker is now a cult favorite, and the film’s unvarnished look at childhood, failure, and redemption feels more relevant than ever.
For fans of Linklater’s work, it’s a fascinating detour—a rare foray into mainstream comedy from a director known for indie dramas. And for those who grew up with the original, it’s a reminder that sometimes, the bad news isn’t so bad after all.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.