
Annette Bening
Diana Nyad

Athlete Diana Nyad sets out at 60 to achieve a nearly impossible lifelong dream: to swim from Cuba to Florida across more than 100 miles of open ocean.
Official
I’ve never been much of a swimmer. The idea of willingly submerging myself in open water—let alone for hours, let alone for 110 miles—fills me with a quiet terror. So when Nyad opens with Annette Bening’s Diana Nyad slicing through the dark ocean, her face a mask of determination and exhaustion, I’m not just watching a sports biopic.
I’m watching someone stare down the thing that scares me most: the vast, indifferent expanse of the unknown. And yet, the film’s most compelling moments aren’t the ones where Nyad battles the sea. They’re the ones where she battles herself.

Directors Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi and Jimmy Chin, best known for their documentaries Free Solo and The Rescue, bring a documentarian’s eye to this narrative debut. That’s both a strength and a limitation. The film’s underwater sequences are visceral, almost tactile—the way the camera lingers on Nyad’s strokes, the way the water distorts her body, the way the jellyfish stings look like something out of a horror movie.
There’s a moment early on, during her first failed attempt, where the ocean suddenly turns against her. The waves rise, the currents shift, and the camera doesn’t cut away. It’s uncomfortable to watch, not because it’s poorly done, but because it’s too well done.
You feel the panic in your own chest.
But Nyad isn’t just about the swim. It’s about the people who make the swim possible. Jodie Foster, as Nyad’s coach and best friend Bonnie Stoll, is the film’s secret weapon.
Foster has always had a knack for playing characters who are sharp, no-nonsense, and deeply human, and here she’s no different. The dynamic between her and Bening is electric—less a mentor-student relationship and more like two old friends who know each other’s flaws too well to sugarcoat them. When Stoll tells Nyad, “You’re not a goddamn superhero,” it’s not just tough love.
It’s the truth. And Foster delivers it with a weariness that suggests she’s said it a hundred times before.
The film’s emotional core rests almost entirely on their chemistry. Richard Roeper put it best: “When Bening and Foster are onscreen together, it’s movie magic. They don’t just have chemistry; they’re chemistry professors.” And he’s right.
There’s a scene midway through where Nyad, exhausted and delirious, hallucinates her younger self swimming alongside her. The camera cuts between Bening’s weathered face and the younger actress playing Nyad in flashback, and for a moment, you see the weight of decades in her eyes. It’s a quiet, devastating moment—one that wouldn’t land half as hard without Foster’s grounded presence anchoring it.

That said, Nyad isn’t without its missteps. The film’s biggest flaw is its refusal to engage with the controversies surrounding Nyad’s real-life swim. Her 2013 Cuba-to-Florida crossing has never been officially ratified due to incomplete records and questions about whether she received unauthorized assistance.
The film acknowledges none of this. Instead, it presents her journey as an unqualified triumph, a middle finger to the doubters and the ocean itself. It’s an understandable creative choice—after all, no one wants to watch a movie about a woman who might have cheated—but it also feels like a missed opportunity.
As Christy Lemire wrote in her review for RogerEbert.com, “There’s a thornier, messier, much more provocative story to be told here, so it’s frustrating the filmmakers opt for easy inspiration instead.”
The film’s flashbacks to Nyad’s childhood, where she was sexually abused by her swim coach, are another sticking point. They’re shot with a prism effect, as if the past is being refracted through water, and while the intention is clear—to show how trauma shapes her—the execution feels heavy-handed. The scenes don’t so much haunt the present as they do interrupt it, like a commercial break for psychological backstory.
Alison Willmore at Vulture was even blunter: “Nyad makes its subject look like an asshole. ... Despite that dedication, there’s a hollowness to the way the film characterizes its protagonist.” It’s a harsh critique, but not an entirely unfair one. The film wants us to root for Nyad, but it doesn’t always give us a reason to like her.
And yet, for all its flaws, Nyad lingers. Maybe it’s because Bening’s performance is so physically committed—her body language, the way she carries herself, the sheer exhaustion in her eyes—that you can’t look away. Maybe it’s because the ocean itself becomes a character, beautiful and terrifying in equal measure.
Or maybe it’s because, at its core, this is a story about obsession. Not just Nyad’s obsession with the swim, but the obsession of the people around her who enable it. Foster’s Stoll is the voice of reason, but even she can’t resist the pull of Nyad’s dream.
There’s something almost tragic about that—about the way we cling to the people who push us to our limits, even when we know they’re pushing us toward disaster.

The film’s final act is a masterclass in tension. Nyad’s fifth and final attempt is shot with a relentless, almost unbearable focus. The jellyfish stings, the hallucinations, the moments where she’s on the verge of giving up—it’s all there, and it’s all shot with a documentary-like realism that makes it feel like you’re right there with her.
When she finally stumbles onto the shore, the moment is less triumphant than it is surreal. She’s alive. She did it.
But the ocean is still there, vast and indifferent. The film doesn’t try to give that moment a neat resolution, and in a way, that’s its greatest strength.
I left Nyad thinking about the things we do to prove something—to ourselves, to the world. About the people who help us do those things, even when they know we’re being reckless. About the way the past clings to us, like saltwater on skin.
It’s not a perfect film. It’s messy, uneven, and at times frustratingly conventional. But it’s also honest in a way that most sports biopics aren’t.
It doesn’t just show you the finish line. It shows you the cost of getting there. And sometimes, that’s enough.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Annette Bening and Jodie Foster headline Nyad, the 2023 biographical drama about marathon swimmer Diana Nyad’s grueling attempts to conquer the Straits of Florida. But the film’s journey to the screen was nearly as turbulent as Nyad’s open-ocean swims—filled with directorial debuts, long-simmering controversies, latestnetflix.com argues, and a story that blurs the line between fact and cinematic embellishment.
Nyad marks the first narrative feature for documentary filmmakers Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi and Jimmy Chin, best known for their Oscar-winning Free Solo (2018). Their pivot from real-life adventure docs to scripted drama raised eyebrows, but the duo’s expertise in capturing extreme physical feats translated surprisingly well. Vasarhelyi, whose background includes adventure and extreme sports documentaries, brought a visceral authenticity to Nyad’s punishing swim sequences. The film’s production reportedly leaned on Chin’s mountaineering experience to choreograph the underwater scenes, though details about the shoot remain scarce.
Bening, who took on the role of the 60-something Nyad, trained rigorously for months to mimic the swimmer’s endurance. Foster, playing Nyad’s coach and best friend Bonnie Stoll, reportedly bonded with Bening over the physical demands of the shoot—though neither has publicly shared behind-the-scenes anecdotes.
Nyad’s release reignited a years-long debate about the legitimacy of Diana Nyad’s 2013 Cuba-to-Florida swim. Critics have long questioned whether she completed the 110-mile journey without assistance, citing inconsistencies in her accounts and the lack of independent verification. The film, based on Nyad’s 2015 memoir Find a Way, presents her story as an unqualified triumph, but real-life skeptics argue the movie glosses over key controversies.
Netflix’s decision to stream Nyad in late 2023 brought the controversy back into the spotlight, with outlets like the Los Angeles Times dissecting what’s fact and what’s fiction in the biopic. The film’s creative team has defended its portrayal, but the debate underscores how Nyad’s legacy remains as contentious as the swim itself.
The film takes some liberties with Nyad’s story, though the extent of the dramatization is up for debate. For instance:
Despite the star power of Bening and Foster, Nyad’s production hasn’t generated much tabloid buzz. No reports of on-set clashes, salary disputes, or casting drama have surfaced—just a straightforward, if controversial, adaptation of Nyad’s memoir. The film’s biggest talking point remains its real-life subject, not its Hollywood backstory.
For now, Nyad shows endurance—both in the water and in the court of public opinion.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.