Skip to main content
Series poster for The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge (2023)

The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge

2023
Ended • 1 Season • 10 Episodes
TV-PG · English
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

In this high-stakes "Nailed It!" spinoff competition, 10 novice bakers pick up tips from professional coaches while vying for a sweet cash prize.

Seasons

1 listed
Status
Ended
Seasons
1 season
Episodes
10 episodes
First aired
Aug 4, 2023
Last aired
Aug 4, 2023
Network
Netflix

Latest episode: S1 E10 Finale (Aug 4, 2023)

  1. Season 1 poster

    Season 1

    10 episodes Aug 4, 2023 1.0

Trailer

Official

Cast

Reviews

5 min read

The Great Bake-Off That Wasn’t (And Why That’s Okay)

I’ll admit it: I came to The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge with low expectations. Not because I dislike the Nailed It! franchise—I’ve laughed through enough of its glorious, frosting-smeared disasters to know its appeal—but because reality competition spinoffs often feel like they’re stretching a joke too thin. Ten episodes of amateur bakers vying for a reported budget?

That’s a lot of pressure for a show built on the joy of failure. And yet, somewhere between the first collapsed cake and Nicole Byer’s unhinged commentary, I found myself weirdly invested. Not in who would win, exactly, but in the way the show managed to turn its own limitations into something oddly charming.

A contestant stares in horror at their lopsided cake while Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres look on with amused expressions

The original Nailed It! was a masterclass in schadenfreude with a heart. Its genius lay in its simplicity: three home bakers, one impossible challenge, and the guarantee that at least one of them would produce something resembling a culinary crime scene. The show didn’t need stakes beyond the sheer delight of watching people try (and fail) to recreate Pinterest-perfect desserts.

But The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge tries to have it both ways—it wants to keep the chaos while adding the structure of a competition. The result is a show that’s neither fish nor fowl, and yet, somehow, that’s part of its appeal.

Take the format. Each episode follows a predictable rhythm: a quick tutorial from coaches Erin Jeanne McDowell and Robert Lucas, followed by a "Big Cake Bake" challenge where contestants put their newfound (and often shaky) skills to the test. The problem?

The tutorials are so brief they feel more like a formality than actual instruction. Watching a contestant attempt to pipe frosting after a two-minute demo is like watching someone try to perform brain surgery after a YouTube tutorial. The disconnect is intentional, of course—this is still Nailed It!, where the fun comes from the gap between ambition and execution—but the competition element muddies the waters.

When someone gets eliminated, it’s hard not to feel a pang of guilt, as if the show has betrayed its own ethos. Nailed It! was never about winning; it was about the glorious, messy process of trying.

And yet, the show’s heart remains in the right place. Nicole Byer is still the best thing about it. Her rapport with Jacques Torres is as effortless as ever, and her ability to pivot from mockery to genuine encouragement in the span of a single sentence is a skill I didn’t know I needed in my life.

There’s a moment in the first episode where a contestant’s cake collapses, and Byer doesn’t just laugh—she leans in, wide-eyed, and says, "Okay, but what if we just… call it abstract?" It’s a small thing, but it encapsulates the show’s spirit: the willingness to meet failure with creativity, even if that creativity is just rebranding a disaster as "modern art."

A contestant in a flour-dusted apron holds up a cake that looks more like a science experiment gone wrong

The critics, as they often do, have split opinions. The Wall Street Journal’s John Anderson called the show "a franchise without a destination," noting that the bakers "make a mess and move on," which is both true and missing the point. The mess is the point.

Decider’s Joel Keller enjoyed it but wondered if the show would lose its charm as contestants inevitably improved. (Spoiler: They don’t. The learning curve is steep, and the show’s editing ensures that even the most competent bakers still find ways to flail.) Reality Blurred’s Andy Dehnart was less kind, giving it a C- and calling the expansion a "step backward" that diluted the original’s chaotic charm.

But here’s the thing: The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge isn’t trying to be the original. It’s trying to be something else, and in its own awkward way, it succeeds.

That’s not to say it’s without flaws. The competition structure feels tacked on, like a network note that the show needed "more stakes." The a reported budget prize is a nice incentive, but it’s hard to care about the winner when the real joy comes from the losers—the ones who turn their failures into punchlines.

And the elimination rounds, while necessary for the format, feel like a betrayal of the show’s original spirit. Nailed It! was never about who could bake the best; it was about who could fail the most spectacularly. Here, the pressure to improve feels at odds with the show’s DNA.

But then there are moments that remind you why this franchise works. Like the consolation prize for eliminated contestants: a 60-second shopping spree in the pantry, where they can grab whatever kitchen tools they want. It’s a small gesture, but it’s pure Nailed It!—a way to soften the blow of elimination with something tangible, something silly.

Or the guest judges, like Patton Oswalt and Vanessa Bayer, who lean into the absurdity with the kind of deadpan humor that makes the whole thing feel like a inside joke you’re in on.

Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres stand behind a table covered in baking supplies, grinning at the camera

The show’s biggest strength might be its refusal to take itself too seriously. There’s no pretense of high art here, no attempt to elevate baking into something more than it is. It’s just a group of people trying their best (or, more often, their worst) in a kitchen, with Byer and Torres serving as the perfect ringleaders.

The Wall Street Journal’s critique about the franchise lacking a destination isn’t wrong, but maybe that’s the point. The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge isn’t going anywhere in particular, and that’s okay. It’s a show that’s content to wander, to meander, to let its contestants fail and laugh and occasionally succeed in spite of themselves.

And maybe that’s enough. In a landscape of prestige TV and high-stakes dramas, there’s something refreshing about a show that doesn’t pretend to be more than it is. It’s not trying to change the world; it’s just trying to make you laugh while a cake collapses in slow motion.

And honestly? That’s a relief. I don’t need every show to be a masterpiece.

Sometimes, I just need Nicole Byer to tell me that my life choices are questionable, and a group of strangers to remind me that failure is part of the process. Whether that’s worth ten episodes is debatable, but for a few hours, it’s exactly the kind of mindless joy I didn’t know I needed.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s "The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge" Serves Up Fresh Drama—But Is It Really Unscripted?

Netflix’s Nailed It! franchise has spent years celebrating baking fails with chaotic charm, but its 2023 spin-off, The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge, promised something bigger: a competition format with higher stakes, new faces, and a cash prize. Premiering on August 4, 2023, latestnetflix.com maintains, the series retained fan-favorite hosts Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres while introducing fresh elements—and fresh questions about whether the show’s reality-TV roots are as authentic as they seem.

A New Format, Familiar Faces

The original Nailed It! thrived on its lighthearted approach to baking disasters, but The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge shifted gears by pitting 10 amateur bakers against each other in a structured competition. Byer and Torres returned as hosts, joined by pastry chefs Erin Jeanne McDowell and Robert Lucas, who provided guidance (and occasional exasperation) to contestants. The twist? A cash prize awaited the baker who could "cross the finish line as the greatest," according to IMDb’s description.

The spin-off’s arrival wasn’t entirely unexpected. The Nailed It! brand had already expanded with themed specials, including a Halloween edition in 2022, and the franchise’s Emmy nominations—three for Outstanding Competition Program and two for Outstanding Host—proved its staying power. But The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge marked Netflix’s first attempt to turn the formula into a full-fledged competition series, complete with elimination rounds and a grand prize.

Scripted or Just Well-Planned?

Reality TV thrives on the illusion of spontaneity, and The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge is no exception. Netflix has billed the series as "a natural, reality, unscripted production through and through," emphasizing that while the challenges, cast selection, and set design are meticulously planned, the outcomes are organic. But skepticism lingers—especially among fans accustomed to the franchise’s more freewheeling style.

The show’s structure suggests a tighter narrative than the original Nailed It! Episodes feature clear arcs, with contestants receiving lessons from the pros before tackling high-pressure challenges. The addition of a cash prize also raises the stakes, potentially encouraging more dramatic moments—whether genuine or manufactured. Still, without behind-the-scenes leaks or cast interviews, it’s hard to say how much of the drama is organic. For now, Netflix’s insistence on the show’s unscripted nature remains the official line.

What’s Next for the Franchise?

As of now, The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge hasn’t been renewed for a second season, leaving its future uncertain. The original Nailed It! continues to release themed specials, but the spin-off’s competitive format may have been a one-time experiment. If Netflix does bring it back, expect more of the same: chaotic baking, Byer’s infectious energy, and Torres’ dry humor—with or without a script.

For now, fans can only hope the show’s blend of humor and competition finds its footing. Whether it’s truly unscripted or just brilliantly edited, The Big Nailed It Baking Challenge delivers exactly what the franchise does best: a mix of laughter, disaster, and the occasional edible masterpiece.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.