Skip to main content
Movie poster for You Get Me (2017)

You Get Me

“Some mistakes won't let go.”

2017
1h 29m
R · English
Director: Brent Bonacorso
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

After arguing with his girlfriend, Ali, Tyler lands in the arms of sexy new girl, Holly. The next morning, he finds that not only does Ali agree to take him back, but Holly is a new student at their school and is dead set on her new man.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Thrill That Wasn’t: How You Get Me Mistakes Obsession for Tension

I’ll admit it: I went into You Get Me expecting a guilty pleasure. A Netflix original thriller with Bella Thorne as the unhinged love interest? A plot that promised the kind of escalating chaos usually reserved for late-night cable movies?

It sounded like the cinematic equivalent of junk food—easy to consume, maybe a little regrettable by morning, but undeniably fun while it lasted. Instead, I got a film that fumbles its own premise so thoroughly it’s hard to believe anyone involved thought this was a good idea.

A dimly lit bedroom scene, the camera angled over a character's shoulder as they stare at their phone, the glow casting eerie shadows across their face.

The setup is simple, almost painfully so. Tyler (Taylor John Smith), a high school senior, has a one-night stand with Holly (Bella Thorne) after a fight with his girlfriend, Ali (Halston Sage). The next morning, he wakes up to find Ali has forgiven him—and Holly has transferred to his school.

What follows is a series of increasingly absurd attempts by Holly to insert herself into Tyler’s life, escalating from clingy to outright dangerous. On paper, this should work. The thriller genre thrives on the tension of the ordinary curdling into something sinister, the way a harmless crush can twist into obsession.

But You Get Me never figures out how to make that tension feel real. Instead, it relies on a checklist of thriller tropes—stalking, gaslighting, a third-act confrontation—without ever bothering to ground them in anything resembling human behavior.

Take Holly’s character, for instance. Bella Thorne is an actress who’s spent her career oscillating between campy roles and more serious ones, and here, she leans hard into the unhinged femme fatale archetype. The problem isn’t her performance—she commits to the role with a kind of manic energy that’s almost impressive—but the script’s refusal to give her any depth.

Holly isn’t a person; she’s a collection of tics. She shows up uninvited to Tyler’s house. She manipulates his friends.

She even breaks into his room to leave him a "gift" (a dead bird, because of course). But why? What’s driving her?

The film never bothers to explain, and without that context, her actions feel less like a descent into madness and more like a series of plot beats designed to keep the story moving. It’s as if the writers watched Fatal Attraction and Swimfan, took notes on the most outrageous moments, and then forgot to include the character development that made those films work.

A tense moment in a high school hallway, Holly standing too close to Tyler, her expression a mix of desperation and calculation, while he looks visibly uncomfortable.

The film’s biggest sin, though, is its inability to make us care. Tyler is a cipher, a blank slate onto which the plot happens. We’re told he’s a good guy—his friends like him, his girlfriend forgives him, his parents are supportive—but we never see it.

There’s no moment where we understand why Ali loves him, or why Holly becomes so fixated on him. He’s just… there. And because we don’t care about him, we don’t care about the danger he’s in.

When Holly’s behavior escalates, it’s hard to feel anything but annoyance. Not fear. Not suspense.

Just the creeping realization that you’re watching a film that doesn’t know how to build tension.

This isn’t to say You Get Me is entirely without merit. There are fleeting moments where the film almost works. A scene in a diner, where Holly corners Tyler and Ali, has a spark of genuine unease.

The way Thorne’s voice drops into a whisper, the way her eyes dart between the two of them—it’s the closest the film comes to capturing the unsettling unpredictability of obsession. But these moments are few and far between, drowned out by the film’s reliance on clichés. The third act, in particular, devolves into a series of over-the-top confrontations that feel lifted from a direct-to-video thriller from the early 2000s.

There’s a car chase that goes nowhere, a fight scene that’s more awkward than thrilling, and a final twist that’s so telegraphed it might as well come with a spoiler alert.

A climactic confrontation in a dimly lit room, the camera capturing the tension between Holly and Tyler, her face half-lit by the glow of a nearby lamp, his expression a mix of fear and exhaustion.

It’s tempting to write You Get Me off as a bad movie, but that feels too easy. Bad movies can still be fun, still have a kind of reckless energy that makes them worth watching. You Get Me isn’t fun. It’s not even bad in an interesting way.

It’s just… there. A film that mistakes volume for intensity, shock value for suspense, and a checklist of thriller tropes for actual storytelling. The real tragedy is that it had the ingredients for something better.

Bella Thorne is a compelling actress when given the right material. The premise is solid, if familiar. But the execution is so lacking that it’s hard to imagine anyone walking away from this film feeling anything but relief that it’s over.

Maybe that’s the point. Maybe You Get Me is meant to be a cautionary tale about the dangers of obsession, a warning about how quickly a harmless crush can turn into something darker. But if that’s the case, it fails even at that.

Because the film never makes us feel the weight of its own message. It’s all surface, no substance. And in the end, that’s the most frustrating thing about it.

Not that it’s bad, but that it could have been so much more.

Audience Opinions

Audience 5.2/10
"A forgettable teen thriller with occasional flashes of tension, dragged down by clichés and weak execution."

The film aims for suspense and has recognizable young actors, but the story feels recycled from better thrillers, with underdeveloped characters and predictable twists. The pacing and dialogue often fall flat, and it never lives up to its potential.

What viewers praise
  • Decent cast performances Bella Thorne and Halston Sage give engaging performances that keep the film watchable despite thin material.
  • Occasional suspense Some scenes build real tension and hint at what the film could have been.
  • Stylish visuals The cinematography gives the thriller a sleek, modern look.
Common complaints
  • Predictable plot The story relies on overused thriller tropes, making the twists unoriginal and easy to guess.
  • Weak character development Supporting characters are underwritten, so their arcs carry little emotional weight.
  • Poor pacing The film loses momentum, with slow stretches that dilute the tension.
  • Clichéd dialogue Lines often feel forced or unnatural.
Recommended for
Teen thriller fans Bella Thorne enthusiasts Casual Netflix viewers Low-stakes suspense seekers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Inside the Making of You Get Me: Bella Thorne’s Thriller and the Netflix Hype

You Get Me (2017) arrived on Netflix with a mix of teen drama and psychological thriller energy, anchored by Bella Thorne’s intense performance. latestnetflix.com's take is that Directed by Brent Bonacorso, the film follows a high school romance spiraling into obsession, but behind the scenes, its journey from festival premiere to streaming debut offers a few juicy details.

A Netflix Original with Festival Buzz

The movie premiered at the Los Angeles Film Festival (LAFF) before landing on Netflix on June 23, 2017. Bonacorso’s festival interviews suggest the film was positioned as a dark twist on teen romance, with the director hinting at the psychological unraveling of its characters. While the evidence doesn’t reveal box office numbers (likely due to its streaming-first release), the festival circuit gave it early exposure, and Netflix’s push included cast interviews and promotional content.

Cast Chemistry and Social Media Hype

The ensemble cast—led by Thorne, Halston Sage, and Taylor John Smith—leaned into the film’s provocative themes in promotional appearances. Clips from cast interviews, like the "Confessions" and "Sexy or Stalker?" segments, show the actors playfully debating the film’s blurred lines between romance and obsession. Nash Grier, a social media influencer at the time, brought a built-in fanbase, which likely helped amplify the movie’s reach.

Thorne, already a tabloid fixture, delivered one of the film’s most quoted scenes: "I'm a very loving person"—a line that became a meme-worthy moment and a highlight in promotional clips. Her filmography, which spans dozens of projects by 2017, made her a natural fit for the lead role.

Mixed Reception and the Rotten Tomatoes Reality

Critically, You Get Me didn’t set the world on fire. SensCritique users rated it a lukewarm 3.7/10, and while Rotten Tomatoes doesn’t list an official score in the snippet, the lack of fanfare suggests it was more of a guilty pleasure than a critical darling. YouTube rants and reviews, like the "Epic Rant" video, frame it as a so-bad-it’s-good thriller, leaning into its over-the-top drama.

The Missing Pieces

Despite the promotional push, details about the film’s production—budget, on-set dynamics, or Bonacorso’s vision beyond festival interviews—remain scarce in the evidence. Rumors or unconfirmed behind-the-scenes drama? None surface in the snippets. For now, You Get Me lives on as a snapshot of 2017’s teen-thriller craze, carried by Thorne’s star power and Netflix’s algorithm.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.