Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Wretched (2019)

The Wretched

“What is forgotten will never be found.”

2019
1h 35m
NR · English
Director: Drew T. Pierce
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A rebellious teenage boy, struggling with his parents' imminent divorce, encounters a terrifying evil after his next-door neighbor becomes possessed by an ancient witch that feasts on children.

Trailer

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Witch Next Door, or How to Forget Your Own Fear

I’ve seen The Wretched three times now, and each viewing leaves me with the same unsettling question: What if the real horror isn’t the witch, but the way we let ourselves forget what we’ve just seen? Not in the grand, cinematic sense—no jump scares lingering in the dark—but in the quiet, domestic way the film erases its own stakes. It’s a movie that thrives on memory, or the lack of it, and by the end, I’m not sure I trust my own.

The Pierce brothers, directing their first feature, have crafted something deceptively simple: a suburban horror fable where the monster isn’t lurking in the woods but in the house next door, wearing the face of a neighbor. The setup is familiar—divorcing parents, a rebellious teen (Ben, played by John-Paul Howard), a summer job at a marina, and a creeping sense that something is off about the woman who moved in next door.

But the film’s genius (or its most frustrating trick, depending on your patience) is how it weaponizes the mundane. The witch doesn’t announce herself with thunder or gore; she just… exists. A flicker in the corner of the frame.

A voice too calm. A smile that doesn’t reach her eyes.

A shadowy figure stands in a dimly lit hallway, her face obscured by darkness, while a child clutches a stuffed animal in the foreground.

What makes The Wretched work—and what makes it infuriating—is its refusal to play by the rules of either slow-burn horror or jump-scare thrillers. The film is drenched in atmosphere: the humid, sticky air of a Michigan summer, the way the sunlight filters through the trees like it’s trying to warn you, the eerie stillness of a neighborhood where no one seems to notice the disappearances.

The sound design is particularly masterful. There’s a scene where Ben is alone in his house, and the only noise is the hum of the refrigerator and the distant, rhythmic thump of a basketball being dribbled outside. It’s the kind of detail that makes the hair on your arms stand up, not because it’s loud, but because it’s too quiet.

The witch doesn’t need a score; she has the absence of one.

But then the film stumbles. Or maybe it’s intentional. Maybe the stumbles are the point.

The witch’s power, we’re told, lies in her ability to make people forget. And so the characters do—constantly. They walk away from conversations mid-sentence, they ignore glaring red flags, they let children wander off into the woods like it’s nothing.

It’s a clever narrative device, but it also means the film’s tension is built on a foundation of deliberate stupidity. There’s a moment where Ben’s father (Jamison Jones) literally watches the neighbor’s son vanish into thin air, and his reaction is… to shrug and go back inside. I wanted to scream at the screen. *Turn around!

Do something!* But that’s the joke, isn’t it? The witch doesn’t need to chase you. She just waits for you to forget she’s there.

The performances are uneven, but in a way that almost feels intentional. John-Paul Howard’s Ben is a typical sullen teen, all eye rolls and half-hearted rebellion, but there’s a vulnerability there that keeps him from being a cliché. Piper Curda, as Mallory, is the film’s secret weapon.

She’s warm and funny, the kind of girl who makes you believe in the possibility of friendship even when the world is ending. And then there’s the witch herself, played by Azie Tesfai with a chilling, understated menace. She’s not a shrieking hag or a gore-covered monster; she’s a woman who offers you lemonade and then asks if you’d like to stay for dinner. Forever.

A close-up of a woman’s face, her eyes glowing faintly in the dark, as she leans in with an unnerving smile.

The film’s third act is where it either loses you or cements its place in your nightmares. Without spoiling anything, I’ll say this: the ending is not a twist. It’s a gut punch.

A moment where the film’s central metaphor—about the way we ignore what’s right in front of us—collapses into something far more personal. It’s the kind of ending that lingers, not because it’s shocking, but because it’s sad. The witch doesn’t just eat children; she eats memories, relationships, the things that make us human.

And by the time the credits roll, you’re left wondering how much of what you just saw was real, and how much was the witch’s doing.

That’s the film’s real trick. The Wretched isn’t just about a monster in the woods. It’s about the monsters we invite into our lives—the ones we choose to ignore because confronting them is too painful. The witch is a metaphor for addiction, for grief, for the way we let ourselves be consumed by the things we refuse to acknowledge.

And in that sense, the film’s biggest flaw—its reliance on characters forgetting the obvious—becomes its most haunting strength. Because isn’t that what we all do? Forget the things we don’t want to remember?

I keep coming back to the film’s tagline: What is forgotten will never be found. It’s a line that could apply to the missing children, but it also applies to Ben, to his parents, to the audience. The witch doesn’t just take; she makes you complicit in your own forgetting. And by the end, I’m not sure I trust myself to remember what I’ve seen.

Maybe that’s the point.

A wide shot of a suburban street at dusk, the houses bathed in an eerie orange glow, with a lone figure standing in the middle of the road.

The Wretched isn’t a perfect film. It’s messy, sometimes frustrating, and it leans too hard on its own mythology. But it’s also one of the most unsettling horror movies I’ve seen in years—not because of what it shows, but because of what it makes you forget.

And that, in the end, might be the scariest trick of all.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.7/10
"A creepy, atmospheric horror with solid scares but a slow burn that tests patience."

The eerie small-town setting and the unsettling witch antagonist deliver genuine chills. The pacing drags in places, though, and the story is too predictable, relying on familiar horror tropes without enough fresh twists to stand out.

What viewers praise
  • Effective atmosphere The film’s moody, small-town setting and eerie tone create a consistently unsettling vibe.
  • Strong villain presence The witch antagonist is genuinely creepy and well executed, making for memorable scares.
  • Solid lead performance John-Paul Howard’s portrayal of the troubled teen adds depth to the story.
  • Practical effects The use of practical effects for the witch enhances the horror’s realism and impact.
Common complaints
  • Slow pacing The film takes too long to build tension.
  • Predictable plot The story follows familiar horror tropes and feels unoriginal.
  • Underdeveloped side characters Supporting characters lack depth, making their arcs feel shallow or forgettable.
  • Weak third act The climax and resolution feel rushed or unsatisfying compared to the build-up.
Recommended for
Folk horror fans Atmospheric horror lovers Practical effects enthusiasts Slow-burn horror watchers Small-town horror fans

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Wretched: The Little Witch Movie That Dodged Scandal and Still Ruled Hollywood

Indie horror flicks are supposed to come with cursed shoots, screaming matches in the makeup trailer, and at least one messy breakup. latestnetflix.com's read is that The Wretched (2019) somehow skipped the drama, conquered the pandemic box office, and left fans inventing their own tea just to keep things spicy.


Scandals & Controversies: The “Too Clean” Horror Hit

  • When cinemas were shuttered and blockbusters were hiding on hard drives, a tiny Michigan-shot witch movie quietly became America’s No. 1 film, dominating the box office via drive-ins for weeks on end. Industry coverage called its rise “unlikely” and “viral,” with Forbes noting that this $66,000 indie was suddenly a “beacon of hope” for theatrical releases. No cheating numbers, no shady reporting tricks – just a freak alignment of horror fans and empty schedules. - That success sparked a mini-controversy among genre diehards: some critics and commenters argued the film’s status as “box office champ” was overblown because it hit big only when there was basically nothing else in theaters. Others clapped back that a win is a win – especially for a blood-soaked witch story. - On the content side, the biggest “scandal” isn’t lawsuits or boycotts, but fans dragging the film for huge plot holes and questionable logic. Reddit threads roast it as a movie where “half of the story was left on the editing room floor,” with viewers joking that any narrative gaps are hand‑waved away as “the witch made everyone forget”. It’s become part of the film’s cult identity: messy lore, killer vibes.

On-Set Drama (Or Lack Thereof) & Practical-Effects Flex

  • Instead of feuds, the juiciest behind-the-scenes story is nepotism of the coolest kind: directors Brett and Drew Pierce are the sons of Bart Pierce, who worked on effects for Sam Raimi’s original Evil Dead. They grew up around latex and fake blood and then used that legacy to build their own gnarly witch. - The creature work is almost entirely practical, courtesy of makeup FX supervisor Erik Porn. Horror outlets drooled over the film’s “gnarly and awesome” hands-on effects and credited them with carrying the movie through its weaker writing. Interviews reveal the FX were time‑intensive and brutal to pull off on a small schedule. - An Instagram post from FX artist Annie Tagge shows crew literally crammed under the set floorboards prepping the witch gags, turning the location into a low-budget haunted house. No reports of walk-offs, no screaming fits – just people sweating in crawlspaces for your entertainment. - The movie was shot in the tiny Michigan towns of Omena and Northport, where locals watched their marinas and cottages turned into horror sets, then later bragged that their sleepy peninsula had produced a national box-office #1. If there were neighbor complaints, they didn’t make the trades.

Cast Feuds & Romance Rumors

  • Reviews across the horror blogosphere single out the “cool easy chemistry” between John-Paul Howard and Piper Curda, saying their relationship never feels forced and anchors the movie emotionally. That, of course, launched the inevitable “are they dating?” whispers among fans – but there’s no reported evidence of an off-screen fling. - Instead, the most notable real-world personal detail comes later: Piper Curda publicly talking about being asexual and discussing relationships and breakups in broader interviews and social posts unrelated to The Wretched. Any fanfiction about steamy set romance is just that — fanfiction. - There are no publicized cast feuds, onset screaming matches, or shady behavior attached to the film in festival Q&As or fan circles. For a horror movie, the production itself is suspiciously… well-adjusted.

Leaks, Fan Theories & Witchy Obsessions

  • With no real-world scandals to chew on, the fandom turned its energy to over-analyzing the ending. A major Reddit thread debates whether the final reveal means Mallory is possessed, replaced, or has been the witch’s puppet all along. Fans point to that fake flower and the casual way she walks off with the kids as “proof” something much darker is going on. - TikTok horror creators have joined in, spinning quick-hit “ending explained” clips and mini‑video essays that frame the film as a twisty suburban paranoia tale with secret clues about the witch’s rules. - At the same time, critics and viewers argue over the film’s DIY mythology. Interviews with the Pierce Brothers confirm they invented a new set of witch rules rather than adapting a specific legend. Some horror writers praise that as “a chilling blend of fairy tale and horror,” while others say the lore feels half-baked and fuels those infamous plot holes.

Sequel Chaos & Future Witch Drama

  • Just when everyone assumed The Wretched would stay a one‑and‑done cult item, news broke in 2025 that a sequel, The Wretched 2 / The Wretched Devours, was gearing up — with the Pierce Brothers back at the helm and production relocating to Syracuse, New York. Horror outlets and local Michigan coverage both confirmed it, noting that the original’s Leelanau County locations have been ditched for new territory. - Fans immediately flooded comment sections asking the real questions: Will the original witch’s rules stick? Is Mallory coming back? Is Ben doomed to be the town’s forever “crazy kid who was right”? So far, all of that is unconfirmed – the marketing is leaning heavily on the first movie’s pandemic‑era legend rather than revealing story details.

Wild Trivia to Impress Your Horror Friends

  • The movie won a “Best Scare” award at Grimmfest 2019, sponsored by horror institution Rue Morgue. - It was scooped up by IFC Midnight after its Fantasia festival run — a deal Deadline reported as straightforward, with none of the usual “rights war” drama. - Commentators repeatedly describe the film as a “comfort food” horror that feels like an ’80s kid-in-peril classic with modern gross‑out FX, which helped it become a go‑to rec during lockdown.

In short: The Wretched might not have given us DUI arrests, cheating scandals, or diva meltdowns… but it did give us indie horror outmuscling studio behemoths, practical FX war stories, and a fandom still arguing about that witch years later. For a $66k Michigan witch movie, that’s some pretty potent magic.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.