Skip to main content
Series poster for The Trial (2019)

The Trial

2019
Canceled • 1 Season • 8 Episodes
TV-MA · Italian
Search on Netflix

Overview

The murder of a teen girl impacts a public prosecutor linked to the victim, a lawyer seeking a career-making case and a suspect who says she's innocent.

Seasons

Status
Canceled
Seasons
1 season
Episodes
8 episodes
First aired
Nov 29, 2019

Cast

12 people

Reviews

6 min read

The Courtroom as a Mirror: How The Trial Turns Justice Into a Hall of Mirrors

I’ve always been drawn to courtroom dramas less for their legal fireworks than for the way they lay bare the fragility of truth. The Trial, Stefano Lodovichi’s eight-episode Italian mini-series, understands this instinctively. It doesn’t just ask whether the accused is guilty—it asks whether guilt, innocence, or even justice can ever be cleanly separated from the people who define them. The answer, it turns out, is as murky as the reflection in a rain-slicked Mantua street at night.

A dimly lit courtroom, the prosecutor Elena Guerra standing at the center, her shadow stretching long across the wooden floor as she addresses the judge.

The series opens with the murder of Angelica Petroni, a 17-year-old girl found dead in the lake outside Mantua. The suspect is Claudia Marini (Camilla Filippi), a local woman with a history of erratic behavior and a connection to Angelica that’s more complicated than it first appears. But the real tension isn’t in the whodunit—it’s in the people tasked with untangling the mess.

Elena Guerra (Vittoria Puccini), the prosecutor, carries a secret that ties her to Angelica in ways she can’t afford to reveal. And Ruggero Barone (Francesco Scianna), the defense attorney, is a man who treats the law like a game of chess, where the pieces are people and the stakes are careers. Their adversarial relationship isn’t just professional; it’s personal, a slow-burning duel that plays out in glances, pauses, and the kind of dialogue that feels like it’s been sharpened to a point.

What makes The Trial more than just another procedural is its refusal to let the audience off the hook. Lodovichi and his co-writers (Alessandro Fabbri, Laura Colella, and Enrico Audenino) structure the story around parallel timelines: the trial itself, unfolding in real time, and the night of the murder, revealed in fragments. This isn’t a new trick—The Affair did something similar, and The Night Of played with perspective in its own way—but The Trial uses it to expose how memory and bias warp the truth.

A witness’s testimony might seem damning in one scene, only to be undercut by a flashback that reveals their recollection was shaped by fear, or shame, or something darker. The effect is less about solving the crime than about watching the legal system—supposedly the great equalizer—bend under the weight of human frailty.

A wide shot of Mantua at dusk, the city’s medieval towers and rooftops bathed in golden light, the lake in the distance reflecting the fading sun.

The show’s visual language reinforces this idea. Lodovichi shoots Mantua like a character in its own right, a city steeped in history and decay. The drone shots of its Renaissance palazzos and labyrinthine streets aren’t just pretty establishing shots—they’re a reminder that this place has seen centuries of secrets, of power and privilege shielding the guilty.

The courtroom scenes, by contrast, are claustrophobic, the camera often lingering on faces in tight close-ups, the way a prosecutor might study a witness for a tell. There’s a moment in the third episode where Elena and Ruggero face off across the courtroom, the camera pushing in on their profiles as they trade barbs. It’s a small choice, but it turns their legal sparring into something almost intimate, like two dancers locked in a tango they can’t escape.

Puccini and Scianna are the show’s anchors, and their performances are what keep The Trial from collapsing under its own ambition. Puccini’s Elena is a study in controlled tension—her posture rigid, her voice measured, but her eyes betraying a current of something raw beneath. There’s a scene in the fifth episode where she’s alone in her office, staring at a photo of Angelica.

She doesn’t say a word. She doesn’t need to. The way her fingers tremble as she reaches for the frame tells you everything about the guilt she’s carrying.

Scianna, meanwhile, plays Ruggero as a man who’s always three steps ahead, his charm a weapon as much as his intellect. But there’s a brittleness to him, too—a sense that his confidence is a performance, one that might crack if pressed too hard. Their scenes together crackle with an energy that’s equal parts attraction and antagonism, and it’s to the show’s credit that it never reduces their dynamic to a will-they-won’t-they cliché.

If The Trial stumbles, it’s in its pacing. The series takes its time, and while that’s often a strength, there are moments where the slow burn feels less like deliberate tension and more like padding. The courtroom scenes, in particular, can drag, especially in the middle episodes where the procedural elements threaten to overwhelm the character drama.

(There’s a subplot involving a corrupt judge that feels like it belongs in a different show entirely.) And while the flashbacks are effective, they’re also repetitive—by the sixth episode, you’ve seen the night of the murder from so many angles that the reveal loses some of its punch. Decider’s review put it bluntly: "The Trial starts out so shaky that even if it improves, the hoops that it jumps through... puts the rest of the series in doubt." That’s a little harsh, but not entirely unfair.

Elena Guerra and Ruggero Barone standing in a dimly lit hallway, their faces half in shadow, the tension between them palpable as they exchange a charged glance.

What saves the show from its own excesses is its willingness to grapple with uncomfortable questions. The Trial isn’t just about whether Claudia killed Angelica—it’s about whether the legal system is capable of delivering justice when the people running it are as flawed as the people on trial. Elena’s secret—that Angelica was her biological daughter, given up for adoption years earlier—isn’t just a soap-opera twist.

It’s a gut punch that forces the audience to confront their own biases. Would we trust her to be impartial if we knew? Would we even want her to be?

The show doesn’t offer easy answers, and that’s its greatest strength.

The English dub, by the way, is a disaster. I don’t say that lightly. The voices are mismatched, the timing is off, and there’s a moment in the first episode where Ruggero’s lips move but the words come out a beat too late, like a badly dubbed kung fu movie.

It’s distracting enough that it’s worth switching to the original Italian with subtitles, even if you’re not a purist. (And if you are a purist, well, you already knew that.)

The Trial isn’t perfect. It’s too long, too uneven, and at times too willing to indulge in courtroom theatrics that strain credibility. But when it works, it works because it understands something fundamental about justice: that it’s not a destination, but a process, and one that’s only as honest as the people guiding it.

By the final episode, the case is resolved, but the questions linger. What does it mean to seek the truth when the truth is a moving target? And what happens when the people we trust to uphold the law are just as broken as the rest of us?

I keep thinking about that scene in Elena’s office, the way she holds Angelica’s photo like it’s something fragile, something that might shatter if she grips it too tightly. That’s the image that stays with me—not the verdict, not the twist, but the quiet, private moment of a woman realizing that justice, for her, will never feel like enough.

Audience Opinions

"A gripping Italian crime drama with strong performances but uneven pacing and a convoluted plot."

Intense performances, particularly from the leads, give the crime story depth. The series suffers from a slow build-up and an overly complex storyline that is hard to follow at times. The atmospheric tension is a highlight, but the execution is mixed.

What viewers praise
  • Strong lead performances Vittoria Puccini and Francesco Scianna deliver compelling performances that anchor the series.
  • Atmospheric tension A moody, suspenseful tone holds attention.
  • Unique Italian setting The Italian backdrop and cultural details give the crime genre a fresh angle.
Common complaints
  • Convoluted plot The storyline is overly complex and difficult to follow.
  • Uneven pacing The slow build-up makes the series feel drawn out.
  • Underdeveloped side characters Supporting characters lack depth, which weakens the overall narrative.
Recommended for
Italian crime drama enthusiasts Fans of intense character studies Viewers who enjoy slow-burn mysteries

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Inside Netflix’s Italian Legal Thriller The Trial: Behind the Scenes of Il Processo

Stefano Lodovichi’s The Trial (Il Processo), the 2019 Italian legal drama that became a sleeper hit on Netflix, blends courtroom tension with personal betrayal. Starring Vittoria Puccini and Francesco Scianna, the series follows a prosecutor navigating a high-stakes murder case while confronting her own past. But how did this gripping thriller come together? Here’s what the evidence reveals about its creation, reception, latestnetflix.com contends, and behind-the-scenes buzz.


From Tuscany to Netflix: Lodovichi’s Vision

Stefano Lodovichi, born in Grosseto, Tuscany, in 1983, cut his teeth in thriller and drama genres before The Trial. A 2007 graduate, he built a reputation for taut storytelling, often blending crime with psychological depth. While the SERP doesn’t detail his exact pitch for Il Processo, his background suggests a deliberate choice to merge legal procedural tropes with Italian cinematic flair. The series’ opening credits—a moody, neon-lit montage—hint at Lodovichi’s stylistic signature, emphasizing atmosphere over exposition.

Netflix’s involvement likely amplified the show’s reach. Though the SERP doesn’t confirm production budgets or streaming deals, The Trial’s 2020 Netflix release (despite its 2019 Italian debut) aligns with the platform’s push into European originals. Rumors of a second season swirled early, with YouTube clips teasing plot extensions, though no official renewal has been confirmed.


Casting the Courtroom: Puccini and Scianna’s Dynamic

Vittoria Puccini, known for her roles in Italian period dramas, takes center stage as Elena Guerra, a prosecutor whose personal ties to the case complicate her pursuit of justice. Her chemistry with Francesco Scianna, who plays defense attorney Ruggero Barone, became a talking point. Scianna, a rising star in Italian cinema, reportedly brought a "charming but ruthless" energy to the role, clashing with Puccini’s steely resolve.

Supporting cast members like Camilla Filippi (as Elena’s sister) and Simone Colombari (as a shady businessman) added layers to the narrative. The SERP doesn’t reveal behind-the-scenes tensions or rehearsal anecdotes, but reviews praised the ensemble’s ability to balance legal jargon with emotional rawness. One YouTube reviewer called Puccini’s performance "a masterclass in restrained intensity," though others noted the show’s pacing lagged in early episodes.


Reception: Praise, Criticism, and Confusion

The Trial’s arrival on Netflix sparked mixed reactions. Some viewers lauded its "authentic Italian grit" and twist-heavy plot, while others criticized its convoluted timeline. The SERP highlights a common complaint: confusion with similarly titled projects, like The Trial of the Chicago 7 (2020), which dominated headlines around the same time. Rotten Tomatoes’ page for The Trial (2019) is notably sparse, with no critic scores or audience ratings visible in the evidence.

YouTube reviews offer a snapshot of fan reactions. One clip describes the series as "a slow-burn thriller with a payoff worth the wait," while another calls it "overly melodramatic". The show’s trailer, which teases a shocking murder and a web of lies, set high expectations—some of which the series struggled to meet.


The Future: Will There Be a Season 2?

Rumors of a second season persist, fueled by Netflix’s history of renewing international hits. A YouTube video from 2021 speculates about new plotlines, including Elena’s unresolved family drama and Barone’s murky alliances. However, the SERP contains no official confirmation from Lodovichi or Netflix. If greenlit, Season 2 would likely dive deeper into the show’s central mystery, though production delays or cast scheduling could pose hurdles.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.