
Mark Duplass
Aaron

After finding an ad online for “video work,” Sara, a video artist whose primary focus is creating intimacy with lonely men, thinks she may have found the subject of her dreams. She drives to a remote house in the forest and meets a man claiming to be a serial killer. Unable to resist the chance to create a truly shocking piece of art, she agrees to spend the day with him. However, as the day goes on, she discovers she may have dug herself into a hole from which she can’t escape.
Official
I’ve always had a soft spot for horror that doesn’t rely on jump scares or gore to unsettle you. The best kind lingers in the quiet moments—the way a character’s smile doesn’t reach their eyes, or how a room feels too small when someone won’t stop talking. Creep 2 understands this intimately. It’s a film that doesn’t just want to scare you; it wants to make you complicit in its unease, to question why you’re still watching when every instinct tells you to look away.
Patrick Brice’s sequel to his 2014 indie horror Creep doubles down on the found-footage aesthetic, but this time, the meta-layer isn’t just a stylistic choice—it’s the point. The film follows Sara (Desiree Akhavan), a video artist who responds to an online ad from a man named Aaron (Mark Duplass) claiming to be a serial killer. She thinks she’s found the ultimate subject for her work: a real-life monster to document.
What she doesn’t realize is that Aaron isn’t just performing for the camera—he’s performing her, and the line between predator and prey blurs with every passing minute.

The brilliance of Creep 2 lies in how it weaponizes the found-footage format. Found footage, at its best, sells the illusion of reality—it makes you forget you’re watching a movie. But here, the camera isn’t just a passive observer; it’s an active participant in the power struggle between Sara and Aaron.
Early on, Sara’s confidence is palpable. She’s the one holding the camera, the one in control of the narrative. But Aaron, with his disarming charm and eerie unpredictability, slowly inverts that dynamic.
By the time Sara realizes she’s not the documentarian but the subject, it’s too late. The camera, which was supposed to be her shield, becomes her prison.
This role reversal isn’t just a clever twist—it’s a commentary on the ethics of storytelling, particularly in horror. How many times have we watched a film where a woman is stalked, terrorized, or killed, all for the sake of entertainment? Creep 2 forces us to confront that voyeurism head-on. Sara isn’t just a victim; she’s an artist who thought she could exploit a killer for her own gain.
But Aaron, in his own twisted way, is an artist too. His medium isn’t film—it’s manipulation, and his canvas is Sara’s fear. The film asks: Who’s really in control when the camera is rolling?
And more uncomfortably, why do we keep watching?
Mark Duplass’s performance is the linchpin of the film’s tension. He’s played variations of this character before—charming, off-kilter, just unsettling enough to make you question his motives—but here, he dials it up to eleven. Aaron isn’t just creepy; he’s performative.
He knows he’s being filmed, and he loves it. There’s a moment early in the film where he grins at the camera and says, “I’m gonna make you feel something,” and it’s chilling because you realize he’s not just talking to Sara. He’s talking to us.
Duplass walks a razor’s edge between darkly funny and genuinely terrifying, and the film’s success hinges on his ability to make you laugh one second and squirm the next.
Desiree Akhavan, meanwhile, is a revelation. Sara could have easily been a one-note “final girl” archetype, but Akhavan brings a layered vulnerability to the role. She’s not just scared—she’s frustrated.
Frustrated that she walked into this situation, frustrated that she can’t outsmart Aaron, frustrated that her own artistry is being used against her. There’s a scene where she tries to reason with him, her voice trembling but her eyes sharp with calculation, and you can see the exact moment she realizes she’s in over her head. It’s a masterclass in how to convey fear without screaming.

The film’s pacing is relentless, clocking in at a lean 80 minutes. There’s no fat here—every scene serves to ratchet up the tension or deepen the unease. Brice and Duplass (who co-wrote the script) understand that horror thrives on what you don’t see.
The violence, when it comes, is abrupt and brutal, but it’s not the focus. The real horror is in the anticipation, the way Aaron toys with Sara (and by extension, the audience) like a cat with a mouse. The found-footage format amplifies this effect.
There’s no score to tell you when to be scared, no jump cuts to manipulate your emotions. Just two people in a room, and the growing sense that something is very wrong.
That said, Creep 2 isn’t without its flaws. The found-footage gimmick, while effective, can feel limiting at times. There are moments where the camerawork feels too shaky, as if the film is trying to remind you that, yes, this is supposed to look “real.” And while the meta-commentary on horror and exploitation is compelling, it’s not exactly subtle.
The film wears its themes on its sleeve, which might frustrate viewers looking for something more ambiguous. But then again, subtlety isn’t really the point here. Creep 2 is a film that wants to provoke, to unsettle, to make you question why you’re still watching when every fiber of your being is screaming at you to turn it off.
The ending, in particular, is a gut punch. Without spoiling anything, it’s the kind of conclusion that lingers long after the credits roll, not because it’s shocking (though it is), but because it forces you to reckon with your own complicity. The film’s final shot is a masterstroke of horror—quiet, understated, and utterly devastating.
It’s the kind of moment that makes you want to go back and watch the whole thing again, just to see how you missed the signs.

Creep 2 isn’t a film that will appeal to everyone. If you’re looking for traditional scares or a neatly wrapped-up narrative, you’ll likely walk away disappointed. But if you’re willing to sit with its discomfort, to let it get under your skin, it’s a fascinating experiment in horror.
It’s a film that understands the genre’s power to unsettle, to provoke, and to force us to confront the darker parts of ourselves. And in an era where horror is often reduced to jump scares and CGI monsters, that’s a rare and valuable thing.
As the French outlet SensCritique noted in its review, Creep 2 is a film that “plays with the conventions of found footage to create something truly unsettling”. It’s a fair assessment, but it doesn’t quite capture the film’s emotional punch. Creep 2 isn’t just unsettling—it’s personal. It’s a film that looks at you as much as you look at it, and by the end, you’re left wondering who was really in control the whole time.
The answer, of course, is the camera. And the camera never blinks.
"A divisive sequel that leans into dark humor and meta-commentary but lacks the unsettling tension of its predecessor."
The film tries to subvert expectations with self-aware humor and a shift in tone, but it works less well as horror. The leads' dynamic and the found-footage style still help, while the story's unpredictability splits opinion: clever to some, frustratingly uneven to others.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Creep 2 (2017) arrived three years after its predecessor, trading the claustrophobic tension of the original for a darker, more self-aware take on found-footage horror. Directed by Patrick Brice and starring Mark Duplass—who also co-wrote the film—the sequel leaned into the franchise’s signature blend of unease and dark humor. But behind the scenes, the production was a scrappy, latestnetflix.com maintains, improvisational affair that embraced its limitations to deliver something unexpectedly bold.
Like the first Creep (2014), Creep 2 thrived on spontaneity. Duplass and Brice’s creative partnership was central to the film’s tone, with the two often riffing on set to keep performances fresh. The sequel’s premise—a videographer (Desiree Akhavan) interviewing a man (Duplass) who claims to be a serial killer—lent itself to unscripted moments, as the actors played off each other’s energy. In interviews, Brice has hinted that much of the film’s dialogue was improvised, a technique that kept the tension unpredictable.
The low-budget nature of the production (reportedly under $1 million) meant long hours and minimal crew, but it also allowed for creative freedom. Brice, who also served as cinematographer, shot the film in just 12 days, a tight schedule that forced quick decisions and a focus on performance over perfection. The result was a raw, intimate horror experience that felt more like a twisted character study than a traditional slasher.
While the first Creep centered on a male videographer (Patrick Brice) documenting Duplass’s unsettling behavior, Creep 2 flipped the script by casting Desiree Akhavan as Sara, a journalist interviewing a man who calls himself Aaron (Duplass). The change in perspective added a layer of meta-commentary to the franchise, with Akhavan’s character serving as both audience surrogate and potential victim.
Akhavan, known for her work in Appropriate Behavior and The Bisexual, brought a dry, understated wit to the role, contrasting with Duplass’s increasingly unhinged performance. The dynamic between the two leads was a key selling point of the sequel, with critics noting how Akhavan’s presence elevated the material beyond mere shock value. Rumor has it that her casting was a deliberate choice to subvert expectations, though neither Brice nor Duplass has confirmed whether this was part of a larger thematic plan [unconfirmed].
Despite Creep 2’s cult following, the franchise has yet to produce a third installment. The sequel’s ambiguous ending—hinting at Aaron’s survival and potential for further chaos—left the door open for continuation, but no official plans have been announced. Brice and Duplass have moved on to other projects, with Brice directing The Overnight (2015) and Corporate Animals (2019), while Duplass has focused on producing and acting in films like Together Together (2021).
Fans have speculated about a Creep 3, with some pointing to Duplass’s comments in interviews about the character’s enduring appeal. However, without concrete evidence, the future of the series remains uncertain. What is clear is that Creep 2 stands as a unique experiment in found-footage horror, one that embraced its flaws and turned them into strengths.
Part of the film’s lasting appeal lies in its refusal to play by horror’s rules. Unlike traditional sequels that ramp up the body count, Creep 2 doubled down on psychological unease, using its low-budget constraints to create something unsettlingly real. The film’s 80-minute runtime flies by, thanks to Duplass and Akhavan’s electric chemistry and Brice’s tight direction.
Critically, the reception was mixed but passionate. While some viewers found the sequel’s humor too jarring for a horror film, others praised its boldness. With a 5.9/10 rating on SensCritique and a modest but dedicated fanbase, Creep 2 has carved out its niche as a meta-horror oddity—one that’s as much about the art of performance as it is about scares.
For now, Creep 2 remains a fascinating footnote in indie horror, a film that took risks and mostly paid off. Whether it’s the last we see of Aaron or just another chapter in a longer story, its legacy is secure as a sign of what can happen when creativity trumps convention.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.