
Emma Roberts
Sloane

“Who's your perfect plus-one?”
Fed up with being single on holidays, two strangers agree to be each other's platonic plus-ones all year long, only to catch real feelings along the way.
Official
I’ll admit it: I clicked on Holidate because I was tired. Not in the mood for anything heavy, not in the mood for anything new—just something warm, familiar, and easy to swallow. That’s the promise of the holiday rom-com, isn’t it?
A cinematic sugar cookie, dusted with powdered nostalgia and served with a side of will-they-won’t-they tension. Holidate delivers on that promise, but like too many sugar cookies, it’s all surface sweetness with little substance beneath the icing.
The premise is simple enough: Sloane (Emma Roberts) and Jackson (Luke Bracey) are two single strangers who, after a chance meeting at a mall on Christmas Eve, agree to be each other’s platonic plus-ones for every holiday throughout the year. No strings, no expectations—just a mutual escape from the pitying looks of relatives and the exhausting parade of bad setups. It’s When Harry Met Sally meets The Holiday, if those films had been stripped of their wit and replaced with the kind of broad, sitcom-style humor that feels like it was written by a committee.
(And maybe it was—more on that later.)

The film leans hard into the holiday setting as a shortcut to charm. There’s something undeniably cozy about the way Holidate drapes itself in twinkling lights, oversized sweaters, and the kind of forced cheer that only exists in movies. The Christmas scene is all warm golds and deep reds, the kind of palette that makes you want to curl up under a blanket with a mug of something spiked.
But here’s the thing about shortcuts: they don’t take you very far. The holidays in Holidate aren’t a backdrop for character or conflict; they’re a series of postcards, each one more picturesque than the last, but none of them saying anything real. It’s like watching a Hallmark movie directed by someone who’s never actually celebrated a holiday with a family that wasn’t scripted.
And that’s the core issue with Holidate. It mistakes familiarity for depth. The film isn’t interested in subverting the rom-com genre so much as it is in coasting on its most tired tropes.
The meet-cute is perfunctory, the family dynamics are cartoonish (Kristin Chenoweth’s overbearing aunt is a walking punchline), and the will-they-won’t-they tension is stretched so thin it’s practically transparent. There’s a moment early on where Sloane and Jackson lay out their rules for the arrangement—no kissing, no sex, no falling in love—and it’s played for laughs, as if the audience hasn’t seen this exact setup a hundred times before.
The problem isn’t that the film is predictable; it’s that it doesn’t seem to realize predictability is its only card to play.

The performances do little to elevate the material. Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey are both capable actors, but they’re given so little to work with that their chemistry feels more like a math equation than a spark. Roberts, in particular, deserves better.
She’s spent years proving she can balance sharp humor with emotional vulnerability (Scream 4, American Horror Story), but here she’s reduced to reacting to slapstick and delivering one-liners that land with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer. Bracey fares slightly better, mostly because his character is given a few moments of quiet sincerity, but even those feel like they’ve been lifted from a different, better movie.
The supporting cast is where Holidate comes closest to feeling alive. Kristin Chenoweth, as Sloane’s meddling aunt, is a whirlwind of comedic energy, and Alex Moffat (as Sloane’s brother) brings a welcome dose of self-awareness to his role. But even their best moments can’t overcome the film’s fundamental problem: it’s a movie that thinks it’s clever when it’s really just going through the motions.
There’s a scene where Sloane and Jackson attend a Fourth of July party, and the film tries to mine humor from the awkwardness of their platonic arrangement. It’s the kind of scene that should crackle with tension—two people pretending not to want each other while everyone around them assumes they’re a couple—but the writing is so broad, the direction so flat, that it falls completely flat.
(I’ve seen more chemistry in a high school theater production of Grease.)

The audience reception, at least what’s available, suggests I’m not alone in my lukewarm take. The SensCritique rating of 4.8/10 is damning, though it’s worth noting that the film’s TMDB audience score sits at a slightly more forgiving 7.0. That split feels about right: Holidate isn’t a disaster, but it’s not good either.
It’s the cinematic equivalent of a microwave meal—filling in the moment, but leaving you with a vague sense of dissatisfaction afterward. The kind of movie you put on while folding laundry, not the kind you remember the next day.
And maybe that’s okay. Not every movie needs to be a masterpiece. Sometimes, you just want something that feels like a hug, even if it’s a hug from someone you barely know. Holidate knows its audience: people who want the comfort of a rom-com without the messiness of real emotions, people who want the holidays without the stress of actual family dynamics.
It’s a film that exists in the uncanny valley of the genre—close enough to the classics to feel familiar, but far enough away to feel hollow.
I don’t regret watching it. But I don’t think I’ll remember it either. And in the end, that might be the most damning thing of all.
"A lighthearted but forgettable rom-com with charming leads that struggles to stand out from the genre’s usual tropes."
Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey’s playful chemistry provides the movie’s brightest moments and enough charm to keep it watchable. The plot leans on clichéd holiday rom-com formulas with little originality or depth, and the humor often falls flat, making it more a missed opportunity than a festive treat.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Netflix’s 2020 rom-com Holidate promised a fresh twist on the holiday-movie formula: a no-strings-attached pact to be each other’s plus-ones for every major holiday. Starring Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey, the film leaned into awkward family gatherings, over-the-top set pieces, and a healthy dose of cringe humor. But what went down behind the scenes? latestnetflix.com's take is that while the evidence is light on juicy scandals, a few details about the cast, director, and production have surfaced—enough to paint a picture of a movie that embraced its chaotic charm from start to finish.
John Whitesell, the man behind Holidate, is no stranger to the rom-com or holiday-movie grind. Born in 1953, Whitesell has built a career directing and producing lighthearted comedies, often with a seasonal twist. His filmography includes Deck the Halls (2006) and Big Momma’s House 2 (2006), proving he knows how to balance broad humor with just enough heart to keep audiences engaged. Holidate fits neatly into this wheelhouse, though its reception was decidedly mixed—garnering a 4.8/10 rating on SensCritique, where over 3,000 users weighed in.
Whitesell’s approach to Holidate seems to have been all about leaning into the absurdity. The film’s premise—a mutual agreement to avoid holiday loneliness by being each other’s wingman—sets the stage for over-the-top scenarios, from disastrous Thanksgiving dinners to a Fourth of July mishap involving a fireworks-related wardrobe malfunction. If the blooper reel is any indication, the cast and crew were game for the chaos, with outtakes showing Roberts and Bracey cracking up mid-scene.
Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey lead the charge as Sloane and Jackson, two strangers who strike up an unconventional deal. Roberts, a rom-com veteran (Valentine’s Day, We’re the Millers), and Bracey, known for action roles (Point Break remake, Hacksaw Ridge), brought contrasting energies to the film. Their on-screen chemistry was a make-or-break element, and early trailers hinted at a playful dynamic that balanced flirtation with exasperation.
Supporting players like Kristin Chenoweth (as Sloane’s overbearing mother) and Frances Fisher (as Jackson’s judgmental aunt) added layers of comedic friction. Chenoweth, in particular, is a scene-stealer in the film, delivering her lines with the kind of exaggerated gusto that suggests she was having as much fun as the audience. Meanwhile, Andrew Bachelor (aka King Bach) and Alex Moffat round out the cast as Sloane’s best friend and Jackson’s cousin, respectively, bringing their own brands of humor to the mix.
One of the film’s most talked-about moments—a scene where a character (played by Jessica Capshaw) has an extremely unfortunate bathroom incident—became an instant meme. Reaction videos to the scene, like one titled “THE GIRL WHO SHT HERSELF HOLIDATE REACTION,” suggest the sequence was divisive, with some viewers finding it hilariously gross and others cringing too hard to laugh. Whether the cast found it as funny during filming remains unconfirmed, but given the blooper reel’s lighthearted tone, it’s safe to assume the set wasn’t short on laughter.
Holidate arrived on Netflix in October 2020, capitalizing on the streaming giant’s growing appetite for holiday content. The film’s trailer promised a raunchy, modern take on the rom-com genre, and it delivered—at least in terms of cringe and chaos. Reviews were lukewarm, with critics and audiences alike noting that the movie’s humor often veered into juvenile territory. The 4.8/10 rating on SensCritique reflects this divide, with some viewers praising its lightheartedness and others dismissing it as forgettable.
Despite the mixed reception, Holidate found its audience, particularly among fans of Roberts and those looking for a low-stakes holiday watch. The film’s premise—escaping the pressure of holiday dating—resonated with viewers, even if the execution wasn’t always polished. And while there’s no evidence of major behind-the-scenes drama, the blooper reel and reaction videos suggest the cast and crew embraced the film’s messy, unapologetic tone.
Holidate may not be a critical darling, but it’s the kind of movie that thrives on its flaws. The cast’s chemistry, Whitesell’s comedic sensibilities, and the sheer absurdity of its set pieces make it a standout in the crowded holiday-movie genre—even if it’s not for everyone. Whether you’re in it for the cringe, the romance, or just the chaotic energy, Holidate delivers exactly what it promises: a holiday rom-com that doesn’t take itself too seriously.
For those curious about the making of the film, the evidence is thin on behind-the-scenes drama, but the blooper reel and reaction videos offer a glimpse into the fun, unfiltered vibe on set. If nothing else, Holidate proves that sometimes, the best holiday movies are the ones that embrace the mess.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.