Skip to main content
Movie poster for Joan Didion: The Center Will Not Hold (2017)

Joan Didion: The Center Will Not Hold

2017
1h 32m
PG-13 · English
Director: Griffin Dunne
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Literary icon Joan Didion reflects on her remarkable career and personal struggles in this intimate documentary directed by her nephew, Griffin Dunne.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The woman who wrote the earthquake

I have watched Joan Didion: The Center Will Not Hold three times now, and each time I am struck by how little the film actually shows. The omissions follow Didion's own method. The worst truths sit just outside the frame.

Griffin Dunne, her nephew and the director, understands that. He does not explain her. He lets her sit there, Sacramento drawl, smoking, thinking, laughing at her own memories as if they belong to someone else.

Dunne refuses hagiography. What you get is a portrait of a mind that spent a lifetime watching the world so closely that watching became a way to survive.

Joan Didion in her New York apartment, bathed in soft light, her hands folded in her lap as she speaks to the camera.

The film's real asset is access. Dunne has her in the room. The woman who wrote Slouching Towards Bethlehem while chain-smoking in a rented Hollywood apartment, who kept a notebook in her purse because she believed that "we tell ourselves stories in order to live."

Early on she describes her first job at Vogue in the 1950s, typing captions for photos of debutantes. Wry amusement, as if she is still surprised by the distance. Then the camera lingers on her hands.

Thin, veined, slightly trembling. The career story is a cover. She is talking about time, how fast it goes, how little control we have.

That trembling matters. You see it in how she holds a cigarette, how she pauses before answering, how she sometimes seems to listen to a voice only she can hear. Dunne leaves it unnamed. So does she. The body keeps interrupting the story she has built of herself. She would have put that in a notebook.

The film's structure is loose, almost meandering. Some viewers call that a flaw. I think it is the method.

Didion's essays do not walk a straight line. They circle, digress, return to the same image from another angle. The documentary does that too.

Childhood in Sacramento. Years in New York. Marriage to John Gregory Dunne.

The deaths of her husband and her daughter, Quintana. No strict chronology, no neat arc. Layers until you have something like the truth, the kind Didion might have written.

Fragmented, precise, and hard to shake.

One of the strongest sequences is her reading from The Year of Magical Thinking, the memoir about the year after her husband's sudden death. The camera stays on her face. "Life changes fast.

Life changes in the instant. You sit down to dinner and life as you know it ends." Her voice does not break.

She does not cry. She keeps reading, eyes on some point beyond the camera, as if she is seeing the ambulance, the hospital, the empty apartment again. It is hard to sit through.

There is also something clinical in it, grief treated like a specimen. She makes personal pain feel general by looking at it with the same ruthless clarity she brings to everything else.

A close-up of Joan Didion's face as she reads from her work, her expression unreadable, her eyes focused somewhere beyond the camera.

The film's real weakness is its gentleness. Dunne clearly adores his aunt. The documentary is soaked in that affection.

There are moments you wish he had pushed, asked the questions that might have made her uncomfortable. Her work is full of contradictions. Cool detachment masking deep emotion.

A fascination with chaos paired with a need for control. A feminist icon who once wrote that women who don't marry are "doomed to a life of loneliness and despair." The film touches these things.

It does not dig. He is so in awe of her that he cannot challenge her, even when the material asks for it.

I came around to that gentleness, at least partway. Didion spent her life observing other people, cutting into their motives, their fears, their illusions. This is one of the few times she is the subject.

Fair that the film treats her with the care she gave her own subjects, even when that care slides toward reverence.

Near the end she is asked what she thinks happens when we die. She pauses. "I don't know.

I don't think about it." A Didion answer. Evasive, honest, a little defiant.

Then, almost as an afterthought, "I think about the people I've lost." That is the key to the work. The people we have lost.

The stories we tell to make sense of the hole. The way the world keeps moving when it feels like it should stop. The center does not hold.

The writing does. In its own quiet way, so does this film.

Audience Opinions

Audience 7.7/10
"An intimate, melancholic portrait that captures Joan Didion’s voice and grief with great affection, but stops short of a searching, critical biography."

The film is strongest when it puts Didion herself at the center: her presence, speaking voice, and razor‑sharp prose inspire strong emotional reactions and often send people back to her books or into their own writing. The mood is mournful yet beautiful, with close, familial access that makes her feel both legendary and vulnerable. At the same time, the documentary is structurally loose, overly gentle, and somewhat sanitized—it wants to be longer, more rigorously organized, and more critical about her life and work.

What viewers praise
  • Intimate access to Didion The close relationship between subject and director creates a tender, personal view of Didion that feels like being invited into her private world.
  • Powerful on-screen presence Her manner of speaking, gestures, and intelligence are riveting enough that it is easy to want hours more of just listening to her talk.
  • Emotional impact of grief Scenes dealing with the deaths of her husband and daughter are devastating yet illuminating in how precisely she articulates loss.
  • Inspiration to read and write It leaves people eager to explore more of her essays and newly motivated to write or rethink their own lives.
  • Melancholic, beautiful tone The overall atmosphere is quietly sorrowful, thoughtful, and aesthetically pleasing in a way that matches Didion’s sensibility.
Common complaints
  • Soft, uncritical approach The portrait is a loving family story that rarely interrogates Didion or her legacy, leaving a more probing perspective unexplored.
  • Loose, rambling structure The film’s flow can feel meandering, wanting stronger narrative organization and clearer biographical framing.
  • Limited depth and detail It only skims the surface of a long, complex life and would benefit from a longer, more detailed exploration.
  • Narrow focus in places Certain elements, such as the emphasis on her husband, make it feel at times like the story drifts away from Didion herself.
Recommended for
Joan Didion readers Literary documentary lovers Intimate biographical portraits Slow, reflective non-fiction American culture and politics buffs

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

“The Center Will Not Hold” — But the Tea Absolutely Will

Joan Didion may have perfected the art of cool detachment, but the story behind Joan Didion: The Center Will Not Hold is anything but chilly. Between record-breaking ovations, secret health struggles, Kickstarter drama, and one very complicated Hollywood sex-life footnote, latestnetflix.com argues, this “quiet” literary doc is sitting on enough gossip to fill its own New Journalism anthology.


On-Set Drama & Editing Nightmares

  • Griffin Dunne didn’t just make a documentary; he birthed an epic. His first cut ran over three hours, a beast so long he openly admits he’d “never have shown a film that long to Netflix”. Instead, he used it as a private test run for the only critic who mattered: Aunt Joan. - The screening was pure DIY prestige cinema: a laptop and two speakers on Didion’s dining room table, her dog Ellie nearby, and time codes ready so she could flag anything that bothered her. They plotted a bathroom break at the halfway mark, but when the film hit the section about the sudden death of her husband John Gregory Dunne, Joan began to cry—and still insisted they keep going. Ice queen? Absolutely not.

Family Secrets & Silent Struggles

  • While the world was swooning over this “fond and appreciative portrait,” almost nobody knew that Didion had been diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease during the shoot, a fact kept tightly inside her inner circle at the time. - That secret made one festival moment even more dramatic: at the New York Film Festival 2017 premiere, the movie received a seven‑minute standing ovation, which Griffin says was the longest ovation in the festival’s history. He wasn’t just basking in glory—he was panicking about getting his frail aunt to her feet without her falling. Didion’s reaction: a curt, immortal command—“Get me up!”.

Kickstarter Chaos & Merch Controversy

  • Before Netflix money smoothed things out, this was a full‑blown crowdfunded passion project. The campaign for what was then called We Tell Ourselves Stories in Order to Live asked for $80,000—and ended up scoring $221,135 from 3,565 backers, nearly triple the goal. - How do you raise that much for a literary doc? You raid the Joan Didion archive. Rewards included a digital copy of her recipe book and—most controversially—a pair of her actual iconic sunglasses for $2,500. Some observers “found fault” with auctioning off Didion’s personal effects to fans, raising eyebrows about turning a legendary writer’s life into high-end swag. - The campaign promised a who’s-who of talking heads—Patti Smith, Graydon Carter, Bret Easton Ellis among them —cementing the project as the ultimate insiders-only Joan club.

Romance, Scandals & Hollywood Crossovers

  • The Dunne–Didion clan’s orbit is pure Hollywood soap. Exhibit A: Carrie Fisher lost her virginity to Griffin Dunne, as he cheerfully told Page Six in 2024. According to Griffin, Fisher had a boyfriend and “didn’t want him to know she was a virgin,” so she “trusted” Griffin to handle the situation for her. It’s not directly about the doc, but it’s the kind of messy, intimate history that colors every “respectable” frame of The Center Will Not Hold. - Then there’s the greatest bit of casting backstory never technically billed as casting: for years before he was Han Solo, Harrison Ford was Joan Didion’s handyman—literally fixing things around her house. That tidbit, resurfacing in coverage around the documentary’s release, turned a whole generation of fans into instant Didion stans: of course the woman who foresaw the collapse of the American dream once had Indiana Jones fixing her cabinets.

Leaks, Fan Gripes & What Got Cut

  • Dunne freely admits he started with that massive three‑hour cut and then whittled it down for Netflix. Producer Annabelle Dunne has confirmed that Joan saw both the long rough cut and later, shorter versions, meaning there’s a hidden four‑quart container of Didion footage sitting somewhere in an edit suite. No specific deleted scenes have leaked, but fans know there’s more. - On Reddit, some viewers grumbled that the finished film feels “geared towards her husband”, focusing on John Gregory Dunne almost as if it were his documentary rather than Joan’s. That’s fan commentary, not industry scoop—but it’s become a recurring complaint in online chatter about the movie.

Wild Trivia & Emotional Mic Drops

  • The Alta Journal profile of the film details how the whole thing began as a **simple promo video for Blue Nights in 2011—Didion’s book about the death of her daughter, Quintana. When Griffin suggested expanding it into a full documentary, Joan’s response was a cool, almost suspicious “OK, fine”. - Production was emotionally brutal. During the process, Nora Ephron—Didion’s friend and fellow legend—died, a blow that rattled Didion and the crew and contributed to the project’s long, six‑year gestation from “pipe dream” to Netflix premiere. - The most devastating review came from the subject herself. After watching that long early cut at her dining table, eyes full of tears, Didion simply took Griffin’s hand and said: “Thank you.”** In the gossip world, that’s the equivalent of a 10/10 on Rotten Tomatoes.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.