
Pol Monen
Eze

On their last night together, four longtime flatmates' lives are suddenly upended when a secret is revealed during the course of an evening celebration.
Official
I get wary when a film locks everyone in one room and calls it a night. The trap is either real pressure or a stage play that forgot it had a camera. Who Would You Take to a Deserted Island? (2019) puts four longtime flatmates in a Madrid apartment on the last evening before one of them moves out. The English title sounds like a party game.
Jota Linares is not interested in who you would pack for a shipwreck. He is interested in who you would trust with the version of yourself you usually hide, and whether that person is even in the room.
The night starts easy. Drinks, music, the shorthand of shared rent and old jokes. Then a secret comes out without soap-opera fireworks, more like a glass sliding off wet fingers.
The apartment stops being a home and becomes a box. The Spanish title, ¿A quién te llevarías a una isla desierta?, asks the same question with the fun already gone. Who here gets your most exposed self.
Who would you even want to.

SensCritique has the film at 4.7/10. That number usually means a movie that never found its people, or never earned them. I think the score undersells a small, specific drama that was never going to travel like a prestige export.
It is not a perfect night. The second act wobbles. A few emotional turns arrive with the lights already on.
Still, certain lines sit in your head afterward the way a real argument does.
The cast will look familiar if you have been watching Spanish television's recent prestige run. Jaime Lorente (Money Heist, Elite) plays Marcos, the one who is leaving. He is not the loudest person in the apartment.
When he talks, the others try to listen. María Pedraza (Elite, Toy Boy) plays his girlfriend, warm until she is not, then guarded in a way that feels practiced. Pol Monen is Álex, the flatmate whose secret detonates the night, and he is the one I kept watching.
His face is easy to read, which here is a feature. Halfway through he sits on the couch folded in on himself like a question mark. You can see the weight without a speech.
Linares is willing to stay in the discomfort. No grand gesture ties the night in a bow. The camera stays handheld, almost like a documentary, so the rooms feel lived in and too small.
Lighting does a lot of the arguing. Fairy lights, then the kitchen fluorescents, where the worst conversations happen. You can nearly smell the spilled wine and the takeout.
The fridge hums like a clock.

The one-night, one-location bet is also the film's problem. Every beat has to land or the whole thing starts reciting itself. A few lines sound like thoughts that should have stayed unspoken, the kind of exposition people do not actually say while pouring another drink.
Those are small sins. What the movie lacks in polish it tries to make up in honesty. It does not dazzle.
It trusts the rawness of the fight.
What stayed with me was not the secret, not the fight, and not a tidy last shot, because Linares does not offer one. It is how quickly people you have lived with can become strangers after a single fact. The deserted-island question, in this movie, is not about survival skills.
It is about who is still standing next to you when the weather turns. Often the answer is no one, or not the person you assumed. The film does not scold them for that.
It lets them sit in the mess.
That 4.7/10 keeps nagging. Maybe audiences wanted catharsis. Maybe they wanted likable people and a clean goodbye. Who Would You Take to a Deserted Island? asks more than it refunds. It drops you in a room, points at the wreck, and leaves you there. For this kind of film, that is the point.
"A lukewarm reception: the premise and young cast earn some credit, but pacing and emotional depth draw criticism."
Reactions to *Who Would You Take to a Deserted Island?* (2019) are sparse and divided. Directed by Jota Linares, the teen drama features a young ensemble including Pol Monen, Jaime Lorente, and María Pedraza as a group of friends stranded on an island. The premise is intriguing, and some praise the cast chemistry and the attempt to explore friendship and survival. The execution draws criticism, particularly the pacing and lack of emotional depth: even at 93 minutes it drags and fails to develop its characters. Its 4.7/10 from 278 votes on SensCritique reflects this lukewarm reception, and it is widely called underwhelming for a Netflix release. No performances or moments stand out in the discussion. Coverage is thin, mostly trailers and brief metadata rather than in-depth reviews.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Jota Linares’ Who Would You Take to a Deserted Island? (2019) arrived on Netflix with a premise as intriguing as its title. The Spanish-language film, originally titled ¿A quién te llevarías a una isla desierta?, follows a group of young adults grappling with friendship, love, and survival after a boating accident leaves them stranded. With a cast featuring rising stars like Jaime Lorente (Money Heist) and María Pedraza (Elite), latestnetflix.com argues, the movie promised a mix of drama and adventure—but what do we really know about its behind-the-scenes story?
The film’s ensemble includes Pol Monen, Andrea Ros, and Abril Zamora, alongside Lorente and Pedraza. While the trailer teased a tense, emotional journey, details about the actors’ experiences on set remain scarce. Lorente, already a fan favorite from Money Heist, was likely a major draw for Spanish-speaking audiences, while Pedraza’s role in Elite had cemented her as a breakout talent. The chemistry between the cast—hinted at in promotional clips—suggests a focus on interpersonal dynamics over pure survival tropes.
Jota Linares, known for his work in Spanish indie cinema, directed the film with a clear emphasis on character-driven drama. The movie’s runtime (93 minutes) and genre classification as a "drama" rather than a full-blown thriller suggest a deliberate pace, prioritizing emotional stakes over action. While Linares’ previous projects haven’t reached the same level of global recognition, Who Would You Take to a Deserted Island? positioned him as a filmmaker comfortable with intimate, high-stakes storytelling.
The film’s reception appears mixed. On SensCritique, it holds a modest 4.7/10 rating based on nearly 300 votes, indicating a divided audience. Netflix’s decision to greenlight the project likely stemmed from its potential to tap into the teen drama market, though it didn’t achieve the same cultural footprint as Elite or Money Heist. Still, the trailer’s moody aesthetic and the cast’s star power ensured it didn’t go unnoticed.
For all its intrigue, Who Would You Take to a Deserted Island? remains a relatively low-profile release. There’s no confirmed word on box office numbers, behind-the-scenes conflicts, or even whether the cast bonded off-screen. Rumors about a potential sequel or spin-off haven’t surfaced, leaving the film as a standalone experiment in teen survival drama.
If you’re curious, the movie is still available on Netflix in select regions—but don’t expect a blockbuster. It’s a quiet, character-focused story that might resonate more with fans of indie Spanish cinema than mainstream audiences.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.