
John Fantasia
Executive

Investigators reveal how Boeing’s alleged priority of profit over safety could have contributed to two catastrophic crashes within months of each other.
Official
I’ve watched Downfall: The Case Against Boeing twice now, and both times I found myself gripping the armrests of my chair—not because the film is a thriller in the traditional sense, but because it turns the act of flying into something deeply unsettling. Rory Kennedy’s documentary doesn’t just recount the tragedies of Lion Air Flight 610 and Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302; it dismantles the illusion that commercial aviation is a flawless system, governed by cold, infallible logic.
Instead, it reveals a corporation where profit margins and shareholder returns took precedence over the lives of passengers and crew. The film’s power lies in its restraint. It doesn’t need to sensationalize the crashes; the facts, laid out methodically, are damning enough.

Kennedy, whose previous documentaries like The Ghosts of Abu Ghraib and Last Days in Vietnam have tackled institutional failures with a journalist’s precision and a storyteller’s empathy, approaches Downfall with a similar rigor. The film is structured like a legal case, building its argument piece by piece: internal Boeing emails, whistleblower testimonies, congressional hearings, and heartbreaking interviews with the families of victims.
There’s no voiceover grandstanding, no dramatic reenactments—just the slow, relentless accumulation of evidence. The effect is chilling. By the time the film reaches its climax, the question isn’t whether Boeing is guilty of negligence, but how deep the rot goes.
One of the most striking sequences comes early, when Kennedy walks us through the development of the 737 MAX. Boeing, desperate to compete with Airbus’s more fuel-efficient A320neo, rushed the MAX into production without adequately addressing the risks posed by its new Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS). The film doesn’t get bogged down in technical jargon, but it doesn’t shy away from the details either.
We see how Boeing’s engineers raised red flags about MCAS, only to be overruled by management. We hear from pilots who were never properly trained on the system, and from families who lost loved ones in crashes that could have been prevented. The film’s brilliance is in how it connects these dots—not just as a series of corporate missteps, but as a moral failure.

What’s most unsettling about Downfall is how ordinary the villains are. There are no mustache-twirling executives here, no dramatic monologues about greed. Instead, we see bureaucrats and engineers making small, incremental decisions—each one seemingly reasonable in isolation—that collectively lead to catastrophe.
The film’s most damning moments come from Boeing’s own internal communications, where employees joke about the MAX’s safety or dismiss concerns with a shrug. In one email, an engineer refers to the plane as “designed by clowns who in turn are supervised by monkeys.” It’s a line that lands like a punch to the gut, not because it’s hyperbolic, but because it feels like the truth.
Kennedy also doesn’t let regulators off the hook. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), which delegated much of its oversight to Boeing itself, comes under scrutiny for its cozy relationship with the company it was supposed to police. Elaine Chao, who served as Secretary of Transportation during the 737 MAX crises, appears in the film, though her role is limited.
(Her inclusion feels more like a nod to the political context than a deep dive into her actions.) The film’s focus, rightly, remains on the systemic failures that allowed Boeing to prioritize profits over safety.

If Downfall has a flaw, it’s that it doesn’t fully explore the broader cultural context of Boeing’s decline. The company, once a symbol of American engineering prowess, has become synonymous with corporate greed and regulatory capture. How did this happen?
Was it the merger with McDonnell Douglas in 1997, which shifted Boeing’s culture from engineering-driven to finance-driven? The film touches on this, but only briefly. I found myself wanting more—more history, more analysis of how Boeing’s corporate culture evolved (or devolved) over time.
But perhaps that’s a story for another documentary.
What Downfall does best is humanize the victims. The film doesn’t just show us the crashes as abstract tragedies; it introduces us to the people who died, the families they left behind, and the investigators who fought to uncover the truth. In one particularly moving scene, we meet Michael Stumo, whose daughter Samya died in the Ethiopian Airlines crash.
Stumo’s quiet, measured grief is more powerful than any dramatic reenactment could be. It’s a reminder that behind every statistic, every corporate decision, there are real lives at stake.
The film’s SensCritique rating of 7/10 suggests that some viewers found it effective but not groundbreaking. I’d argue that’s a fair assessment, but also a bit beside the point. Downfall isn’t trying to reinvent the documentary form; it’s trying to hold a powerful corporation accountable. In that, it succeeds brilliantly.
It’s not a film that leaves you with easy answers or a sense of closure. Instead, it leaves you with a lingering unease—a sense that the systems we trust to keep us safe are more fragile than we’d like to believe.
A few days after watching Downfall, I found myself on a flight, staring out the window as the plane taxied down the runway. I thought about the pilots in the cockpit, the engineers who designed the plane, the regulators who signed off on its safety. And for the first time, I felt a flicker of doubt.
Not fear, exactly—just the quiet realization that flying, for all its convenience, is still an act of faith. Downfall doesn’t ask us to stop flying. It asks us to demand better.
"A hard-hitting documentary on Boeing's failures that leaves some wanting deeper technical analysis."
The film is praised for its gripping investigation of the 737 MAX disasters, corporate negligence, and regulatory failure. Some feel it skims the technical side, favoring emotional and political angles over engineering.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Rory Kennedy’s 2022 documentary Downfall: The Case Against Boeing doesn’t just revisit the tragic crashes of Lion Air Flight 610 and Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302—it dismantles the corporate culture that allowed them to happen. latestnetflix.com's read is that the film, streaming on Netflix, blends investigative rigor with emotional testimony, making it as much a legal indictment as a documentary.
Kennedy, known for her socially conscious filmmaking (The Ghosts of Abu Ghraib, Last Days in Vietnam), takes a no-holds-barred approach here. The documentary frames Boeing’s 737 MAX disasters as the result of systemic negligence: cost-cutting over safety, regulatory capture, and a corporate ethos that prioritized profits over lives. Interviews with crash victims’ families, aviation experts, and lawmakers—including Rep. Peter DeFazio and former Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao—paint a damning picture of a company that allegedly misled regulators and the public.
Kennedy’s involvement goes beyond directing. In interviews, she’s described the film as a call to accountability, emphasizing how Boeing’s actions (or inactions) led to 346 deaths. One standout moment comes from Michael Stumo, father of crash victim Samya Stumo, who confronts the human cost of Boeing’s decisions in raw, unfiltered terms.
The documentary’s production leaned heavily on whistleblowers, internal Boeing documents, and congressional hearings to build its case. While the evidence doesn’t reveal new behind-the-scenes drama about the film’s making, Kennedy’s past work suggests a meticulous approach to storytelling. Her films often rely on archival footage and firsthand accounts, and Downfall appears to follow suit, using cockpit voice recordings, text messages between Boeing employees, and damning emails to underscore its arguments.
The trailer alone—released across multiple platforms—hints at the film’s tone: somber, urgent, and unflinching. Clips of Boeing executives testifying before Congress, juxtaposed with grieving families, set the stage for a documentary that’s as much about justice as it is about tragedy.
Critics and audiences have responded strongly to Downfall. On SensCritique, it holds a 7/10 rating based on 265 votes, with praise for its thoroughness but some criticism of its one-sided perspective. Rotten Tomatoes’ audience score (not detailed in the evidence) would likely reflect similar divides—supporters lauding its investigative depth, detractors arguing it leans too heavily on emotional appeals.
What’s undeniable is the film’s role in keeping Boeing’s scandals in the public eye. By centering victims’ stories, Kennedy ensures the narrative isn’t just about technical failures but about the lives lost—and the corporate decisions that made those losses possible.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.