
Girls Incarcerated
Overview
An eight-part documentary series that goes behind the scenes at Madison Juvenile Correctional Facility in Indiana, where teenage girls struggle to overcome their troubled pasts and find hope for the future.
Seasons
- Status
- Ended
- Seasons
- 2 seasons
- Episodes
- 16 episodes
- First aired
- Mar 1, 2018
Reviews
4 min readThe Walls That Talk Back
I didn’t expect to care this much about a place I’ll never visit. Madison Juvenile Correctional Facility in Indiana isn’t exactly the kind of setting that invites casual curiosity—it’s a locked door, a system, a last resort. But Girls Incarcerated doesn’t just peer through the bars; it hands you a set of keys and says, Here, listen. And once you start listening, it’s hard to look away.
The series follows a group of teenage girls serving time for crimes that range from theft to assault to more serious offenses. The cameras don’t flinch from the harshness of their lives—broken homes, addiction, abuse, the kind of poverty that grinds people down before they’ve even had a chance to grow up. But what’s striking isn’t the bleakness; it’s the way the girls refuse to be defined by it.
They laugh, they fight, they scheme, they cry. They’re still kids, even when the system treats them like adults. That tension—between childhood and punishment, between hope and the weight of what’s already been lost—is the series’ quiet, insistent heartbeat.

There’s a moment in the first episode that sticks with me. A girl named Taryn, who looks no older than 15, is talking about why she’s there. She’s matter-of-fact, almost bored, as she describes the fight that landed her in Madison.
But then she pauses, and her voice cracks just a little. “I don’t even know why I did it,” she says. It’s not an apology. It’s not an excuse.
It’s the sound of someone realizing, maybe for the first time, that her actions have consequences she can’t outrun. The camera lingers on her face, and you can see the exact second she shuts down again, retreating behind the armor of teenage indifference. That’s the series in a nutshell: these girls are experts at hiding their pain, but the cracks keep showing.
What makes Girls Incarcerated different from other prison documentaries isn’t just its focus on young women—though that’s rare enough—but its refusal to sensationalize. There are no dramatic reenactments, no ominous voiceovers telling you how to feel. The filmmakers trust the girls to tell their own stories, and the result is something far more intimate than most true-crime fare.
We see them in therapy sessions, where they’re asked to confront the trauma they’ve spent years burying. We see them in the classroom, struggling to focus on algebra when their minds are elsewhere. We see them in the yard, where friendships form and alliances shift, where a shared cigarette can mean everything or nothing at all.

The series doesn’t shy away from the ugliness of incarceration, but it also doesn’t reduce these girls to their worst moments. There’s a scene where two of them, locked in a petty rivalry, get into a screaming match in the hallway. The guards intervene, and one of the girls is dragged away, still shouting.
It’s chaotic, messy, real. But later, we see the same two girls sitting together in the common area, not quite friends, but not enemies either. They’re just two kids trying to survive a system that wasn’t built for them.
That’s the thing about Girls Incarcerated—it doesn’t offer easy answers. It doesn’t tell you whether these girls deserve second chances or whether the system is failing them (though, let’s be honest, it’s failing them). It just shows you what’s there: the pain, the resilience, the moments of grace that flicker even in the darkest places.
The craft of the series is unobtrusive but effective. The camerawork is observational, almost fly-on-the-wall, but it’s not passive. There’s a rhythm to the editing that mirrors the ebb and flow of life inside Madison—long stretches of quiet punctuated by sudden bursts of emotion.
The sound design is particularly strong; you hear the clank of doors, the murmur of voices, the way laughter can turn to tears in an instant. It’s immersive without being manipulative, which is harder to pull off than it looks.
What lingers, though, isn’t the technical skill. It’s the girls themselves. There’s Brianna, who dreams of being a nurse but can’t seem to stay out of trouble.
There’s Megan, whose sharp tongue hides a deep well of insecurity. There’s Taryn, who oscillates between defiance and vulnerability, as if she’s not sure which version of herself she’s supposed to be. They’re not saints.
They’re not victims. They’re complicated, messy, infuriating, and sometimes heartbreakingly kind. In other words, they’re human.

I keep thinking about something one of the girls says in the final episode. She’s talking about what she wants to do when she gets out, and for a second, she lets herself imagine it—a job, a home, a life that doesn’t involve bars. Then she catches herself and laughs. “I don’t even know if that’s possible,” she says.
It’s a throwaway line, but it’s also the whole point of the series. These girls have been told, in ways both subtle and overt, that they don’t deserve second chances. Girls Incarcerated doesn’t argue with that. It just asks you to look at them—to really look—and decide for yourself.
I don’t know if this series will change anyone’s mind about the justice system. I don’t know if it will inspire policy changes or spark a national conversation. But I do know this: it made me care about a group of girls I’ve never met, in a place I’ll never go.
And in a world where it’s easier than ever to look away, that feels like something.
Audience Opinions
"A raw, emotional look at juvenile detention that lands despite uneven execution."
The series is praised for its unfiltered portrayal of young women in the justice system, a perspective rarely seen in documentaries. Critics say it does little to explore the root causes of incarceration and sometimes favors sensationalism over substance.
- Authentic portrayal It offers a rare, honest glimpse into the lives of incarcerated teenage girls.
- Emotional impact The girls' stories are compelling and often heartbreaking.
- Inspirational moments Moments of resilience and hope offer a sense of redemption for some of the young women featured.
- Lacks depth The series skims the surface of systemic issues, leaving key questions about the justice system unanswered.
- Sensationalized at times It sometimes prioritizes dramatic moments over the girls' backgrounds and challenges.
- Uneven focus It jumps between subjects without enough follow-through, so some stories feel incomplete.
Buzz & Rumors
Public reportsThe jail was already empty when Netflix hit play.
Madison Juvenile Correctional Facility closed in October 2017. The Indiana Department of Correction moved the girls to Camp Summit in LaPorte so the adult women's prison next door could take the beds. Netflix still dropped Girls Incarcerated: Young and Locked Up on March 2, 2018, five months later, as if the burgundy campus in Madison were still running. In Touch Weekly caught the shutdown before anyone could binge eight hours and treat the place as a going concern. IMDb's trivia line is colder. latestnetflix.com's view is that the facility closed because the female juvenile count had collapsed,,.
Loud TV president Nick Rigg sold the series in a language Netflix already spoke. He told Realscreen it was Orange Is the New Black for a 13 Reasons Why generation. Teens, he said, "can still be molded and changed. They're not stuck in the system." Plum Pictures had the access. The two shops had partnered in 2015 to pitch U.S. Unscripted. Rigg swore they were not making a reality series and "weren't going to make TV stars of these girls." Staff called them students, not inmates, and he treated that vocabulary as the moral of the show. Executive producers on the Loud side included Rigg, David George, Jordana Hochman, Bianca Barnes-Williams, and Royd Chung. Stuart Cabb and Lisa Keane were on for Plum,.
The New Yorker watched it in one sitting and did not buy the bounce.
Doreen St. Felix's April 2018 piece named Loud Television as the company behind Tiny House Hunting and said the series rarely asked whether a detention center was the right room for a girl who drank, smoked weed, or asked to be locked up after a crash. Taryn Twine, 17, told cameras she requested Madison as self-punishment after a friend died in a car she was driving. A Christian volunteer arrived to warn the girls they would go to hell if they were gay. Alexis, dating Armani, answered that they were interacting with her opinions. Najwa Pollard finished her sentence and could not leave because no guardian would claim her. The season ended on a candy-bar "prison cake" for her 16th birthday. The show got a resolution. Pollard did not.
Decider's early recap put about 15 students on camera. Brianna Guerra, 17, called herself a bad girl, then violated probation about a month after release. Former counselor Jacie Minnick later told the site Najwa had gotten out and was "trying to stay positive." Superintendent John Galipeau, on camera in episode one, listed the intake as everything from small-time drug possession to armed robbery. He had been working with kids for 20 years. Then the state closed his building,.
Season 2 followed Galipeau to LaPorte. Wikipedia lists eight more episodes on June 21, 2019, then a hard stop. No third season. Hochman told Distractify the new hall was smaller, bunks instead of cells, more fights for the cameras. She also said producers do not stay in touch with the girls after wrap. "My biggest hope is that they gain some power and confidence from being in the spotlight." The spotlight was the product. TMDB still files the series as ended, Netflix title 80185178,,.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Related series
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.
Mafia: Most Wanted
Ladies Up
Theodore Roosevelt
Sparking Joy with Marie Kondo
Killer Ratings
The Outreau Case: A French Nightmare
Sergeant Kim at Military
Buried by the Bernards
Daughters of Destiny
Love Never Lies: Destination Sardinia