Skip to main content
Movie poster for I Used to Be Funny (2024)

I Used to Be Funny

2024
1h 46m
NR · English
Director: Ally Pankiw
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Sam, an aspiring stand-up comedian and au pair struggling with PTSD, weighs whether to join the search for Brooke, a missing teenage girl she used to nanny. As she fights to recover from her trauma and return to the stage, memories of her deep bond with Brooke rush back—making it impossible to ignore her disappearance.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Laughter That Sticks in Your Throat

I’ve seen this trick before: a comedian uses jokes to deflect pain, and the camera lingers just long enough to show the cracks beneath the punchlines. But I Used to Be Funny doesn’t just linger—it presses down, hard, until the laughter curdles into something else entirely. Rachel Sennott’s Sam isn’t just a stand-up comic having a rough patch; she’s a woman whose body and voice have been hijacked by trauma, and the film refuses to let her—or us—look away.

Ally Pankiw’s feature debut is a tightrope act, balancing the irreverent energy of Toronto’s comedy scene with the suffocating weight of PTSD. It’s a film that understands how humor can be both a lifeline and a trap, especially for women who’ve been taught to swallow their rage. The nonlinear structure—flipping between Sam’s past and present—could’ve felt like a gimmick in lesser hands, but Pankiw uses it to mirror the way memory intrudes, unbidden and unwelcome.

One moment, Sam is killing it on stage, her jokes sharp enough to draw blood; the next, she’s curled into a ball on her couch, her breath shallow, her eyes darting like a cornered animal.

Sam on stage, mid-joke, her face lit with the artificial glow of a comedy club spotlight

The film’s most devastating scenes aren’t the ones where Sam breaks down—they’re the ones where she almost does. There’s a quiet moment in her apartment, the blue glow of her laptop screen casting shadows across her face as she watches old footage of herself performing. The camera holds on her expression, a mix of longing and revulsion, as if she’s watching a stranger.

It’s a small gesture, but it speaks volumes about the way trauma distorts self-perception. Sennott, who’s made a career out of playing women who weaponize awkwardness, has never been more exposed. Her physicality here is a masterclass in restraint: the way her shoulders hunch when she’s alone, the forced brightness in her voice when she’s around others, the way her hands tremble just before she delivers a punchline.

It’s the kind of performance that makes you forget you’re watching an actor. Pankiw’s direction is equally precise, though not without its stumbles. The film’s moody blue tones and audio cues (a sudden silence, a muffled scream) are effective in building tension, but the nonlinear timeline occasionally feels more fussy than functional.

The reveal, when it comes, lands with a thud rather than a gut punch, as if the film is more interested in the idea of trauma than its specifics. But perhaps that’s the point. Trauma isn’t always a single, dramatic event; sometimes it’s a slow unraveling, a series of small betrayals that add up to something unspeakable.

Sam and Brooke sitting on a bed, their faces half-lit by a bedside lamp, the intimacy of the moment palpable

The heart of the film lies in Sam’s relationship with Brooke (Olga Petsa), the young girl she used to babysit. Their bond is the film’s emotional anchor, a rare pocket of warmth in an otherwise chilly landscape. Petsa, who plays Brooke as a precocious 12-year-old with a sharp tongue and a tender heart, is a revelation.

Their scenes together crackle with authenticity, a reminder of what Sam has lost—not just her sense of safety, but her capacity for connection. When Brooke goes missing, the film’s stakes shift from the personal to the urgent, though the mystery of her disappearance never quite lands with the same weight as Sam’s internal struggle. What I Used to Be Funny gets right is its refusal to offer easy answers.

Sam’s journey isn’t about "healing" in the tidy, inspirational sense; it’s about learning to live with the mess. The film’s final act, which finds Sam returning to the stage, isn’t a triumphant comeback so much as a tentative step forward. The camera lingers on her face as she delivers her set, her jokes landing but her eyes betraying something darker.

It’s a moment that encapsulates the film’s central tension: Can you ever really go back to who you were before? Or are you doomed to perform the version of yourself that others expect? I Used to Be Funny isn’t just a dark comedy with dramatic undertones; it’s a film that understands how laughter and pain are often two sides of the same coin. The best comedians, after all, are the ones who’ve stared into the abyss and come back with a joke.

The question is what it costs them. I left the film thinking about the women I know who use humor as armor, who laugh loudest when they’re hurting the most. I Used to Be Funny doesn’t just observe that phenomenon—it interrogates it, with all the messiness and contradiction that entails. It’s not a perfect film, but it’s an honest one, and in an era where women’s pain is so often sanitized or sensationalized, that feels like a radical act.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Rachel Sennott and Ally Pankiw on the Raw, Radical Heart of I Used to Be Funny

Rachel Sennott’s Sam isn’t just another comedian having a bad day—she’s a woman unraveling in real time, and I Used to Be Funny (2024) refuses to let her off the hook. Directed by Ally Pankiw, the Canadian indie dramedy dives headfirst into the messy overlap of trauma, humor, and self-sabotage, with Sennott delivering a performance that’s equal parts hilarious and harrowing. But how did this sharp, unflinching film come together? latestnetflix.com's read is that behind-the-scenes details reveal a project built on trust, creative risk-taking, and a shared mission to redefine how women’s pain is portrayed on screen.


A Script Born from Personal Demons

Pankiw’s feature debut isn’t just a character study—it’s a reckoning. The film follows Sam, a stand-up comedian in Toronto whose career and mental health spiral after a traumatic event involving Brooke (Olga Petsa), a young girl she once babysat. The story’s emotional core stems from Pankiw’s own experiences, though she’s been tight-lipped about the specifics. In interviews, she’s framed the film as a way to explore trauma without sensationalism, using comedy as both a shield and a weapon.

What’s clear is that Pankiw didn’t want to soften the edges. The script blends laugh-out-loud moments with gut-punch scenes, a tonal tightrope that could’ve easily collapsed in lesser hands. Variety notes that Pankiw deliberately avoided the “trauma porn” trope, instead letting the humor and pain coexist in a way that feels uncomfortably real. That balance was key to selling the film’s radical honesty—and it’s why Sennott, known for her razor-sharp comedic timing in Bottoms and Shiva Baby, was the perfect lead.


Rachel Sennott: From Viral Comedy to Vulnerable Drama

Sennott’s rise to fame has been defined by her ability to turn awkwardness into art. But I Used to Be Funny demanded something deeper. The role of Sam required her to oscillate between biting wit and raw vulnerability, often in the same scene. In a Marie Claire interview, Sennott and Pankiw described the film as a “love letter to women who use humor to survive,” but also a critique of how society polices their pain.

The chemistry between Sennott and Pankiw was evident from the start. The director, who cut her teeth on TV projects like Feel Good (2020), has a knack for drawing out naturalistic performances from her actors. For Sennott, that meant trusting Pankiw’s vision even when the material veered into dark territory. “It’s not a movie about a comedian,” Sennott told Marie Claire. “It’s a movie about a woman who happens to be a comedian”. That distinction is crucial—Sam’s identity isn’t defined by her job, but by her struggle to reconcile who she was with who she’s becoming.

The supporting cast—including Jason Jones, Sabrina Jalees, and Ennis Esmer—brings its own energy, but the film’s emotional weight rests squarely on Sennott’s shoulders. Roger Ebert’s review praises her ability to “make despair funny without making it feel like a joke,” a sign of the trust between actor and director.


The Radical Choice: Letting the Audience Sit with Discomfort

Pankiw’s approach to I Used to Be Funny wasn’t just about blending comedy and drama—it was about forcing the audience to confront the ways women’s trauma is often dismissed or exploited. The film’s title itself is a sly commentary on how society expects women to perform happiness, even when they’re falling apart. As Pankiw told Variety, “We wanted to make something that felt true to the way women actually talk about their pain—with humor, but also with rage”.

That philosophy extends to the film’s structure. I Used to Be Funny jumps between timelines, using flashbacks to underscore how the past haunts Sam’s present. It’s a narrative choice that could’ve felt gimmicky, but Pankiw’s direction keeps it grounded. The film’s Toronto setting also plays a role, with the city’s grungy comedy clubs and sterile apartments mirroring Sam’s internal chaos.

Critics have been divided on whether the film’s tonal shifts always land, but few deny its ambition. Ebert’s review calls it a “bold feature debut” that wrestles with thorny questions about art, accountability, and the cost of honesty. For Pankiw and Sennott, that’s the point—I Used to Be Funny isn’t here to comfort. It’s here to unsettle.


What’s Next for Pankiw and Sennott?

With I Used to Be Funny making waves on the festival circuit, both Pankiw and Sennott are poised for bigger stages. Pankiw’s background in TV (she directed the entire first season of Feel Good) suggests she’s equally comfortable in episodic storytelling, and her knack for nuanced character work could make her a sought-after voice in prestige drama. As for Sennott, her performance in I Used to Be Funny proves she’s more than just a comedic force—she’s a dramatic actor with serious range.

Rumors about future collaborations between the two have already started swirling, though neither has confirmed anything concrete. What’s certain is that I Used to Be Funny marks a turning point for both women—a film that’s as much about artistic growth as it is about the stories it tells.

For now, audiences can expect the movie to continue its festival run before a wider release. If early reactions are any indication, it’s a project that will linger long after the credits roll.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.