Ambition in a Hall of Mirrors
I kept thinking, while watching The Politician, that it’s a series built on the oldest trick in American culture: take the thing everyone says they care about — democracy, virtue, youth, destiny — and show how quickly it turns into a costume party. There’s a boy here, Payton Hobart, who talks about the presidency the way other people talk about breathing. That’s funny at first, then faintly alarming, then a little sad.
latestnetflix.com's read is that Ryan Murphy has always liked excess, but here the excess is doing a specific job: it turns adolescence into a civic pageant, a place where self-invention and self-delusion are almost impossible to tell apart.
The show arrived in 2019 as a Netflix original, and that matters. This wasn’t a network teen comedy, or a tidy prestige drama pretending to be one. It was part of Murphy’s late-career migration into the streaming bazaar, where he’s free to make things glossy, scattered, self-aware, and just a little too much (which is, depending on your mood, either his gift or his curse).
In the broader arc of Murphy’s work, The Politician sits somewhere between the camp operatics of Glee and the polished social satire of American Horror Story at its most mannered. But it also feels like a cousin to Election and Heathers, those earlier dissections of teen ambition where popularity becomes a blood sport. Murphy and his collaborators understand that the high-school ecosystem is already political; they just dress it up in cashmere and campaign posters.
What’s interesting is that the show doesn’t merely mock ambition. It admires it, then recoils from it, then circles back to admire it again. That instability gives the series its charge.
Payton is absurd — he speaks in the language of strategy and destiny before he’s old enough to have a convincing bedtime routine — but the show never fully treats him as a joke. Ben Platt plays him with a physical rigidity that’s crucial: the squared shoulders, the too-still face, the slight forward tilt of someone forever leaning into the next argument. He looks like a person trying to posture his way into a future he can already see.
Platt came out of Dear Evan Hansen with a reputation for playing earnest, anxious boys who can sing their way through emotional collapse; here, he sheds some of that vulnerability only to reveal a more unnerving thing underneath it. Payton isn’t soft. He’s controlled to the point of fragility.
Murphy’s visual style is, as ever, overdesigned on purpose. The frames are full of jewel tones, immaculate surfaces, and interiors that seem to have been arranged by someone with a grudge against spontaneity. Even the school hallways have a corporate sheen.
That’s not just prettiness; it’s argument. The show keeps telling us that American power is theatrical, and then it makes every locker, podium, and dining room look like a miniature stage. I’m not entirely sure every joke lands, especially when the writing starts chasing its own cleverness, but the image-making is consistent: people are trapped inside systems they can’t stop performing for.
The first season’s central comic device is simple and durable — a student campaign treated with the solemnity of a gubernatorial race — yet the best scenes are the ones that let the absurdity breathe. There’s a recurring pleasure in watching Payton and his team conduct themselves with the grim precision of operatives while standing in spaces designed for adolescents who are still worried about prom.
That mismatch is the point. Politics, the show suggests, is just high school after the diploma, with better tailoring.
One scene that stayed with me — and there are several in this vein — is when the polished machinery of the campaign starts to feel less like a plan than a confession. The blocking becomes increasingly tight; characters crowd each other, interrupt, speak over one another, then pause just long enough to realize they’ve all exposed something they’d rather have hidden. Murphy likes these scenes where the emotional truth slips out through process.
A vote count, a press moment, a carefully calibrated plea — all of it can turn suddenly intimate, almost embarrassing. The camera doesn’t always linger long enough for full catharsis, but maybe that’s right. In this world, nobody gets to luxuriate in sincerity.
They weaponize it instead.
What gives the series some of its warmth is the ensemble around Platt. Zoey Deutch, as Infinity, is especially good at making a character feel like a schematic until she doesn’t. She has this sly, held-back energy, the kind of performance that lets you believe she’s concealing more than the script has given her.
Judith Light, meanwhile, is one of those actors who can imply an entire political philosophy with a raised eyebrow and a change in posture. She’s been doing exacting work for decades — from sitcoms to prestige drama — and here she uses that authority to keep the show from floating away on its own cleverness. Bette Midler, in her later-season turn, understands the series’ tonal rules instinctively.
She doesn’t smooth them out. She leans into the camp, then finds the bruise underneath it. Gwyneth Paltrow, too, is sharper than the surrounding material sometimes deserves; she knows how to make privilege seem both seductive and mildly nauseating.
The show’s second season widens the lens, and I think that’s both its strength and its problem. It gets bolder about the machinery of power, especially as Payton leaves the sealed aquarium of high school behind. But once the setting expands, the metaphor loosens a bit.
The earlier episodes had the delicious perversity of making school elections feel like national destiny; later on, the series has to contend with the fact that the real political world is messier, uglier, and less neatly satirized. Some of the story turns begin to feel overplotted. Still, even when I could see the gears, I rarely stopped watching.
Murphy is very good at making artifice feel like a mood.
There’s also something quietly poignant about the show’s obsession with youth as a rehearsal for rule. Payton’s confidence is almost religious, but it’s always undercut by the possibility that he doesn’t actually know who he is without the campaign signage. That’s the series’ smartest insight, and maybe its most melancholy one: ambition can become a substitute for character if you’re not careful.
In the right light, that sounds like a joke. In the wrong one, it sounds like America.
I wouldn’t call The Politician neat. It rambles. It gets overeager.
Sometimes it loves its own surface too much, and sometimes it seems to mistake speed for insight. But I kept coming back to how it stages desire — not as noble purpose, but as a set of poses people strike in order not to feel ordinary. That’s a pretty good trick for a TV series about power.
It’s also, maybe, the most honest thing it can say about the way we build our public selves: one speech, one ballot, one performance at a time.