Skip to main content
Movie poster for A Secret Love (2020)

A Secret Love

2020
1h 22m
AA · English
Director: Chris Bolan
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Amid shifting times, two women kept their decades-long love a secret. But coming out later in life comes with its own set of challenges.

Trailer

Official

Cast

11 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Love That Dared Not Speak Its Name—Until It Had To

I keep thinking about the way Pat Henschel holds her coffee cup. It’s not a prop; it’s a shield. In A Secret Love, the 2020 documentary about her six-decade relationship with Terry Donahue, Pat’s hands are almost always busy—stirring, gripping, tapping the table.

When the camera lingers on them, you can see the veins, the age spots, the way her fingers tremble just slightly. It’s not nervousness, exactly. It’s the weight of a lifetime spent calculating how much of herself she could safely reveal.

The film opens with a black-and-white photograph: two young women in baseball uniforms, grinning. Terry Donahue, a professional player in the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (the real-life inspiration for A League of Their Own), and Pat Henschel, her teammate and lover. The photo is staged, performative—the kind of image you’d send to family back home.

But the way Pat describes it, decades later, is anything but: "We were just two girls in love, and nobody knew." The line lands like a punch. Not because it’s dramatic, but because it’s so matter-of-fact. Of course nobody knew.

That was the point.

Two elderly women sit side by side on a couch, looking at old photographs in their laps.

Chris Bolan, the director and Terry’s great-nephew, doesn’t just tell their story—he unearths it. The film is a collage of home movies, Polaroids, and present-day interviews, all stitched together with a quiet urgency. There’s no narrator, no omniscient voice guiding us.

Instead, we get Pat and Terry themselves, their voices sometimes cracking, sometimes steady, always honest. Bolan’s approach is deceptively simple: he lets them talk. And in doing so, he reveals how much of their lives was spent not talking.

The most devastating moments in A Secret Love aren’t the grand revelations—they’re the small, almost mundane admissions. Pat recalling how she and Terry would drive to Canada to visit family, always careful to book separate hotel rooms. Terry mentioning, offhand, that she once had a boyfriend, just to keep up appearances.

The way Pat’s voice drops when she says, "We never held hands in public." It’s not anger or bitterness in her tone. It’s exhaustion. Sixty years of exhaustion.

What makes the film so powerful is its refusal to romanticize their secrecy. There’s no tragic score swelling when Pat describes the fear of being outed, no slow-motion shots of them gazing longingly at each other. Instead, Bolan lets the silence do the work.

In one scene, Pat and Terry sit in their living room, surrounded by decades of shared history—furniture, knickknacks, the detritus of a life built together. The camera lingers on a framed photo of them in their 30s, young and vibrant. Then it cuts to the present: two elderly women, still together, still in love, but now facing the prospect of illness and separation.

The contrast is heartbreaking, not because it’s melodramatic, but because it’s so ordinary.

A close-up of an elderly woman's hands holding a framed black-and-white photograph of two young women.

The film’s emotional climax isn’t their coming out to family—though that moment, when Terry’s niece Diana learns the truth, is gutting in its own way. It’s the fight that erupts later, when Pat and Diana clash over Terry’s care. The argument is raw, messy, and uncomfortably real.

Diana accuses Pat of isolating Terry from her family; Pat fires back that Diana doesn’t understand their life together. The camera doesn’t flinch. It’s ugly, and it’s human, and it’s the kind of moment most documentaries would cut.

But Bolan leaves it in, because it’s part of their story too.

Here’s the thing about A Secret Love: it’s not just a film about being gay in the mid-20th century. It’s a film about what it means to love someone so deeply that you’re willing to erase parts of yourself to keep them safe. And then, later in life, what it means to realize that the world has changed enough that you don’t have to hide anymore—but your body might not have the time to enjoy it.

The gossip around the film—those iPhone-confessed family fights, the rumors about Pat’s wealth, the debates over who gets to tell queer stories—feels almost beside the point. Because at its core, A Secret Love isn’t about scandal or drama. It’s about two women who loved each other for 65 years, who built a life together in the shadows, and who, in their 80s, finally got to say, "This is who we are." The tragedy isn’t that they had to hide.

It’s that they had to wait so long to stop.

An elderly couple sits together on a couch, smiling at each other with affection.

I keep coming back to that coffee cup. The way Pat’s hands never quite settle. It’s as if, even in her 80s, even after coming out, even after the documentary, she’s still bracing for the moment someone tells her she’s holding it wrong.

That’s the real legacy of a life spent in secret—not the grand gestures, but the small, daily calculations. The way you learn to love someone so quietly that the world forgets to ask if you exist.

A Secret Love doesn’t just document a relationship. It mourns the time lost to silence—and celebrates the courage it took to finally speak.

Audience Opinions

Audience 8.2/10
"A deeply moving and long-overdue celebration of love, full of raw emotion and authenticity."

The film tells the real-life love story of Terry Donahue and Pat Henschel, spanning nearly seven decades. Its intimate portrait of their relationship, set against the backdrop of societal prejudice, is praised for its honesty and emotional depth. The pacing occasionally drags, but the heartfelt moments far outweigh any minor flaws.

What viewers praise
  • Emotionally powerful The couple's genuine love and struggles leave a lasting impact and can easily bring you to tears.
  • Authentic storytelling The documentary feels personal and true to life, favoring raw honesty over melodrama.
  • Historical significance Highlights an important, often overlooked chapter of LGBTQ+ history with respect and care.
  • Strong performances Terry and Pat's natural chemistry and vulnerability make their story compelling.
  • Inspiring resilience Their decades together in the face of prejudice are uplifting and moving.
Common complaints
  • Slow pacing The film's rhythm is uneven, with moments that feel drawn out.
  • Limited scope The documentary could have explored broader societal context or other perspectives.
  • Repetitive moments Certain emotional beats are revisited and could have been condensed.
Recommended for
LGBTQ+ history enthusiasts Documentary lovers Fans of real-life love stories Those seeking emotional depth Baseball history buffs Advocates for LGBTQ+ rights

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Secret Tea Behind A Secret Love: Family Fights, Basement Archives & iPhone Confessions

Two grandmas, one Netflix doc, and a mountain of secret drama. You thought A Secret Love (2020) was just a gentle queer tearjerker? latestnetflix.com's view is that Oh honey, the behind-the-scenes story has more tension than a Thanksgiving with your ex.


On-Set Drama & iPhone Confessions

  • The most explosive moment in the whole film—the vicious fight where Pat, Terry, and niece Diana emotionally go at it over care and control—almost wasn’t a “real” shoot day. Director Chris Bolan says the crew had already packed up when the argument started, so he grabbed his iPhone and secretly filmed the whole meltdown instead of the nice professional footage Netflix probably expected. - Afterward, he confessed to Pat and the family that he’d captured it on his phone. They were reportedly shocked but ultimately agreed to let the raw clash stay in the film because it was too honest and important to cut. That’s not just cinéma vérité, that’s “we accidentally made a reality show” energy.
  • Bolan spent seven years filming, editing, and building the documentary, juggling “I’m your great-nephew” with “also I’m putting your worst arguments on Netflix”. That’s a family group chat I would not want to be in.

Cast Feuds & Family Tea

  • Viewers clocked it immediately: there is serious tension between Pat and Terry’s family. In fan threads, people say Terry’s relatives “weren’t fond of Pat” and seemed to resent that Pat had “kept Terry all to herself” for decades. - The big retirement-home storyline? Fans describe it as basically “Pat vs. The Niece.” Pat is painted as “hella controlling” over decisions about Terry’s care and deeply resistant to moving back to Canada where the rest of the family lives. - There’s also a morbidly juicy detail fans latched onto: Pat mentions having three potential husbands who all died—viewers repeat it like a dark running joke in discussions. If this were a Ryan Murphy fiction series, you know exactly where that plot would go.

Money, Mysteries & Quiet Millions

  • One of the most gossiped-about angles online? The money. In the doc, it’s clear Pat and Terry can afford a very nice assisted-living facility. On Lipstick Alley, commenters claim the couple had “over a million” in assets even before selling their house and openly wonder where the cash came from. - Fans speculate it’s a mix of pensions, savings from a modest but frugal life, and maybe the tiniest trickle of residual glory from the A League of Their Own era—Terry played in the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League, which inspired the film and later projects. No proof of Hollywood checks, but the theory’s out there.

Scandals & Controversies: Who Tells the Story?

  • The biggest “scandal” attached to A Secret Love isn’t cheating or crime, it’s representation drama. Queer critics and fans have called out the way the story is framed. - BuzzFeed’s Shannon Keating (quoted in a critical review) slammed the film for “the subtle but insidious homophobia baked into this very telling of their story,” arguing that it leans too hard on secrecy, shame, and family approval instead of just letting Pat and Terry’s queer joy take center stage. - Another reviewer points out that the doc spends a lot of time on straight relatives’ reactions and not nearly enough on the couple’s Chicago queer community, which we glimpse only briefly in lovely dinner scenes with their gay friends. - There’s also low-key chatter about how the framing might have been different if the movie hadn’t been directed by their (well-meaning but non-queer) great-nephew. Some critics openly wonder what a queer woman filmmaker would’ve done with the same material.

Leaks, Secrets & Wild Trivia

  • That dreamy archival footage of mid-century queer life—bar scenes, parties, candid moments—wasn’t sitting in a pristine studio vault. It was reportedly discovered in a suitcase in a basement, a literal buried treasure of vintage gay history that the filmmakers unearthed and wove into the doc. Basement, but make it iconic. - Pat herself was hilariously unimpressed by the whole idea of becoming Netflix-famous. When Bolan first pitched the documentary, she basically shrugged: why would anyone care, she insisted, about “just an ordinary life”. Seven decades of forbidden love and you still think you’re boring? Legend. - Producer heavyweights Ryan Murphy and Jason Blum jumped on board to back the project, bringing their genre power to a tiny, intimate story about two elderly women who didn’t think they were extraordinary at all. The result: a small film with massive emotional fallout—if your TikTok FYP in 2020 was full of people ugly-crying, A Secret Love was probably the culprit.

In the end, A Secret Love is exactly what it says on the tin: a secret that finally spills out—on camera, in family fights, in old basement suitcases, and in the messy public square of the internet. The doc gives you the romance; the gossip gives you the rest.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.