Skip to main content
Series poster for The Indian Detective (2017)

The Indian Detective

2017
Ended • 1 Season • 4 Episodes
14 · English
Director: Sandy Johnson
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A Toronto police officer gets involved in a homicide investigation while visiting his father in Mumbai.

Seasons

1 listed
Status
Ended
Seasons
1 season
Episodes
4 episodes
First aired
Nov 23, 2017
Last aired
Dec 14, 2017
Episode length
40m
Network
CTV

Latest episode: S1 E4 Episode 4 (Dec 14, 2017)

  1. Season 1 poster

    Season 1

    4 episodes Nov 23, 2017 6.1
    1. 1 Episode 1
    2. 2 Episode 2
    3. 3 Episode 3
    4. 4 Episode 4

Trailer

Cast

7 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Joke That Got Lost in Translation

I’ll admit it: I went into The Indian Detective expecting a Russell Peters stand-up special with a plot. That’s not entirely fair—it’s a four-episode Netflix series, not a comedy tour—but the man’s reputation precedes him. Peters, the Toronto-born comedian whose observational humor about cultural identity has made him a global name, carries this show on his shoulders, and the question hanging over it is simple: Can a man who built his career on the stage translate that razor-sharp wit into a narrative that doesn’t just feel like a string of punchlines?

The answer, unfortunately, is a qualified no. Not because Peters isn’t trying, or because the premise—Doug D’Mello, a Toronto cop visiting his estranged father in Mumbai, stumbles into a murder investigation—isn’t promising. But somewhere between the cultural fish-out-of-water gags and the half-hearted crime procedural, the series loses the thread of what makes Peters’ comedy work in the first place: the tension between expectation and reality, the way identity is both a performance and a prison.

Here, that tension feels more like a checklist than a lived experience.

A neon-lit Mumbai street at night, with Doug D’Mello standing under a flickering sign, looking overwhelmed.

The first episode sets up the stakes well enough. Doug (Peters) is a constable in Toronto, more comfortable cracking jokes than cracking cases, and his latest botched drug bust sends him fleeing to Mumbai to visit his father, Stan (Anupam Kher), a retired cop with a disapproving glare and a heart of gold. The dynamic between them is the show’s strongest element—Stan’s disappointment is palpable, Doug’s defensiveness even more so—and it’s the kind of material Peters could mine for pathos if he weren’t so busy playing the lovable goof.

There’s a moment in the first episode where Doug, trying to impress his father, puts on a police uniform and immediately trips over his own feet, knocking over a tray of chai. It’s a classic Peters bit, the kind of physical comedy that works in a stand-up routine but feels tonally jarring in a scene that’s supposed to be about a fractured father-son relationship.

That’s the problem, really. The Indian Detective wants to be a lot of things at once: a family drama, a crime procedural, a fish-out-of-water comedy, a love letter to Mumbai. It’s ambitious, but ambition without focus is just noise. The murder plot—centered on William Shatner’s billionaire villain, David Marlowe—feels like an afterthought, a way to give Doug something to do besides wander the streets of Mumbai looking bewildered.

Shatner, to his credit, leans into the campiness of his role, but the investigation itself is so perfunctory that it’s hard to care who killed whom or why. The procedural elements are there to service the comedy, but the comedy is too often there to service the procedural, and the result is a show that’s neither funny enough nor compelling enough to justify its own existence.

What’s frustrating is that the ingredients for something special are all here. Mumbai is a vibrant, chaotic backdrop, and the series doesn’t shy away from showing its contrasts—the neon-lit streets, the crowded markets, the quiet moments of reflection in a city that never sleeps. There’s a scene in the second episode where Doug, lost in the city, ends up at a street food stall and bonds with the vendor over their shared love of Toronto.

It’s a small moment, but it’s the kind of thing that could have grounded the series in something real, something human. Instead, it’s quickly undercut by a slapstick chase sequence that feels like it belongs in a different show entirely.

Peters is a charismatic lead, but the script doesn’t give him much to work with beyond his stand-up persona. His Doug is a man who’s spent his life using humor as a shield, and there are glimpses of the vulnerability beneath the jokes—like when he admits to his love interest, Robyn (Christina Cole), that he’s not sure he’s ever really belonged anywhere. But these moments are few and far between, and they’re often drowned out by the show’s insistence on keeping things light.

It’s as if the writers are afraid to let Doug be anything other than the funny guy, even when the story calls for something deeper.

The supporting cast is a mixed bag. Anupam Kher brings warmth and gravitas to Stan, but his character is mostly relegated to the sidelines, popping up to deliver a withering one-liner before disappearing again. Christina Cole’s Robyn is a serviceable love interest, but her character feels like a placeholder, a way to give Doug someone to flirt with while the plot meanders along.

The real standout is Mishqah Parthiephal as Priya, a Mumbai police officer who becomes Doug’s reluctant partner. She’s sharp, no-nonsense, and the only character who seems to exist in the same world as the audience. Her chemistry with Peters is electric, and it’s a shame the show doesn’t lean into it more.

If there’s a saving grace to The Indian Detective, it’s the way it captures the push and pull of cultural identity. Doug is a man caught between two worlds—too Indian for Canada, too Canadian for India—and the series does a decent job of showing how that tension plays out in his interactions with others. There’s a scene where he tries to order food in Hindi and butchers the pronunciation so badly that the waiter just stares at him in silence.

It’s a small moment, but it’s the kind of thing that resonates because it’s rooted in something real. Peters has built his career on mining these kinds of experiences for comedy, and when the show lets him do that, it works. The problem is that it doesn’t let him do it often enough.

In the end, The Indian Detective feels like a missed opportunity. It’s not a bad show, but it’s not a particularly good one either. It’s the kind of series that’s easy to watch but hard to remember, a pleasant enough diversion that doesn’t leave much of an impression once it’s over.

That’s not nothing—there’s value in entertainment that doesn’t demand too much of its audience—but it’s not the kind of thing that lingers. Peters deserves better, Mumbai deserves better, and audiences deserve better than a show that’s content to coast on its premise without ever really digging into what makes it interesting.

Maybe that’s the real joke. The Indian Detective had all the right pieces, but it never figured out how to put them together. And in the end, that’s the punchline no one saw coming.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.8/10
"A lighthearted crime-comedy with some charm that struggles to balance humor and plot depth."

Russell Peters' comedic presence and the show's cross-cultural premise provide some entertainment, particularly for fans of his stand-up. The series is uneven, though: the humor often feels forced and the crime elements are underdeveloped.

What viewers praise
  • Russell Peters' performance Peters' comedic timing and familiar stand-up persona make his character the highlight.
  • Cross-cultural premise The fish-out-of-water setup between Canadian and Indian law enforcement yields fresh, amusing dynamics.
  • Lighthearted tone The comedic take on crime drama makes it an easy, undemanding watch.
Common complaints
  • Forced humor Some jokes fall flat or lean too heavily on Peters' stand-up style.
  • Underdeveloped plot The crime elements take a backseat to comedy, leaving the mystery shallow or rushed.
  • Uneven pacing Some episodes drag or feel disjointed.
Recommended for
Russell Peters fans Light crime-comedy seekers Cross-cultural humor lovers Casual binge-watchers

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Russell Peters Brings Mumbai to Netflix in The Indian Detective

Comedian Russell Peters stepped into uncharted territory with The Indian Detective, the 2017 Netflix series that blended crime drama with his signature humor. The show marked Peters’ first major foray into scripted television as both star and executive producer, following a career built on stand-up specials and guest roles. Set against the neon-lit streets of Mumbai, the series promised a fresh twist on the detective genre—one where Peters’ Toronto-raised cop, Doug D’Mello, latestnetflix.com contends, navigates the chaos of Indian law enforcement while reconnecting with his roots.

A Comedy-Drama Hybrid with High Stakes

The Indian Detective leaned into Peters’ strengths: cultural clashes, fish-out-of-water humor, and sharp observational comedy. The trailer teased a mix of action and wit, with Peters’ Doug D’Mello caught between two worlds—his Canadian upbringing and his father’s Indian heritage. The show’s tone balanced crime-solving with family drama, a formula that appealed to fans of Peters’ stand-up, where personal identity often took center stage.

Behind the scenes, Peters made it clear this wasn’t just another guest role. In a CTV interview, he described the project as a passion piece, emphasizing the importance of representing Indian culture on a global platform like Netflix. The series arrived on the streaming service on December 19, 2017, capitalizing on the holiday binge-watching season.

The Cast: A Mix of Veterans and Fresh Faces

Peters wasn’t alone in carrying the show. The ensemble included Star Trek legend William Shatner as Doug’s skeptical boss, Rob Ford, and Bollywood icon Anupam Kher as his estranged father, Stanley D’Mello. Kher’s role, in particular, added emotional weight to the series, with clips highlighting the strained relationship between father and son.

Supporting players like Mishqah Parthiephal (as Doug’s love interest, Priya) and Christina Cole (as his Canadian colleague, Gina) rounded out the cast. Hamza Haq and Meren Reddy also appeared in key roles, though details about their characters remain sparse in the available evidence. The chemistry between Peters and Kher, however, was a standout, with Peters joking in interviews about the surreal experience of working alongside a Bollywood legend.

Behind the Camera: A Director’s Mismatch?

The series was created and directed by Sandy Johnson, an American actress best known for her role as Judith Myers in Halloween (1978). Johnson’s background in horror and modeling raised eyebrows—this was her first major directorial credit for a comedy-drama. While the evidence doesn’t clarify how Johnson landed the gig, her involvement added an unexpected layer to the production.

Peters, for his part, seemed unfazed by the creative pairing. In a behind-the-scenes clip, he praised the Mumbai shoot, calling it a "dream come true" for an Indian-Canadian like himself. The city’s vibrant energy seeped into the show’s aesthetic, from bustling markets to high-speed chases through crowded streets.

The Verdict: A Cult Favorite or a Missed Opportunity?

The Indian Detective arrived with buzz but faded quickly from the conversation. Netflix never renewed it for a second season, leaving fans to speculate about its abrupt end. Rumors swirled about creative differences or budget constraints, but no official statements confirmed either. The show’s limited promotional footprint—mostly confined to Peters’ social media and YouTube clips —suggested a quieter rollout than expected.

Still, the series carved out a niche. Clips like "Between Two Women" and "The Indian Law" showcased Peters’ ability to balance humor with drama, a skill that translated well from stand-up to scripted TV. For a comedian known for pushing boundaries, The Indian Detective was a bold experiment—even if it didn’t stick the landing.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.