Skip to main content
Movie poster for Gumraah (2023)

Gumraah

2023
2h 10m
UA · Hindi
Director: Vardhan Ketkar
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A murder investigation becomes complicated after the cops discover a pair of lookalike suspects.

Trailer

Official

Cast

7 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Double Bind: How Gumraah Stumbles Over Its Own Reflection

I’ve seen this trick before—the murder, the twin suspects, the slow unraveling of identity. It’s a classic setup, one that Thadam, the 2019 Tamil original, handled with a certain taut efficiency. So when Gumraah arrived as its Hindi remake, I’ll admit I was skeptical.

Not because remakes are inherently bad (though Bollywood’s recent run of South Indian adaptations hasn’t exactly been a golden age), but because the premise demands precision. A story about doppelgängers isn’t just about plot twists; it’s about the uncanny, the way a face can become a mask, and how easily we mistake one man for another. Gumraah understands the assignment in theory.

In practice? It fumbles the execution, like a magician who forgets the sleight of hand halfway through the trick.

The film opens with a murder—brutal, sudden, the kind of violence that should jolt you awake. Aditya Roy Kapur plays both the victim’s lover, Arjun Sehgal, and the prime suspect, a street-smart conman named Ronnie. The police, led by the stern ACP Dhiren Yadav (Ronit Roy) and the sharp-eyed SI Shivani Mathur (Mrunal Thakur), are immediately stumped.

How do you solve a crime when the suspect has a perfect alibi, provided by his own face? The premise is ripe for tension, for the kind of paranoia that makes you question every glance, every gesture. But Gumraah keeps undercutting itself, as if it’s afraid to trust its own conceit.

A tense interrogation scene, with Aditya Roy Kapur’s two characters framed in stark contrast—one under the harsh light of suspicion, the other in shadow

Take the musical numbers, for instance. Yes, you read that right. In the middle of a murder investigation, Gumraah pauses for a song.

Not a diegetic one—there’s no nightclub, no radio playing in the background—just a full-blown musical interlude, complete with choreography and a sudden shift in tone. It’s the kind of moment that makes you wonder if the film is in on the joke or if it’s just hopelessly confused. Critics weren’t kind about this choice. Scroll.in called the film a "blunt remake that needed sharpening," and it’s hard to disagree when the narrative keeps tripping over its own feet.

Even the moments that should land with a punch—like the reveal of the second lookalike—feel oddly muted, as if the film is more interested in ticking boxes than in building genuine suspense.

That’s not to say Gumraah is without its pleasures. The second half, in particular, picks up speed, as the investigation spirals into a series of twists that, while not entirely surprising, at least keep you engaged. Aditya Roy Kapur’s dual performance is the film’s saving grace.

He’s not just relying on superficial differences—Arjun’s polished demeanor versus Ronnie’s swagger—to sell the illusion. There’s a physicality to his portrayal, a way of holding his body that shifts subtly between the two roles. Arjun moves like a man who’s spent his life in boardrooms, his posture rigid, his gestures measured.

Ronnie, on the other hand, is all loose limbs and restless energy, a man who’s used to slipping through cracks. It’s a quiet achievement, one that makes you wish the script had given him more to work with.

Aditya Roy Kapur as Ronnie, the street-smart conman, leaning against a wall with a smirk, his body language loose and confident

The supporting cast, too, deserves credit for keeping the film afloat. Ronit Roy, as the biased ACP, brings a weary gravitas to his role, his performance a reminder of why he’s one of Bollywood’s most reliable character actors. Mrunal Thakur’s Shivani is less developed—she’s often relegated to the role of the "smart woman who sees through the lies," a trope that feels tired even when played with sincerity.

But there’s a moment, late in the film, where she confronts Arjun, her voice trembling with frustration, that cuts through the noise. It’s a small beat, but it’s real, and it’s the kind of detail that makes you wish the film had trusted its actors more.

The craft, unfortunately, doesn’t always rise to the occasion. The cinematography is uneven, veering between moody and muddy, and the art department’s attention to detail is… questionable. (At one point, blood is the wrong color.

Not "stylized" wrong, just "we didn’t bother to check" wrong.) The film’s use of title cards—"The Crime," "The Investigation," "The Twist"—feels like a crutch, as if the story isn’t confident enough to guide the audience on its own. Film Companion put it best: "The most shocking twist is that it’s (occasionally) fun." And it’s true, in a way. There’s a certain guilty pleasure in watching Gumraah stumble through its own narrative, like a drunk man trying to walk a straight line.

You know it’s not working, but you can’t look away.

A close-up of Aditya Roy Kapur as Arjun, his face half-lit, the tension in his eyes betraying the weight of suspicion

What Gumraah ultimately lacks is a sense of purpose. Remakes are tricky beasts—they need to justify their existence, either by reimagining the source material or by finding something new in the familiar. Gumraah does neither. It’s content to be a pale imitation, a film that hits the same beats as Thadam but without the original’s nuance or sophistication.

There’s a moment, near the end, where the film seems to acknowledge its own limitations. Arjun, staring at his reflection, asks, "Who am I?" It’s a question that lingers, not because it’s profound, but because the film never bothers to answer it.

I left Gumraah with a strange mix of frustration and curiosity. Frustration, because it’s clear what the film could have been—a taut, atmospheric thriller about identity and deception. Curiosity, because Aditya Roy Kapur’s performance makes me wonder what he might do with a script that actually trusts him.

There’s a kernel of something interesting here, buried under layers of lazy writing and half-baked execution. Maybe that’s the real twist: Gumraah isn’t a bad film. It’s just a film that doesn’t know what it wants to be.

And in a genre built on certainty, that’s the most damning flaw of all.

Audience Opinions

Broad evidence
Audience 6.8/10
"A gripping premise with solid performances, undercut by predictable twists and uneven pacing."

The plot about lookalike suspects is intriguing, and the lead performances stand out, especially Aditya Roy Kapur's dual role. The film leans on familiar thriller tropes and slows down in the second half, and its characters lack depth.

What viewers praise
  • Engaging premise Lookalike suspects in a murder investigation is a fresh, intriguing concept.
  • Strong lead performance Aditya Roy Kapur's dual role is a standout; he clearly differentiates the two characters.
  • Good first-half pacing The setup and twists in the first half are engaging and well executed.
Common complaints
  • Predictable twists The twists and resolution are too familiar for the genre.
  • Slow second half The pacing drags in the latter part and the film loses momentum.
  • Underdeveloped characters Supporting characters, including the female lead, lack depth and screen presence.
  • Mixed execution The strong premise is never fully capitalized on, and the execution is uneven.
Recommended for
Thriller enthusiasts Fans of crime mysteries Aditya Roy Kapur admirers Plot-driven story lovers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Aditya Roy Kapur’s Dual Challenge: The Making of Gumraah (2023)

Gumraah, the 2023 Hindi-language action thriller directed by Vardhan Ketkar, promised a high-stakes narrative from the outset. The film, a remake of the 2019 Tamil hit Thadam, hinged on a murder mystery complicated by the discovery of two lookalike suspects—both played by Aditya Roy Kapur in a dual role. latestnetflix.com's read is that For Kapur, this wasn’t just another project; it was a chance to flex his acting range in a genre dominated by twist-driven storytelling.

A Remake with High Expectations

Gumraah arrived as a remake of Thadam, a film that had already carved its niche in the Tamil film industry. The original’s premise—a murder investigation unraveling due to identical suspects—was a tightrope walk for any actor, let alone one taking on both roles. Kapur’s casting as Arjun Sehgal and Ronnie, the two lookalikes at the center of the storm, was a bold move. The film’s success would depend on his ability to differentiate the characters while keeping the audience guessing.

The pressure was palpable. Remakes often invite comparisons, and Gumraah was no exception. However, the film’s producers, T-Series Films, seemed confident in Ketkar’s vision. The director, known for his work in the thriller space, was tasked with adapting the story for a Hindi-speaking audience while retaining the original’s suspenseful core.

Kapur’s Dual Role: A Test of Versatility

Aditya Roy Kapur’s decision to take on dual roles in Gumraah was a calculated risk. The actor, who had previously delivered strong performances in films like Malang and Sadak 2, was no stranger to intense, character-driven roles. But Gumraah demanded more—it required him to embody two distinct personalities, each with their own motivations and flaws.

Kapur’s portrayal of Arjun and Ronnie wasn’t just about physical resemblance. The characters had to feel like separate individuals, with their own mannerisms, speech patterns, and emotional arcs. Early buzz suggested that Kapur rose to the challenge, though the film’s reception would ultimately hinge on whether audiences bought into the illusion.

The supporting cast—Mrunal Thakur, Ronit Roy, Vedika Pinto, and others—played crucial roles in grounding the story. Thakur, in particular, was cast as the female lead, adding emotional depth to the otherwise male-dominated narrative. Roy, a veteran of the industry, brought gravitas to his role as the investigating officer, balancing the film’s high-octane moments with procedural tension.

Behind the Scenes: The Thriller’s Production

Details about Gumraah’s production remain sparse, but a few key points stand out. The film was produced by T-Series Films, a powerhouse in the Indian film industry known for backing high-profile projects. The collaboration with Ketkar, a director with a knack for thrillers, suggested a deliberate push to create a commercially viable yet critically engaging film.

One of the biggest challenges for the team would have been the logistics of shooting dual roles. Kapur’s scenes as both Arjun and Ronnie required precise choreography, from camera angles to lighting, to maintain the illusion of two distinct characters. While no behind-the-scenes footage or interviews have surfaced to confirm the specifics, it’s safe to assume that the production leaned heavily on visual effects and meticulous editing to pull off the lookalike dynamic.

**The Verdict: Did Gumraah Deliver?**

Gumraah’s premise was undeniably intriguing—a murder mystery with a doppelgänger twist is a rare find in Hindi cinema. However, the film’s success would depend on whether the execution lived up to the hype. Early indications suggested that Kapur’s dual performance was a standout, but the film’s pacing and narrative clarity would be equally critical.

The remake angle also invited scrutiny. Thadam had already set a high bar, and Gumraah needed to offer something fresh to justify its existence. Whether it managed to do so remains a topic of debate among fans and critics alike. What’s clear, though, is that the film represented a significant step for Kapur, who continues to push boundaries in his choice of roles.

The Road Ahead

For Aditya Roy Kapur, Gumraah was more than just another film—it was a statement. The actor has been steadily building a reputation for taking on challenging roles, and his dual performance in this thriller only reinforced that image. While the film’s box office and critical reception may have been mixed, it undeniably added another layer to Kapur’s evolving career.

As for Vardhan Ketkar, Gumraah marked another entry in his filmography as a director capable of handling high-concept thrillers. Whether he’ll return to the genre remains to be seen, but for now, the film shows his ability to adapt and innovate within familiar frameworks.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.