
Margaret Qualley
Honey O'Donahue

“She only has two desires, and one of them is justice.”
Honey O'Donahue, a small-town private investigator, delves into a series of strange deaths tied to a mysterious church.
Official
I’m beginning to suspect Ethan Coen and Tricia Cooke are mostly interested in seeing whether the rest of us can keep pace. Their so-called "lesbian B-movie trilogy" started last year with Drive-Away Dolls, which felt like a sugar-rushed swerve. Now Honey Don't! arrives and trades highway chaos for a sun-blasted, vaguely desolate Bakersfield neo-noir.
It’s an odd movie, no question. latestnetflix.com's read is that i’m still unconvinced it hangs together as a mystery in the usual sense, but that also seems beside the point.

The story, if that word even quite fits, is all hardboiled fragments, detours, and false leads. Margaret Qualley plays Honey O'Donahue, a local private eye who still favors a Rolodex and carries quarters for pay phones. After a young woman is found dead in an overturned car in Antelope Canyon, Honey starts tugging at clues that lead to the Four-Way Temple, a church that also happens to function as a drug-trafficking operation.
Coen and Cooke push hard on their Bogart and Altman influences, sketching a version of California that has nothing to do with glamour and everything to do with cheap motels and strip-mall fatigue. The film looks right. The mood is there.
The engine, though, coughs now and then.
There’s an early scene that lays out the movie’s whole wavelength. Honey stands over the wreck in the canyon, statuesque in high-waisted slacks and heels. Nearby, Marty (Charlie Day), a local homicide detective, is so busy fumbling through a flirtation with a woman who has already told him more than once that she likes girls that he barely registers the corpse.
Qualley doesn’t waste energy on an eye roll. She just looks at him with that dead, drained expression of someone who has already spent too much time on fools. The joke isn’t really that she’s a woman in a male-dominated space.
It’s that most of the men around her barely merit the effort.

Qualley keeps the movie from drifting away completely. After so many performances built on jittery movement and manic energy, it’s striking to watch her sink into this kind of low-key, heavy-eyed cynicism. She barely has to move.
Everything feels measured, watchful, almost predatory. The film really comes alive in her scenes with Aubrey Plaza, who plays a sharply combative local cop named MG Falcone. The two of them orbit each other with this brittle, guarded rhythm that eventually turns into real heat.
Then there’s Chris Evans. If anyone wondered where all that post-Captain America goodwill might go, apparently the answer is straight into the furnace. As Reverend Drew Devlin, Evans plays a slick, sex-fixated cult leader using his church to move narcotics for "the French."
He ditches every trace of upright heroism. He slumps. He grins.
He turns that all-American face into something greasy and hollow. It’s a ludicrous performance in the best way, and a very funny one too. You come away wishing he’d gone villainous sooner.

Whether any of that is enough for a full ninety minutes will mostly come down to your tolerance for shaggy pulp. The script can feel less like a story than a pile of moods and stylistic habits looking for something sturdier to hold onto. Then again, maybe that looseness is the appeal.
As /Film’s Bill Bria noted, "It’s Qualley who takes the reins of the film so thoroughly that it’d still be a pleasure to watch even if there were no one else in it." He’s right. Honey Don't! is messy, uneven, and at times pretty maddening, but it never goes flat. Sometimes it’s enough just to watch a handful of very good actors stomp around in the dirt and call that the mystery.
"A scattershot queer neo-noir whose stylish look and charismatic lead cannot overcome a muddled story and clumsy writing."
Margaret Qualley’s performance and the queer detective premise carry most of the enjoyment, along with the offbeat humor, the sapphic couple, and the retro crime-movie vibe. Far more common are complaints that the plot is aimless and incoherent, side characters are thin or irritating, the tone lurches between dark comedy and crime thriller, and the sex scenes are excessive without emotional payoff, leaving the film shallow and frustrating rather than clever.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Midnight at Cannes, 24 May 2025. Honey Don't! Started late, past 12:30 a.m., and still got a standing ovation Deadline timed at six and a half minutes. Tricia Cooke, who wrote the film with her husband Ethan Coen, yelled that there should be more queer cinema all the time. Margaret Qualley's husband Jack Antonoff was in the room, clapping louder. Aubrey Plaza walked a red carpet for the first time after her husband Jeff Baena died in January. Chris Evans was not there. CinemaBlend reported he posted that it was his mother's 70th birthday, and that some things you cannot miss. latestnetflix.com's take is that Captain America picking his mom over a Palais midnight slot is the most decent thing anyone did that week.
Evans plays Reverend Drew Devlin, a Four-Way Temple preacher who is either sermonizing or in bed. Coen told Collider the pitch was simply to read the script, and that Evans "did it with relish." Qualley is Honey O'Donahue, a Bakersfield private eye in red heels, the second time Coen and Cooke have built a lesbian pulp film around her after Drive-Away Dolls. They have called the three scripts a lesbian B-movie trilogy. The third title they have floated is Go Beavers. Wikipedia notes the couple spent twenty years writing this stack. Variety reported Qualley telling i-D she had to dial back her "natural Scooby-Doo" instincts to play someone smoother.
A six-minute clap, then a $7.4 million thud. Focus Features opened the film in the United States on 22 August 2025. Rotten Tomatoes landed at 45 percent. The Numbers put the worldwide take at about $7.4 million against a $20 million budget logged on TMDB. What's on Netflix then confirmed a US streaming date of 3 February 2026, after a Peacock window, under Universal's new licensing path onto Netflix. A Cannes midnight movie with a Marvel star as a sex-cult pastor still needed the streamer to find a crowd.
Coen told Reuters he wanted the violence to be "fun, not just some like weird sadistic thing," chasing the inventiveness of Sam Raimi's early work. He also said he picked Bakersfield to capture a non-glamorous California. The Hollywood Reporter liked the performances and still called the movie a series of gags with nowhere to go. That is a polite way of saying the Palais will clap for anything at midnight, and Friday night in Des Moines will not.
The official Focus Features trailer is the click-clacking heels and Evans filling a need. Netflix now has the film. Coen and Cooke still owe a third B-movie. Evans already proved he will skip a festival for his mother. The rest of the trilogy will have to live with that energy.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.