
Ralph Fiennes
David Henninger

“Everything must be faced.”
Over a weekend in the High Atlas Mountains of Morocco, a random accident reverberates through the lives of both the local Muslims and Western visitors to a house party in a grand villa.
Official
I kept waiting for the moment when The Forgiven would stop explaining itself and just be. That moment never came. What we get instead is a film that knows exactly what it wants to say—about guilt, privilege, the weight of a single life—but can’t resist the urge to say it again, louder, with more wine and more wind machines.
John Michael McDonagh’s drama unfolds over a single weekend in the High Atlas Mountains, where a group of wealthy Westerners have gathered for a debauched house party. The host, David Henninger (Ralph Fiennes), is a man who has spent his life collecting beautiful things, including his wife Jo (Jessica Chastain), who tolerates him with the weary patience of someone who has long since stopped expecting better.
On the way to the villa, David hits and kills a local teenager with his car. The boy’s father, Abdellah (Ismael Kanater), arrives at the party the next morning, demanding David return with him to the village to face justice—or at least, to face the body.
It’s a premise that should crackle with tension, but McDonagh’s script keeps smothering the fire with layers of dialogue. The Western characters talk and talk and talk, their conversations laced with the kind of brittle wit that feels less like natural speech and more like a playwright’s idea of how clever people sound when they’re drunk. (There’s a reason McDonagh’s previous films, The Guard and Calvary, worked better—they had the decency to be funny.) Here, the satire of rich, self-satisfied liberals feels half-hearted, as if the film is afraid to fully commit to mocking them, even as it clearly disdains them.

Fiennes, though, is mesmerizing. David is a man who has spent his life constructing a persona—charming, erudite, effortlessly superior—and Fiennes plays him like a man who has forgotten he’s wearing a mask. There’s a moment early on, when David first realizes what he’s done, where his face goes slack, his mouth slightly open, as if he’s just been told a joke he doesn’t understand.
It’s the kind of small, human detail that makes the rest of the film’s grand gestures feel even more hollow by comparison. Chastain, too, is excellent, though her role is more reactive—Jo is the audience’s surrogate, watching David’s unraveling with a mix of horror and resignation. But the film keeps cutting away from her, as if it’s afraid to linger too long on a woman who might actually have something to say.
The real energy comes from the supporting cast, particularly Matt Smith and Caleb Landry Jones as a bickering gay couple whose relationship is equal parts affection and mutual disdain. Their scenes together crackle with a lived-in chemistry that the rest of the film lacks. Smith, in particular, steals every moment he’s in, his Richard a man who has weaponized charm to the point where even his insults sound like compliments.
When he turns to David and says, “You’re not a monster, you’re just a cunt,” it’s the first time the film’s dialogue feels like it’s actually cutting to the bone.

The film’s most striking sequence comes when David finally accompanies Abdellah back to the village. The desert here is vast and indifferent, the camera lingering on the empty landscape as if to remind us that none of this—neither David’s guilt nor Abdellah’s grief—matters to the world at large. The two men barely speak, and when they do, it’s in halting, stilted exchanges that feel more honest than anything that came before.
There’s a quiet power in these scenes, a sense that the film has finally stopped trying to impress us and is just letting the weight of the moment settle in.
But then, inevitably, the film undercuts itself. The ending is abrupt, almost perfunctory, as if McDonagh couldn’t decide whether to let David face real consequences or give him an easy out. (I won’t spoil it, but suffice to say, it feels like a cop-out.) The problem isn’t that the film is ambiguous—ambiguity can be powerful—but that it doesn’t earn its ambiguity.
It wants to have it both ways: to condemn David’s privilege while also letting him off the hook, to critique the Western gaze while still centering the Western experience.

There’s a telling moment early in the film when one of the guests, a washed-up actor, drunkenly declares that he’s “not a tourist, I’m a traveler.” It’s the kind of line that’s meant to sound profound but lands with a thud, because we’ve all heard it before—from people who think they’re deeper than they are. The Forgiven suffers from a similar affliction. It wants to be a serious meditation on guilt and forgiveness, but it can’t resist the urge to dress up its ideas in fancy dialogue and pretty cinematography. The result is a film that’s often beautiful to look at but rarely feels truly alive.
That’s not to say it’s without merit. The performances, particularly Fiennes’, are worth the price of admission, and there are moments—brief, fleeting—where the film’s ambition shines through. But ambition alone isn’t enough. The Forgiven is a film that knows what it wants to say but doesn’t trust its audience to understand it without a lot of hand-holding.
And in the end, that lack of trust is its own kind of privilege.
"Strong performances and striking Moroccan visuals power a morally charged drama whose slow pacing and uneven satire leave viewers divided."
Ralph Fiennes earns praise for a layered performance; Matt Smith and Caleb Landry Jones also stand out, and desert scenery and lighting are a visual highlight. Guilt, privilege, and colonial-era attitudes feel ambitious and thought-provoking, but heavy, sometimes pretentious dialogue and a sluggish rhythm keep the tension from fully landing. Dark comedy and class satire often feel awkward or half-baked—a mixed impression even from those who respect the ambition.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Jessica Chastain told The List she finished The Forgiven on 10 March 2020, flew home, and watched the United States lock down on the 12th. Ralph Fiennes still had the Morocco miles. "Ralph had the most difficult moments on set being in the desert," she said. "I got to drink cocktails and dance." Then the dates. latestnetflix.com's take is that "I finished on March 10, 2020, flew to the United States, and the lockdown started in the United States on March 12.Ralph still had to do all the stuff in the desert."
John Michael McDonagh had announced the film at Cannes in 2018 with a different living room. Rebecca Hall and Mark Strong were attached next to Fiennes and Said Taghmaoui. By December 2019 Chastain was in talks. Cameras rolled in Morocco that February. Screen Daily reported the halt in March. Producers chartered planes to get people out. Six months later they went back. Deadline said Focus Features bought the world outside North America once the cameras finally stopped. McDonagh, launching House of Un-American Activities with this picture, thanked a crew that worked "with masks or without." Producer Elizabeth Eves was blunter. "Like the landscape of Morocco where we shot, the making of this film has been both spectacular and hostile.",,
This is not Roland Joffe's 2018 The Forgiven, the Desmond Tutu picture. McDonagh's version is Lawrence Osborne's 2012 novel, a drunk London doctor and his wife who hit a boy on the way to someone else's High Atlas party. Matt Smith hosts. Christopher Abbott, Caleb Landry Jones, Abbey Lee, Ismael Kanater, Marie-Josee Croze, Alex Jennings drink in the villa. Fiennes and Chastain had already done Coriolanus together. This time the marriage is the wreck, and the shoot split the same way the plot does. She leaves. He stays in the sand.,
Toronto got it on 11 September 2021. Roadside Attractions and Vertical opened the United States on 1 July 2022. The first weekend took $135,476 from 125 theaters. Worldwide the tally sat around $1.4 million. Critics split. Variety's Peter Debruge wrote that the film was "undeniably wicked yet deliciously prickly" and that "McDonagh loves his monsters." Rotten Tomatoes landed at 68 percent. The official trailer sells the heat and the cover-up, not the last mile.,,
Then the movie found the place most desert morality plays end up. Netflix. A starry eat-the-rich weekend that theaters barely noticed now sits next to people browsing for Fiennes or Chastain on a Tuesday. The gossip is the shoot, not the sermon. A pandemic cut the couple's work in two. The wife flew home. The husband stayed. The film about unforgiven Westerners almost did not finish.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.