
Benedetta Porcaroli
Donatella Colasanti

Three well-off young men—former students at Rome’s prestigious all-boys Catholic high school San Leone Magno—brutally tortured, raped, and murdered two young women in 1975. The event, which came to be known as the Circeo massacre, shocked and captivated the country, exposing the violence and dark underbelly of the upper middle class at a moment when the traditional structures of family and religion were seen as under threat.
I keep thinking about the way the camera lingers on the boys’ shoes. Not the polished loafers you’d expect from students at Rome’s elite San Leone Magno Catholic school, but scuffed sneakers, untied laces, the kind of footwear that suggests a deliberate slouch against expectation. It’s a small detail in Stefano Mordini’s The Catholic School, but it’s the kind that sticks—because it’s the first hint that these young men, so carefully groomed by privilege, are already unraveling.
The film is based on Edoardo Albinati’s 2016 novel, which itself is a fictionalized reckoning with the 1975 Circeo massacre, a crime so brutal it became shorthand for the rot beneath Italy’s postwar prosperity. Three former students of San Leone Magno—all from wealthy, connected families—kidnapped, tortured, raped, and murdered two young women, Donatella Colasanti and Rosaria Lopez.
Lopez didn’t survive. Colasanti, left for dead in the trunk of a car, lived to testify. The case exposed something ugly about the country’s ruling class: that entitlement and violence could fester behind the veneer of respectability, that the institutions meant to shape young men—schools, churches, families—could instead warp them.
Mordini doesn’t show us the massacre. Not directly. Instead, he circles it, like a predator stalking its prey, letting the dread build through the mundane.
The first half of the film unfolds in the claustrophobic corridors of San Leone Magno, where the boys—played by a cast of young actors who look like they’ve stepped out of a Renaissance painting, all sharp cheekbones and restless energy—trade barbs, smoke cigarettes, and recite Latin with the ease of those who’ve never had to question their place in the world. There’s a scene early on where they gather in a bathroom, passing around a joint, their laughter too loud, too knowing.
One of them, Andrea (Emanuele Maria Di Stefano), leans against the sink, his face half-lit by the flickering fluorescent bulb. He’s telling a joke about a priest and a prostitute, and the others roar with laughter, but his eyes are flat, empty. It’s the kind of moment that makes you lean forward in your seat, because you know—even if you don’t know the history—that something is coming.

The film’s greatest strength is its refusal to simplify. It doesn’t let the boys off the hook—how could it?—but it also doesn’t treat them as monsters. They’re products of their environment, yes, but that’s not an excuse; it’s an indictment.
The Catholic school of the title isn’t just a setting; it’s a character, a system that polishes its students into something shiny and hollow. The priests who run the school are more concerned with appearances than morality, their sermons about sin ringing hollow against the boys’ casual cruelty. In one chilling scene, a teacher lectures on the importance of chastity while the boys smirk, passing notes about the girls they’ve slept with.
The disconnect is so stark it’s almost funny—until it isn’t.
Mordini’s direction is precise, almost clinical, in its detachment. There are no sweeping score cues to tell you how to feel, no melodramatic close-ups to underline the horror. The camera often holds back, observing from a distance, as if the film itself is reluctant to get too close to the ugliness.
It’s an effective choice, but it also creates a kind of emotional remove. You’re aware of the stakes, but you don’t always feel them in your gut. That might be intentional—this isn’t a film that wants to exploit the violence for shock value—but it also means that when the massacre finally arrives, it lands with a thud rather than a scream.
The second half of the film shifts to the aftermath, and it’s here that The Catholic School stumbles slightly. The novel, by all accounts, is a sprawling, digressive work, weaving together memoir, fiction, and social critique. The film, constrained by its runtime, struggles to contain that ambition.
It jumps between perspectives—the boys, the victims, the investigators—without always giving each thread the weight it deserves. The victims, in particular, feel underdeveloped. We see glimpses of their lives, their hopes, their fear, but they remain largely defined by their suffering.
It’s a frustrating limitation, especially given the real-life horror of what happened to them.

That said, there are moments where the film’s restraint pays off. The final act, which deals with the trial and its fallout, is quietly devastating. The boys, now young men, sit in the courtroom with the same smug indifference they wore in school.
Their families hire the best lawyers, pull strings, do everything they can to minimize the damage. The system, it becomes clear, was never designed to hold them accountable. It’s a bleak conclusion, but an honest one.
The film doesn’t offer easy answers or redemptive arcs. It simply presents the facts and lets them hang in the air, heavy and unresolved.
I’ve seen this trick before—the true-crime story that doubles as a social critique, the film that uses real-life horror to ask bigger questions about class, power, and complicity. But The Catholic School distinguishes itself by its refusal to sensationalize. It doesn’t linger on the violence for shock value, nor does it turn the perpetrators into antiheroes.
Instead, it forces us to sit with the uncomfortable truth that these boys were ordinary. That’s what makes it so unsettling. They weren’t outliers.
They were products of a system that rewarded cruelty with impunity, that taught them their privilege was a shield.
The film’s reception has been muted, at least in English-language circles. There are no major critic quotes to pull from, no buzzy festival premieres or awards buzz. That might be a reflection of its subject matter—true crime, especially when it involves sexual violence, is a fraught genre, one that often invites more controversy than conversation.
Or it might be that The Catholic School is simply too quiet, too measured, to cut through the noise. It doesn’t offer the catharsis of a revenge thriller or the moral clarity of a courtroom drama. What it offers instead is something rarer: a portrait of how evil takes root in the ordinary.

I keep coming back to that bathroom scene. The way the boys’ laughter echoes off the tiles, the way Andrea’s joke hangs in the air like a bad smell. It’s a small moment, but it’s the kind that haunts you.
Because it’s not just about them. It’s about all of us—the systems we uphold, the cruelties we ignore, the way we look away when the shoes don’t match the uniform. The Catholic School doesn’t let you look away. And that, in the end, might be its most uncomfortable achievement.
"A slow-burn crime drama with strong performances but a disjointed narrative that struggles to fully engage."
The film offers atmospheric tension and committed performances, particularly from the younger actors. Its pacing and fragmented storytelling, though, leave it underwhelming, and it fails to deliver on its promising premise.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Stefano Mordini’s The Catholic School (2021) arrived on Netflix with a reputation for unsettling realism, but the film’s journey from page to screen is almost as dramatic as its subject matter. Based on Edoardo Albinati’s controversial 2016 novel La Scuola Cattolica, the movie revisits a chilling true crime that rocked 1970s Rome—and the elite Catholic school at its center. latestnetflix.com's view is that here’s what we know about the making of this provocative drama.
The Catholic School fictionalizes the 1975 Circeo massacre, a brutal crime involving wealthy young men from Rome’s prestigious San Leone Magno school. The novel—and later the film—explores how privilege, toxic masculinity, and institutional complicity fueled violence. While the movie takes creative liberties, its core events mirror real-life horrors: two teenage girls were kidnapped, tortured, and murdered by a group of former classmates, one of whom was the son of a prominent industrialist.
The film’s unflinching portrayal of class and misogyny sparked debate even before its release. Benedetta Porcaroli, who plays one of the film’s central female characters, called it a "necessary film" during its Venice Film Festival premiere, arguing that its themes remain urgent. Yet the adaptation’s fidelity to the novel’s most disturbing details—including graphic depictions of violence—has divided critics. Some praise its boldness, while others question whether the film risks sensationalism.
The young ensemble cast—led by Porcaroli, Giulio Pranno, and Federica Torchetti—delivered raw performances, but rumors swirled about the emotional toll of the material. Sources suggest Mordini, known for his intense directorial style, pushed actors to confront uncomfortable truths about power and complicity. One YouTube breakdown claims the cast underwent "psychological preparation" to handle the film’s dark themes, though no official confirmation exists.
Off-screen, the production faced scrutiny over its handling of sensitive subject matter. The real-life victims’ families have long criticized media portrayals of the Circeo massacre, and while The Catholic School avoids naming actual perpetrators, its fictionalized approach drew comparisons to true-crime exploitation. Netflix’s involvement—marketed with trailers emphasizing the film’s "shocking" nature —fueled further debate about whether the platform prioritized drama over nuance.
Stefano Mordini, a veteran of Italian cinema with a background in documentaries, took a risk adapting Albinati’s dense, 1,200-page novel. The book’s nonlinear structure and philosophical digressions were streamlined into a 106-minute thriller, but Mordini retained its critique of institutional hypocrisy. Reviews note the film’s "claustrophobic" tension, with some praising its visual storytelling, while others argue it struggles to balance character depth with its broader social commentary.
The director’s own ties to Italy’s elite—he was born in Tuscany and has worked with high-profile actors—added another layer of intrigue. Was The Catholic School a personal reckoning with privilege? Mordini has stayed tight-lipped, but his past work (Pericle il Nero, The Invisible Thread) suggests a fascination with moral ambiguity. For this project, he reportedly insisted on shooting in Rome’s affluent Parioli district, where the real-life crimes occurred, to heighten the film’s authenticity.
Upon release, The Catholic School polarized audiences. SensCritique users rated it 4.6/10, with some calling it "a missed opportunity" for its uneven pacing. Others, however, lauded its unflinching gaze at systemic violence, particularly against women. The film’s Netflix rollout—complete with a trailer that leaned into its "true crime" appeal —drew criticism for potentially trivializing the real-life tragedy.
Behind the scenes, the debate continues. Was the film a necessary exposé or an exploitative spectacle? The answer likely lies somewhere in between. What’s clear is that The Catholic School refuses to let its audience look away—whether from the screen or the uncomfortable truths it reflects.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.