Skip to main content
Series poster for Smother-in-Law (2022)

Smother-in-Law

2022
Canceled • 2 Seasons • 20 Episodes
TV-MA · Portuguese
Search on Netflix

Overview

Living with her family since the pandemic struck, the meddling Isadir does her best to disrupt the lives of her bumbling son and rival daughter-in-law.

Seasons

Status
Canceled
Seasons
2 seasons
Episodes
20 episodes
First aired
Apr 13, 2022

Reviews

4 min read

The Lockdown Comedy That Forgot to Be Funny

I’ll admit it: I went into Smother-in-Law expecting a pandemic-era sitcom with teeth. The premise—an overbearing mother-in-law moving in during lockdown, turning domestic life into a battleground of passive-aggressive notes and stolen yogurts—had potential. Lockdown was a petri dish for family dysfunction, and comedy thrives on friction.

But somewhere between the setup and the punchlines, the series loses its way, mistaking volume for wit and caricature for character.

That’s not to say it doesn’t try. The first image I have of the show is this: a cramped apartment kitchen, the kind where every surface is either sticky or cluttered, and in the middle of it stands Isadir (we’re never told her last name, which feels like a missed opportunity). She’s the kind of woman who wears a cardigan like armor, her posture rigid with the certainty that she knows best.

The camera lingers on her hands—always moving, always rearranging, always judging—as she “accidentally” throws out her daughter-in-law’s favorite mug. It’s a small moment, but it’s the closest the show comes to understanding its own premise. The problem is that it never builds on it.

A cramped apartment kitchen, cluttered with mismatched dishes and a fridge covered in notes, where Isadir stands with her arms crossed, looking disapproving.

The series is billed as a comedy, but the humor often feels like it was written by someone who’s only heard about jokes, not actually told one. Take the running gag about Isadir’s “secret” stash of toilet paper—remember the great TP shortage of 2020?—which she hoards like a dragon on a gold pile. It’s a relatable premise, but the execution is so heavy-handed that it plays more like a public service announcement than satire.

The laugh track (yes, there’s a laugh track) doesn’t help. It’s the kind of canned reaction that makes you feel like you’re being told when to find something funny, which is the opposite of how comedy works. You can almost hear the writers in the room, high-fiving over how clever they think they’re being.

And then there’s the daughter-in-law, whose name I can’t remember because the show never bothers to make her more than a punching bag. She’s the straight woman to Isadir’s antics, but she’s given no agency, no quirks, no life beyond being the target of her mother-in-law’s meddling. It’s a tired dynamic, the kind that sitcoms have been recycling since Everybody Loves Raymond, but without the charm or the chemistry.

The son, meanwhile, is a bumbling man-child who exists solely to be scolded by his mother and ignored by his wife. If this is a family, it’s one that’s been assembled from spare parts.

A tense family dinner scene, with Isadir at the head of the table, her son looking exasperated, and the daughter-in-law staring blankly at her plate.

What’s frustrating is that the show almost lands on something interesting. There’s a moment in the second episode where Isadir, after a particularly vicious argument, retreats to the balcony and lights a cigarette. The camera holds on her face as she exhales, and for a second, you see something real: exhaustion, maybe even loneliness.

It’s the kind of quiet beat that could have humanized her, but the show immediately undercuts it with a slapstick fall involving a garden gnome. The message is clear: Smother-in-Law isn’t interested in depth, only in the next joke—even if the joke isn’t funny.

That’s not to say there aren’t flashes of potential. The apartment setting is a smart choice, a pressure cooker of shared space and frayed nerves. And there are a few lines that land, usually when the show leans into the absurdity of lockdown life.

(A throwaway bit about Isadir trying to “social distance” from her own family by measuring out six feet with a tape measure in the living room is the closest the series comes to being clever.) But these moments are few and far between, drowned out by the noise of the laugh track and the relentless pacing. It’s as if the writers were so afraid of silence that they filled every second with something, even if that something wasn’t worth saying.

Isadir standing on a balcony, smoking a cigarette and looking out at the city, her expression unreadable.

The series’ TMDB audience score of 5.8/10 feels about right, though I suspect even that might be generous. It’s the kind of show that’s easy to put on in the background while you scroll through your phone, but hard to remember once it’s over. That’s not necessarily a crime—plenty of sitcoms are designed to be disposable—but Smother-in-Law doesn’t even seem to be trying to be memorable.

It’s content to coast on the laziest tropes of the genre: the nagging mother-in-law, the put-upon wife, the man-child husband. There’s no subversion, no fresh perspective, no point.

And that’s the real shame. Lockdown was a shared trauma, a time when families were forced into close quarters and forced to confront the cracks in their relationships. It was ripe for comedy, but also for something deeper—a chance to explore how we love and resent the people we’re stuck with. Smother-in-Law had the ingredients for that kind of story, but it never bothers to cook them.

Instead, it serves up reheated leftovers, seasoned with a laugh track and a side of eye rolls.

In the end, the show is a missed opportunity. It’s not offensive, just forgettable. And in a year that gave us The Bear’s kitchen chaos and Abbott Elementary’s classroom heart, forgettable is the last thing a comedy should be.

Audience Opinions

"A lighthearted comedy with mixed reactions to its humor and premise."

*Smother-in-Law* is a straightforward comedy built on a premise of familial chaos, and opinions vary on whether the jokes land consistently. Its breezy tone earns some laughs, while the execution strikes others as predictable and shallow. Feedback is sparse, so broader appeal is hard to gauge.

What viewers praise
  • Light and breezy An easy watch for anyone after uncomplicated comedy without heavy themes.
  • Premise potential The mother-in-law dynamic is a relatable setup ripe for comedic situations.
Common complaints
  • Predictable humor The jokes and scenarios feel too familiar, without fresh twists.
  • Uneven execution The comedy doesn’t always hit the mark, and some moments fall flat.
Recommended for
Casual comedy fans Family sitcom lovers Light entertainment seekers

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Decider said skip it. Netflix Brazil ordered more.

Joel Keller's April 13, 2022 Decider column called Smother-in-Law, original title A Sogra Que Te Pariu, Netflix's first Brazilian multicamera sitcom and then told English readers to skip it. He clocked the episodes around 26 minutes, compared the broad pacing to old Univision and Telemundo sitcoms, latestnetflix.com contends, and flagged the "cow" insult Dona Isadir throws at her daughter-in-law on sight. The official trailer still sells that living-room war, clay water filter and all.,

The character is the joke and the business. Rodrigo Sant'Anna created, wrote, and stars as Dona Isadir Queiroz, a Cachambi mother who parks herself in son Carlos's Barra da Tijuca mansion when Rio lockdowns start in March 2020. Rafael Zulu plays Carlos. Lidi Lisboa plays Alice, the lawyer Isadir wants replaced. Portuguese Wikipedia puts Suburbanos Producoes on the line, Alex Cabral on season 1, Marco Rodrigo on season 2, ten episodes per year, 20 to 25 minutes, 4K multicam. Netflix's English synopsis still says the meddling Isadir "does her best to disrupt the lives of her bumbling son and rival daughter-in-law." Grandkids Jonas and Marcia sit in the crossfire. Housekeeper Marinez watches. Friends Fatima and Cezinha come over for barbecues that never stay small.

Two weeks after launch, the skip-it note looked provincial. Estadão reported Netflix confirmed a second season after the show became the sixth most-watched non-English series on the service, with more than 11 million hours watched worldwide and a number-two series rank in Brazil for two weeks. Netflix's own renewal line, printed by Estadão, was not polite. "You asked, and there will be a second season of A Sogra Que Te Pariu, yes! And whoever thinks that's bad can go to hell!" Sant'Anna posted, "Very happy, Mrs. Netflix Brasil!" Wikipedia dates the formal renewal to April 29, 2022, during Rio2C. Season 2 dropped April 12, 2023. The new excuse for staying in the mansion, per Wikipedia, is a grandchild on the way, after a stretch that sends Isadir through jail, WhatsApp scams, and a crush. Lidi Lisboa even left her A Fazenda interview chair to shoot that second year.,

O Globo's Kogut column, March 11, 2023, said a third season was coming, with production in the second half of that year, on the back of that same global top-10 non-English run. As of the catalog, Netflix still lists two seasons. Treat the third year as an announced order that has not shown up as a drop.

The English title sells a mother-in-law gag. The Brazilian story is a drag comic who got a multicam original, a worldwide hours spike, and a renewal quote that sounded like Isadir wrote the press release herself.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.