
Jimmy Shergill
Amar Singh

A serial killer strikes back in London after laying low for three years. Amar, the investigating detective has since resigned from the job but is brought back to crack the case. Amar decides to return and resolve the case once and for all.
I kept waiting for Operation Mayfair to surprise me. Not with a twist—that would’ve been too much to ask—but with a single moment of clarity, a scene where the gears of this London-set crime thriller actually meshed. Instead, I got 116 minutes of good intentions colliding with shoddy execution, like watching a detective trip over his own shoelaces while chasing a killer who left his calling card in Comic Sans.
The premise isn’t without promise: Jimmy Shergill plays Amar Singh, a former detective lured back into the fray when a serial killer he failed to catch three years earlier resurfaces in Mayfair. It’s the kind of setup that should hum with tension—regret, obsession, the gnawing fear of failure. But the film’s grasp of its own mechanics is so tenuous that even the most basic elements of a procedural feel like they’re being explained to you in real time.
(Why is the killer’s signature a red rose? Because the script said so, I guess.)

Shergill, at least, tries. He’s the kind of actor who can make even the most threadbare dialogue sound like it’s being delivered by a man who’s seen too much, and here, he’s working overtime to sell a script that keeps undercutting him. There’s a scene early on where Amar stares at a crime scene photo, his face a mask of quiet fury.
For a second, it almost works—until the camera cuts to a flashback that explains, in painstaking detail, what we just saw in his eyes. It’s the cinematic equivalent of someone leaning over during a movie and whispering, “He’s upset because he failed last time.” Thanks. I’d noticed.
The film’s London setting is another missed opportunity. The city is reduced to a series of interchangeable backdrops—generic pubs, nondescript alleys, the kind of places that could be anywhere and therefore feel like nowhere. Roger Moore at Movie Nation called it “violent, tin-eared, clumsily-staged,” and he’s not wrong, but there’s something almost endearing about how little the film seems to care about its own geography.
At one point, Amar and his team convene in what’s clearly a storefront pretending to be a café, the kind of place where the barista would probably ask if you’re lost. It’s the kind of detail that would be charming if it weren’t so emblematic of the film’s larger problem: Operation Mayfair doesn’t just lack atmosphere—it doesn’t seem to know what atmosphere is.

The killer, when he finally appears, is played by Ankur Bhatia with a kind of smug detachment that might’ve been chilling if the film around him weren’t so busy tripping over its own feet. The cat-and-mouse dynamic between him and Amar is supposed to be the engine of the story, but the script keeps stalling out, resorting to clunky exposition dumps and convenient coincidences. There’s a moment where the killer leaves a clue that’s so obvious it might as well come with a neon sign reading “PLOT DEVICE HERE,” and I could practically hear the film patting itself on the back for its own cleverness.
The cinematography, at least, is a rare bright spot. Santonio Terzio’s work is moody and textured, with a gritty realism that almost makes you forget the script’s shortcomings. Almost.
There’s a nighttime chase sequence that’s shot with a kind of kinetic energy, the camera weaving through the streets like it’s as desperate to escape the dialogue as I was. But even here, the film can’t help but undermine itself. The editing is so disjointed that the tension dissipates almost as soon as it builds, like a joke where the punchline arrives three beats too late.

I’ve seen enough crime thrillers to know that a film doesn’t need a perfect script to work—sometimes, all it takes is a strong performance or a single unforgettable scene. But Operation Mayfair doesn’t even clear that low bar. It’s the kind of movie that makes you wonder if anyone involved stopped to ask, “Does this actually make sense?” The answer, repeatedly, is no.
The killer’s motives are vague, the detective’s methods are baffling, and the supporting characters exist solely to deliver lines that move the plot forward. (Vedieka Dutt, as Amar’s colleague, deserves better—her role is so thin it’s practically translucent.)
There’s a moment near the end where Amar delivers a monologue about justice and closure, and I found myself wishing the film had taken its own advice. Operation Mayfair is a case that should’ve stayed closed—a thriller that never quite figures out what it wants to be, let alone how to get there. It’s not offensive, just exhausting, like listening to someone explain a dream you’ve already forgotten. And in a genre that thrives on tension, that might be the biggest crime of all.
"A low-buzz Netflix crime thriller that drew curious viewers from the charts and mostly disappointed them."
Operation Mayfair had a brief moment on Netflix, debuting at number 12 in the worldwide rankings a few places behind Tin and Tina, so curious viewers did try it. Reception afterward skews negative, with a Google Play audience aggregate of 1.1 out of five pointing to broad disappointment. Hindi and English review videos about the Jimmy Shergill film dissected it rather than recommended it, and its Rotten Tomatoes page offers reviews, ratings and trailers to help you decide whether to skip.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Operation Mayfair (2023) marks director Sudipto Sarkar’s Hindi-language debut, blending a British setting with a high-stakes murder investigation. Starring Jimmy Shergill in a role that merges toughness with emotional depth, the film has drawn attention for its real-life inspirations and Sarkar’s long-held vision for the project. latestnetflix.com's read is that here’s what we know about the making of this crime thriller.
Jimmy Shergill revealed in a promotional interview that Operation Mayfair is "based on real incidents," though specifics about the cases remain undisclosed. The film follows Amar Singh, a detective pulled back into the force to hunt a London-based serial killer targeting women. Shergill’s portrayal of Singh—a cop balancing grit and vulnerability—has been praised as a standout, with critics noting the film’s "intelligently drawn" suspense. The premise of a killer resurfacing after years of silence adds a layer of psychological tension, a hallmark of Sarkar’s storytelling.
Sarkar, who made his directorial debut with Operation Mayfair, has been vocal about his admiration for Shergill. In an interview, he stated, "I always wished to cast Jimmy Shergill" in the lead role, suggesting a long-gestating creative partnership. The film’s bilingual approach—Hindi with British settings—was an intentional choice to craft a "unusual British-Hindi crime caper," blending cultural influences while keeping the narrative grounded.
The supporting cast includes Vedieka Dutt, Ankur Bhatia, and Hritiqa Chheber, among others, though details about their characters’ arcs remain sparse. The film’s release on March 24, 2023, positioned it as a mid-year thriller, though its box-office performance hasn’t been widely documented in the available sources.
The evidence leaves gaps about the film’s development timeline, budget, or any challenges faced during production. Rumors about the killer’s identity or the detective’s backstory—common in crime thrillers—aren’t confirmed in the snippets. Without deeper reporting, these remain speculative.
For now, Operation Mayfair stands as a niche entry in the crime genre, distinguished by its cross-cultural setting and Shergill’s return to investigative roles. Whether it spawns a franchise or fades into obscurity may depend on audience reception beyond its initial release.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.