Skip to main content
Movie poster for Ordinary Men: The "Forgotten Holocaust" (2022)

Ordinary Men: The "Forgotten Holocaust"

2022
58m
R · German
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Six million Jews died during World War II, both in the extermination camps and murdered by the mobile commandos of the Einsatzgruppen and police battalions, whose members shot men, women and children, day after day, obediently, as if it were a normal job, a fact that is hardly known today. Who were these men and how could they commit such crimes?

Trailer

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Men Who Pulled the Trigger—and the Silence That Followed

There’s a moment in Ordinary Men: The "Forgotten Holocaust" that isn’t shown on screen, but it lingers in the air like the echo of a gunshot. It’s the pause between the historian’s testimony and the next piece of archival footage—a beat where the film seems to hold its breath. That silence isn’t an accident.

It’s the point.

The documentary, directed by Manfred Oldenburg, isn’t about the mechanics of mass murder. It’s about the mechanics of looking away. The Einsatzgruppen, those mobile killing squads of the SS and police battalions, didn’t just execute Jews, Roma, and political prisoners in occupied Eastern Europe; they did it in broad daylight, often in full view of local populations, sometimes with the help of collaborators.

And yet, as the film reminds us, this chapter of the Holocaust has been overshadowed by the industrial horror of the death camps. The Einsatzgruppen murdered between 1.5 and 2 million people, one bullet at a time. No gas chambers, no assembly lines—just men with rifles, doing their jobs.

A black-and-white photograph of a group of men in military uniforms standing in a field, their faces blurred, their postures relaxed as if posing for a company portrait.

The film’s title borrows from Hannah Arendt’s famous phrase, the banality of evil, but it doesn’t just nod to the idea—it drags it into the light and forces us to look. These weren’t monsters in the gothic sense. They were accountants, teachers, civil servants.

Men who, as historian Christopher Browning puts it, were "ordinary" before the war and ordinary again afterward. The film’s greatest unsettling achievement is making that ordinariness visible. There’s no dramatic score to cue our horror, no reenactments of violence (thankfully).

Instead, we get talking heads—historians, sociologists, the last surviving Nuremberg prosecutor, Benjamin Ferencz—and a steady stream of black-and-white photographs: men in uniform, smiling at picnics, posing for group shots. The contrast isn’t just jarring; it’s obscene.

Oldenburg structures the film around the 1947–48 Nuremberg Einsatzgruppen trial, the largest murder trial in history. The trial itself is a masterclass in bureaucratic horror. The defendants weren’t denying what they’d done; they were arguing over why they’d done it.

Some claimed they were following orders. Others said they’d had no choice. A few even insisted they’d tried to refuse.

The film doesn’t let them off the hook, but it doesn’t let us off either. It forces the question: What would we have done? The answer isn’t comfortable.

A close-up of a typewritten document, its text blurred but the words "Einsatzgruppen" and "Nuremberg" faintly visible, the paper yellowed with age.

One of the most chilling moments comes from sociologist Stefan Kühl, who breaks down how the killers rationalized their actions. They weren’t sadists, he explains. They were just doing their jobs.

The film doesn’t need to show the killings—we’ve seen them before, in other documentaries, in history books. What it shows instead is the paperwork: the reports, the casual tallies of the dead, the way mass murder was reduced to a line item. That’s the real horror.

Not the blood, but the spreadsheets.

The film’s weakness, if it has one, is its reluctance to dig deeper into the why of its own existence. Why now? Why this trial, this story?

The Einsatzgruppen killings aren’t completely forgotten—Browning’s 1992 book Ordinary Men covered similar ground, and documentaries like The Holocaust: The Revenge Plot (2019) have touched on the mobile killing squads. But Oldenburg’s film doesn’t engage with its predecessors. It acts as if it’s the first to uncover this history, which it isn’t.

That’s a missed opportunity. A stronger film might have asked why this story keeps resurfacing, why we keep needing to be reminded of it.

Still, there’s something undeniably powerful about the way Ordinary Men refuses to sensationalize. It doesn’t need to. The facts are enough.

The film’s most haunting image isn’t of a killing, but of a man—one of the defendants—smiling in a courtroom photograph, his face relaxed, almost serene. He could be your neighbor. Your uncle.

The guy who bags your groceries. That’s the point. Evil isn’t a monster in the dark.

It’s the man in the light, going about his day.

A grainy photograph of a courtroom, the faces blurred, the room filled with men in suits and uniforms, the atmosphere heavy with the weight of testimony.

I watched this film on a quiet Tuesday evening, the kind of night where the world feels still. By the end, I felt like I’d been holding my breath. Not because of the violence—though there’s plenty of that in the testimony—but because of the silence that follows.

The film doesn’t offer easy answers. It doesn’t tell us how to feel. It just presents the facts, then leaves us alone with them.

And that, in the end, might be the most honest thing it could do.

Audience Opinions

Limited evidence
"A harrowing yet essential documentary that forces reflection on the banality of evil through its unflinching focus on ordinary perpetrators."

A difficult but necessary watch: a rigorous examination of how ordinary individuals became complicit in atrocities. It avoids sensationalism and relies on historical testimony, though the subject matter is emotionally overwhelming and the pacing slow for casual audiences.

What viewers praise
  • Unflinching historical rigor Primary sources and expert analysis give a sobering, well-researched view of the Holocaust’s lesser-known participants.
  • Thought-provoking themes Raises uncomfortable questions about human nature, morality, and how easily ordinary people can enable evil.
  • Respectful tone Avoids exploitative storytelling and lets historical accounts and scholars drive the narrative.
Common complaints
  • Emotionally taxing The heavy subject matter and graphic discussion of violence make it a hard watch.
  • Slow pacing The methodical approach can feel dry or overly academic to anyone expecting a more dynamic style.
Recommended for
Holocaust history scholars Documentary enthusiasts seeking depth Readers of Christopher Browning’s work Those interested in moral psychology Educators teaching WWII history

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Chilling Truth Behind *Ordinary Men: The "Forgotten Holocaust"**

Manfred Oldenburg’s 2022 documentary Ordinary Men: The "Forgotten Holocaust" peels back the layers of one of history’s most unsettling questions: How did average citizens become cogs in the Nazi killing machine? The film, a stark departure from Oldenburg’s sports biopics like Kroos, dives into the harrowing story of Reserve Police Battalion 101—a unit of middle-aged German men who, with little ideological fervor, carried out mass executions of Jews in occupied Poland. But beyond its historical weight, the project itself has sparked intrigue for its casting choices, controversial reception, latestnetflix.com contends, and the director’s pivot from sports to genocide.

A Director’s Risky Leap

Oldenburg, best known for his work on athlete profiles (Kroos), took a bold turn with Ordinary Men. The 58-minute documentary marks his first foray into Holocaust studies, a genre demanding both sensitivity and unflinching honesty. While his sports films earned modest praise (a 6.2/10 on SensCritique), Ordinary Men has already outpaced them with a 7.4/10 rating, suggesting audiences and critics alike recognize the gravity of its subject. The shift wasn’t just creative—it was personal. Oldenburg has reportedly called the film his most challenging project, though specifics on his motivations remain scarce in the available evidence.

The Cast: Historians Take Center Stage

Unlike traditional documentaries, Ordinary Men leans heavily on expert testimony rather than dramatic reenactments. The cast is a mix of historians, legal scholars, and survivors, including:

  • Christopher R. Browning, whose 1992 book Ordinary Men inspired the film, dissects how "average" policemen became killers. - Benjamin Ferencz, the last surviving Nuremberg prosecutor, who died in 2023 at 103, provides firsthand legal perspective on Nazi atrocities. - Harald Welzer, a social psychologist, explores the banality of evil, a theme central to the film’s thesis.

Philipp Moog, the only actor in the traditional sense, narrates but doesn’t appear on-screen—keeping the focus squarely on the historians’ analyses. The absence of dramatic recreations is deliberate, Oldenburg has implied, to avoid sensationalizing the violence. Instead, the film relies on archival footage, photographs, and the chilling words of Battalion 101’s own members, read aloud by voice actors.

Controversy and Criticism

The film’s title alone—The "Forgotten Holocaust"—has drawn scrutiny. Some historians argue the term risks oversimplifying the Holocaust’s unique scale, while others praise it for highlighting lesser-known perpetrators. The documentary’s French release under Des hommes ordinaires: Un chapitre oublié de la Solution finale ("An Forgotten Chapter of the Final Solution") suggests international distributors are framing it as a corrective to historical amnesia.

Audience reactions have been polarized. While the 7.4/10 rating indicates strong engagement, some viewers have criticized the film’s dry, academic tone. "It’s more lecture than documentary," one SensCritique user wrote, though others defended its unvarnished approach as necessary. Oldenburg’s decision to avoid emotional manipulation—no swelling music, no dramatic reenactments—has been both lauded and lamented.

Behind the Scenes: Rumors and Unanswered Questions

Details about the film’s production are frustratingly thin. Oldenburg’s previous documentaries, like Kroos, were shot over months with extensive access to their subjects, but Ordinary Men’s timeline remains unclear. Rumors suggest the project was in development for years, with Oldenburg conducting research alongside historians like Browning and Welzer, though no official confirmation exists.

One unverified claim circulating in niche forums is that the film’s budget was a fraction of Oldenburg’s sports projects, forcing creative constraints. If true, it didn’t show—the archival footage is meticulously curated, and the interviews are crisply shot. Another rumor hints at tension between Oldenburg and producers over the film’s length; at 58 minutes, it’s shorter than many Holocaust documentaries, leaving some critics wanting more depth.

Why This Film Matters Now

Ordinary Men arrives at a fraught moment. Rising far-right movements in Europe and the U.S. Have reignited debates about complicity, propaganda, and the dangers of "ordinary" people enabling extremism. The film’s central question—How could they?—resonates far beyond 1940s Poland. As historian Stefan Kühl notes in the documentary, the mechanisms of dehumanization and obedience aren’t relics of the past.

Oldenburg’s film doesn’t offer easy answers. Instead, it forces viewers to confront uncomfortable truths: that evil isn’t always monstrous, and that the line between bystander and perpetrator can be terrifyingly thin.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.