I'm still not sure what possessed me to start Just Alice. Maybe Netflix wore me down. Maybe I just wanted to see how long a show about one woman secretly marrying two men could keep itself upright before tipping into nonsense.
latestnetflix.com's view is that Whatever the reason, I watched all nineteen episodes, hit the finale, and sat there blinking with the peculiar daze that comes from spending that much time inside something both ridiculous and compelling.
Marta Betoldi reportedly came up with this Colombian dramedy's premise back in 2008, and you can understand why it took a while to reach the screen. A woman refuses to choose between her sci-fi novelist husband and her ex-priest lover, then solves the problem by marrying both of them in secret: on paper, that sounds less like a series and more like a dare. But Betoldi doesn't play the idea as camp, exactly.
She treats it with the straight face of a soap opera that knows absurdity is part of its fuel.
Everything depends on Verónica Orozco making Alicia feel like a person rather than a premise, and she absolutely does. Orozco has a wonderfully readable physical presence. She doesn't announce Alicia's guilt; she carries it.
Watch what happens when she lies to Alejo (Michel Brown): the smile brightens just a little too much, the shoulders lock, the fingers clamp down harder on the wine glass. You can feel the fatigue in the muscles. Decider's Joel Keller summed up the challenge well when he wrote that "While Orozco is a charming lead, Just Alice has a highly annoying premise that we know is going to have to make a lot of written somersaults to keep it going for the entire first season".
Fair enough. But the show survives precisely because it embraces those somersaults instead of pretending it won't need them.
The first-episode wedding sequence is the clearest example. Alicia is late to marry Pablo (Sebastián Carvajal), changes into her dress in a restaurant bathroom, then hurtles to the church on the back of a motorcycle driven by her battle-tested friend Susana (Cony Camelo). The scene is gloriously ridiculous, and the direction doesn't duck that.
Her veil whips in the wind, her breathing goes ragged, everything feels on the verge of farce. Then she reaches the altar and the whole rhythm changes. The camera steadies.
The noise recedes. For a brief moment, you understand the sincerity of what she's doing even as you know the lie underneath it is about to poison everything.
Brown and Carvajal help more than the premise would suggest. Brown plays Alejo with a loose, comfortable charm that never tips into idiothood; he feels less duped than serenely established in his own world. Carvajal gives Pablo a very different shape, all held-in guilt and spiritual residue, like leaving the priesthood is something his body still hasn't finished apologizing for.
Put them side by side—Brown's relaxed slouch, Carvajal's rigid, half-penitent stance—and Alicia's divided desire suddenly makes emotional sense even when the plot goes fully operatic.
The show definitely wears out its welcome in the middle. Srijoni Rudra at Digital Mafia Talkies called it "a predictable and highly dramatized show that you must only commit to if you have the time and is only worth considering as a second-screen guilty pleasure watch", which is harsher than I'd put it but not baseless. The narrative has to work overtime to keep Alicia's secret intact, and eventually that means one contrived near-miss after another.
By episode fifteen, you may want to throw something soft at the TV.
Still, beneath all the soap mechanics, Just Alice is circling a real question about desire, marriage, and the impossible shapes women are asked to fit themselves into. Alicia's bigamy isn't framed as simple cruelty. It's a desperate, messy effort to refuse the usual bargain, the one where a woman is expected to amputate part of herself and call it maturity.
Does that idea justify nineteen episodes of escalating deception? Probably not entirely. But I'd rather spend time with a show this gloriously untidy than another polished, bloodless series that never risks embarrassment. Just Alice is overextended, occasionally maddening, and impossible to dismiss.
It leaves a smudge.
Audience Opinions
Audience 5.5/10
"A chaotic, soapy bigamy dramedy with a fun premise and lively cast that gets bogged down by an overlong run, shaky writing, and a deeply frustrating lead."
The double-marriage setup, steamy entanglements, and Verónica Orozco’s committed performance keep the show watchable and often entertaining, bingeable despite misgivings. At the same time, Alicia’s hypocrisy and indecision, the dragged-out 19-episode structure, and a predictable, unsatisfying ending leave many feeling the idea had far more potential than the execution delivers.
What viewers praise
Offbeat bigamy premiseThe story of a woman secretly married to two men offers a fresh spin on the usual love triangle and creates constant dramatic tension.
Entertaining guilty pleasure toneThe mix of comedy, melodrama, and romantic chaos makes for an easy, soapy binge that some find surprisingly addictive.
Charismatic lead actressVerónica Orozco is compelling and versatile, giving the messy character more weight and energy than the script alone provides.
Lively supporting castSeveral secondary characters and the two husbands are engaging and fun to follow, sometimes more appealing than Alicia herself.
Emotional impactDespite the silliness, certain episodes and character beats land as genuinely sad or touching, leaving some viewers conflicted and invested.
Common complaints
Unappealing main characterAlicia’s constant lying, selfish choices, and lack of growth make her hard to root for, with some finding her outright annoying or miscast.
Excessive length and paddingThe 19-episode season feels overextended, with filler subplots and pacing issues that could easily have been trimmed by several episodes.
Predictable, weak endingThe final stretch, including Alicia’s closing speech and the resolution of the triangle, comes off as rushed, clichéd, and less profound than intended.
Inconsistent executionThe show is entertaining but sloppily made, with tonal swings, forced backstories, and plotting that can feel lazy or illogical.
Questionable moral framingAttempts to wrap bigamy and serial lying in a loose message about free love or polyamory are unconvincing or mishandled.
Recommended for
Soapy romantic dramedy fans Guilty-pleasure binge watchers Colombian TV and telenovela fans Love-triangle drama enthusiasts Verónica Orozco followers Light background-watch seekers
Buzz & Rumors
Public reports
Netflix sold her two husbands as a delightful disaster.
The official Tudum piece does not whisper. Krutika Mallikarjuna's deep dive opens with one woman in love, two husbands, and a million little lies, latestnetflix.com maintains, then calls the mix a delightful recipe for disaster. That is house copy. The streamer is proud of the bigamy.
Alicia Fernandez, played by Veronica Orozco of Eva Lasting, spends the first episode sprinting to marry Pablo, a former priest, while missing a live stream of her other husband's book launch. Pablo thinks she is a flight attendant who pops in and out of Bogota. She is a political campaign manager. Alejo, the sci-fi writer played by Michel Brown of The Marked Heart, has already had five years with her. Neither man knows the other exists. Tudum prints all of that as the logline, not as a leak.
Ten Colombian titles, one of them a double marriage.
In July 2025 Netflix announced a ten-title Colombian slate. The Hollywood Reporter listed Just Alice, or Simplemente Alicia, as a dark comedy about a woman balancing two marriages. Variety's exclusive went further. When fate demands that Alicia choose between Alejo and Pablo, she chooses both. Female bigamy may not be a crime, the copy said, but the fallout can be life-altering. RCN Studios produces. Rafael Martinez and Catalina Hernandez direct. Juan Pablo Posada and Daniel Ucros executive produce. Marta Betoldi and Esteban del Campo Bagu write. Nineteen episodes dropped together on November 5, 2025.,,
Colombia had already been eating the Spanish-language hours. Collider, citing Variety, noted that in the second half of 2024 Spanish-language Netflix viewing hit an estimated 2.59 billion hours, with Colombia at 24.6 percent of the Latin American share. This show is the soapy half of that bet, sitting next to a Palace of Justice siege drama and a James Rodriguez documentary.
One critic called it a binge. One said skip it.
Kelcie Mattson at Collider watched the first five of nineteen and scored it 7/10. She called it a telenovela on a Netflix budget and wrote that the premise would not be sexy or entertaining if the genders were reversed. Joel Keller at Decider went the other way. Skip it. Orozco is a charming lead, he said, but the show has a highly annoying premise that will need a lot of written somersaults to last a full season. Common Sense Media's Joly Herman split the difference at 3/5 and pointed it at Sex and the City fans. Digital Mafia Talkies later complained that nineteen episodes is a massive commitment for a wafer-thin plot.,,
The soundtrack did more work than some of the reviews. Tudum flagged Shakira. El Comercio's episode list puts her track "Sombra de Ti" in episode 17, with Gloria Trevi, Daniela Romo, and Mon Laferte elsewhere. Netflix Latinoamerica posted the official avance on October 8. The English title is Just Alice. The gossip is not whether she gets caught. The gossip is that the platform spent a Colombian slate slot on a woman who refuses to pick, then watched English-language critics fight over whether that is fun or exhausting.,,
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as
unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Related series
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.