Skip to main content
Movie poster for Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie (2017)

Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie

2017
1h 21m
16 · English
Director: Jeff Garlin
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

LA homicide detective Gene Handsome's knack for solving mysteries is matched only by his inability to make sense of his own problems.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Detective Who Couldn’t Detect Himself

I’ll admit it: I went into Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie expecting a joke. Not a good one, necessarily, but at least a clear punchline. The title alone—Handsome—felt like a wink, a promise that whatever followed would be self-aware enough to poke fun at its own premise.

And in a way, it is. But what I didn’t expect was how much the film’s central tension would mirror its own existence: a detective who’s brilliant at solving crimes but utterly clueless about his own life, trapped in a story that’s clever enough to know it’s slight but not quite bold enough to transcend it.

Jeff Garlin, who directs and stars as Gene Handsome, has built a career on playing men who are lovable in their incompetence—Murray Goldberg on The Goldbergs, Jeff Greene on Curb Your Enthusiasm. Here, he leans into that archetype, but with a twist: Gene isn’t just hapless; he’s a genuine detective, one who stumbles into solving a murder while his personal life crumbles around him.

The disconnect is the film’s engine. How can a man so perceptive about clues—blood spatter, alibis, the telltale lipstick on a coffee cup—be so oblivious to the fact that his girlfriend is cheating on him, his career is stagnant, and his apartment looks like it was decorated by a man who gave up in 1998?

A cluttered detective’s desk, strewn with case files, takeout containers, and a half-empty bottle of whiskey, while Gene Handsome stares blankly at a crime scene photo.

That question—why are we so good at seeing others’ problems and so terrible at seeing our own?—is the closest Handsome gets to depth. It’s not a profound film, but it’s not trying to be. What it is trying to be is a comedy, and in that, it’s uneven.

The murder mystery at its core is serviceable, a lightweight riff on noir tropes with a modern, self-deprecating edge. The victim is a yoga instructor (played by Ava Acres, who steals every scene she’s in), and the suspects include a washed-up actor (Steven Weber), a hyper-competent rival detective (Leah Remini, who seems to be having the most fun), and a motormouthed neighbor (Amy Sedaris, because of course).

The plot chugs along with the efficiency of a TV procedural, but the real pleasure isn’t in the whodunit—it’s in the detours.

Take the scene where Gene interrogates a suspect in a diner. The camera lingers on the man’s face as he nervously stirs his coffee, the spoon clinking against the mug like a metronome counting down to a lie. Gene, meanwhile, is more interested in his pancakes, cutting them into precise squares before shoveling them into his mouth.

The humor isn’t in the dialogue—it’s in the contrast. Here’s a man who notices everything except the thing right in front of him. The scene doesn’t land with a punchline; it lands with a shrug, a quiet acknowledgment that life is full of details we choose to ignore.

Gene Handsome, mid-bite into a pancake, eyes glazed over as a suspect nervously fidgets across the diner booth.

Garlin’s direction is unshowy, almost to a fault. There are no flashy tracking shots or elaborate set pieces, just a straightforward, workmanlike approach that mirrors Gene’s own methodical (if distracted) detective work. The film’s visual palette is muted—lots of beiges and browns, the colors of a man who’s given up on aesthetics.

Even the murder scenes feel oddly bloodless, as if the film itself is too polite to linger on the violence. It’s not that Handsome is afraid of gore; it’s that it’s more interested in the idea of a murder than the act itself. The real mystery isn’t who killed the yoga instructor—it’s why anyone would care about Gene Handsome in the first place.

And that’s where the film’s biggest flaw lies. Gene is a cipher. We know he’s a good detective because the plot tells us so, but we never see it.

His personal life is a mess, but the film doesn’t give us enough glimpses into his interiority to make us root for him. He’s more of a vessel for the joke than a fully realized character. Natasha Lyonne, as his exasperated love interest, fares better—her scenes crackle with the kind of lived-in frustration that suggests she’s been dealing with Gene’s nonsense for far too long.

But even she’s given little to do beyond react to his cluelessness.

The supporting cast is where Handsome shines. Amy Sedaris, as always, is a delight, playing a neighbor who’s equal parts nosy and oblivious. Eddie Pepitone shows up as a bartender with the weary patience of a man who’s seen too many detectives drown their sorrows in cheap whiskey.

And Timm Sharp, as Gene’s put-upon partner, has a great moment where he deadpans, “I don’t know why I keep expecting you to change,” a line that could double as the film’s thesis statement.

Gene Handsome and his partner stand in a dimly lit alley, the partner looking exasperated while Gene stares blankly into the distance.

If Handsome has a saving grace, it’s that it never overstays its welcome. At 81 minutes, it’s the cinematic equivalent of a quick coffee break—easy to consume, not particularly memorable, but not actively unpleasant. It’s the kind of movie that’s hard to hate but just as hard to love.

Garlin’s direction is competent, his performance is fine, and the jokes land often enough to keep you watching. But it’s also the kind of film that makes you wonder what it could have been if it had taken a few more risks.

There’s a moment near the end where Gene, having solved the case, sits alone in his apartment, staring at the wall. The camera holds on him for a beat too long, as if waiting for him to say something profound. He doesn’t.

He just sighs, gets up, and walks out of frame. It’s a small moment, but it’s the most honest one in the film. Sometimes, the mystery isn’t who committed the crime—it’s what we’re supposed to do with ourselves once the case is closed.

Handsome doesn’t have an answer to that question. But then again, neither does Gene. And maybe that’s the point.

Audience Opinions

Limited evidence
Audience 4.3/10
"A lightweight comedy-mystery that fails to combine humor and plot and leaves little impression."

The comedic tone and Jeff Garlin’s lead performance are occasionally amusing, but the mystery elements are underdeveloped and much of the humor falls flat. The runtime is short, yet the pacing and lack of depth make it feel longer. It doesn’t live up to its potential as a Netflix original.

What viewers praise
  • Jeff Garlin’s performance Garlin’s comedic timing and presence are the standout elements, providing moments of genuine amusement.
  • Short runtime At 81 minutes, the film doesn’t overstay its welcome.
Common complaints
  • Weak mystery plot The central mystery lacks depth and originality and wastes the premise.
  • Unfunny humor Much of the comedy misses the mark, with jokes that feel forced or predictable rather than clever.
  • Thin character development Supporting characters, including Natasha Lyonne and Leah Remini, are underused and lack depth.
Recommended for
Jeff Garlin fans Lightweight comedy seekers Casual Netflix viewers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Jeff Garlin’s Directorial Debut: The Low-Key Charm of Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie

Jeff Garlin has spent decades making audiences laugh—first as a stand-up, then as the lovable, bumbling Murray Goldberg on The Goldbergs and the deadpan Larry David foil on Curb Your Enthusiasm. But in 2017, he stepped behind the camera for his first feature film, Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie, a quirky whodunit that leaned into his signature comedic style. The result? latestnetflix.com's read is that a modest, offbeat flick that flew under the radar but offered a glimpse into Garlin’s vision as a filmmaker.

A Star-Studded Cast, But No Blockbuster Buzz

Handsome assembled a solid ensemble, including Natasha Lyonne (Orange Is the New Black), Leah Remini (The King of Queens), and Amy Sedaris (Strangers with Candy). Yet despite the talent, the movie didn’t generate the kind of hype Netflix often commands. Reviews were mixed, with one critic calling it a "lightweight comedy" that "doesn’t quite deliver on its mystery premise". The film’s 4.3/10 rating on SensCritique suggests it wasn’t a runaway hit, though its 81-minute runtime made it an easy watch for fans of Garlin’s brand of humor.

Garlin himself played the lead role—a scruffy, down-on-his-luck detective named Gene Handsome, whose name alone set the tone for the movie’s self-aware silliness. The trailer teased a murder mystery with a comedic twist, promising a blend of noir tropes and Garlin’s signature awkward charm. But did it live up to the hype? Judging by the sparse online chatter, Handsome was more of a quiet experiment than a breakout success.

Behind the Scenes: Garlin’s Directorial Gamble

Garlin’s transition from actor to director wasn’t entirely surprising—he’d already directed episodes of Curb Your Enthusiasm and his own stand-up specials. But Handsome marked his first foray into feature filmmaking, and he seemed eager to embrace the challenge. In a brief interview clip, Garlin described the movie as a "love letter to detective films," though he admitted it was "a little different" from the usual Netflix fare.

The film’s production details remain scarce, but its Netflix Original status suggests the streaming giant saw potential in Garlin’s vision. Still, with no major press tour or critical fanfare, Handsome felt like a passion project rather than a calculated blockbuster. Rumor has it that Garlin wrote the script himself, though no official confirmation exists in the available evidence.

A Cult Following or a Forgotten Experiment?

Years after its release, Handsome hasn’t exactly become a cult classic. YouTube reviews range from lukewarm to dismissive, with one calling it "a watchable but forgettable comedy". Yet for fans of Garlin’s work, the movie offers a fun, if minor, addition to his filmography.

The biggest takeaway? Handsome was a low-stakes gamble—a chance for Garlin to flex his creative muscles without the pressure of a major theatrical release. Whether it was a misfire or a hidden gem depends on who you ask. But for a first-time director, it’s not a bad start.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.