Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Old Guard (2020)

The Old Guard

“Forever is harder than it looks.”

2020
2h 5m
R · English
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Four undying warriors who've secretly protected humanity for centuries become targeted for their mysterious powers just as they discover a new immortal.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Immortal Burden: How The Old Guard Turns Superhero Fatigue Into Something Quietly Revolutionary

I’ve seen this trick before—the slow-motion knife fight, the hero who won’t stay dead, the villain monologuing about power while the clock ticks down to the final explosion. Superhero fatigue isn’t just a phrase; it’s a physical sensation, like your eyelids getting heavier with every quippy one-liner. And yet, The Old Guard snuck up on me.

Not with spectacle, but with silence. Not with invincibility, but with exhaustion. Gina Prince-Bythewood’s film doesn’t just subvert the genre; it treats immortality like a chronic illness, one that leaves its carriers hollowed out by centuries of watching empires rise and fall, lovers wither into dust, and the world forget the names of the people who saved it.

Andy (Charlize Theron) stands in a dimly lit alley, her face half-shadowed, the weight of centuries pressing down on her shoulders.

Prince-Bythewood, best known for intimate dramas like Love & Basketball and Beyond the Lights, doesn’t approach this material like a director who’s been handed the keys to a blockbuster. She treats it like a character study with knives. The action sequences—often cited as the film’s standout feature—aren’t just well-choreographed; they’re tactile.

You can feel the impact of every punch, the drag of a blade through flesh, the way bodies move when they’ve been fighting for six hundred years. But what lingers isn’t the violence. It’s the way Andy (Charlize Theron) exhales after a kill, her shoulders slumping like she’s just finished a shift at a job she can’t quit.

Or the way Joe (Marwan Kenzari) and Nicky (Luca Marinelli) hold each other in the quiet moments between battles, their love so matter-of-fact it feels radical in a genre that usually treats queer relationships like subtext or fan service.

This is where The Old Guard does its most interesting work. It’s not just that the film features openly gay superheroes—though that alone would be enough to make it a landmark. It’s that their relationship is treated with the same weary tenderness as the rest of the story.

There’s no coming-out arc, no tragic sacrifice, no coded language. Joe and Nicky are just two men who have loved each other for centuries, and the film lets them exist in that love without fanfare. When they’re separated, the grief isn’t performative; it’s the quiet devastation of people who know they’ll outlive everyone they care about. The Daily Beast called it "the first movie with out gay superheroes," but the real achievement is how unremarkable their love feels within the story.

That’s the revolution.

Joe (Marwan Kenzari) and Nicky (Luca Marinelli) embrace in a sunlit room, their faces close, the weight of centuries together palpable in their touch.

The film’s most talked-about sequence—a brutal, extended fight on a cargo plane—is a masterclass in how to make action feel personal. Andy and Nile (KiKi Layne), the newest immortal, go at each other with a ferocity that’s less about spectacle and more about desperation. There’s no quipping, no stylized wirework.

Just two women trying to kill each other while the plane rattles around them, the camera lingering on their faces as much as their fists. It’s not just that the fight is well-choreographed (though it is); it’s that you can feel the exhaustion in their movements. Andy fights like someone who’s been doing this for too long, and Nile fights like someone who’s just realized she might have to do it forever. IndieWire’s Kate Erbland described the action as "eye-popping and narratively motivated," but what struck me was how much of it plays out in silence.

The score drops out at key moments, leaving only the sound of grunts, the thud of bodies hitting the floor, the ragged breathing of people who know this won’t be the last time.

That silence is key to the film’s emotional core. The Old Guard isn’t interested in the glamour of immortality. It’s interested in the cost. Andy’s been alive for so long she’s forgotten her real name.

Booker (Matthias Schoenaerts) drinks himself into a stupor to numb the memories. Quynh (Veronica Ngô) is trapped at the bottom of the ocean, her screams unheard. These aren’t superheroes; they’re survivors, and the film treats their pain with a kind of reverence.

When Andy tells Nile, "We don’t get to be heroes," it’s not a throwaway line. It’s the thesis.

Nile (KiKi Layne) stands in a war-torn landscape, her expression a mix of determination and dread, the weight of her new immortality settling over her.

The villain, Merrick (Harry Melling), is the film’s weakest link—not because Melling is bad, but because the script doesn’t give him much to do beyond being a greedy corporate ghoul. He’s a stand-in for the worst impulses of capitalism, a man who sees immortality as a product to be monetized, and while that’s a fine idea in theory, the execution feels undercooked. Variety’s Owen Gleiberman called parts of the film "logy and formulaic," and it’s hard to disagree when Merrick’s motivations are boiled down to a single, uninspired monologue about power.

But even here, the film finds a way to subvert expectations. Merrick isn’t defeated by a grand gesture or a last-minute twist. He’s undone by the very thing he sought to exploit: the immortals’ refusal to play by his rules.

What The Old Guard understands—and what so many superhero films forget—is that the most compelling stories aren’t about power. They’re about what power costs. The film’s final act isn’t a triumphant victory lap.

It’s a quiet reckoning. Andy, who has spent centuries trying to do the right thing, finally asks herself whether it’s been worth it. The answer isn’t clear-cut, and that’s the point.

Immortality isn’t a gift. It’s a burden, one that leaves its carriers with more questions than answers.

I keep coming back to the way Theron plays Andy—not as a warrior, but as a woman who’s tired of fighting. There’s a moment, late in the film, where she sits in a dimly lit room, her face half in shadow, and you can see the weight of centuries in her eyes. It’s not sadness, exactly.

It’s something heavier. Resignation, maybe. Or the quiet acceptance of a life that will never end.

That’s the real magic of The Old Guard. It takes a genre built on wish fulfillment and asks what happens when the wish comes true—and you realize you didn’t want it after all.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Behind the Scenes of The Old Guard: How Gina Prince-Bythewood and Charlize Theron Brought Immortals to Netflix

The Old Guard (2020) arrived on Netflix as a fresh take on the action genre, blending brutal fight choreography with a story about warriors who can’t die. Directed by Gina Prince-Bythewood and led by Charlize Theron, the film quickly became a standout in the streaming era. But how did this project come together? Here’s what we know from the limited behind-the-scenes buzz.


From Page to Screen: Gina Prince-Bythewood’s Vision

Gina Prince-Bythewood, known for films like Love & Basketball and The Secret Life of Bees, took the helm of The Old Guard after a career pivot into action. The director, born June 10, 1970, brought a unique perspective to the genre, emphasizing character-driven storytelling even in high-octane sequences. In interviews, she’s hinted at the challenges of balancing the film’s fantastical elements with its emotional core.

One key detail: Prince-Bythewood was involved early, working closely with the writers’ room to adapt Greg Rucka’s comic series for the screen. While specifics about script changes aren’t detailed in the available evidence, her hands-on approach suggests a commitment to staying true to the source material while making it cinematic. The director’s background in drama likely influenced the film’s focus on the immortals’ personal struggles, not just their battles.


Charlize Theron’s Physical Transformation

Theron, who plays Andy (the group’s centuries-old leader), is no stranger to physically demanding roles—see Mad Max: Fury Road or Atomic Blonde. For The Old Guard, she reportedly trained extensively to perform her own stunts, a point emphasized in promotional materials. Clips of her sparring with co-star KiKi Layne (who plays Nile, a new immortal recruit) showcase the film’s practical fight choreography, a rarity in an era dominated by CGI.

Theron’s dedication to the role extended beyond training. In interviews, she’s praised Prince-Bythewood’s direction, calling it a "masterclass" in action filmmaking. The actress’s involvement also helped attract a stacked cast, including Chiwetel Ejiofor and Matthias Schoenaerts, though details about their on-set dynamics remain scarce.


Netflix’s Gamble on an Action Original

The Old Guard was one of Netflix’s early forays into big-budget action films, a genre traditionally dominated by theatrical releases. The streaming giant’s decision to greenlight the project likely hinged on Theron’s star power and the built-in fanbase of Rucka’s comics. While box office numbers aren’t applicable, the film’s strong reception (a 7.2/10 on SensCritique) suggests it paid off.

Prince-Bythewood has spoken about the creative freedom Netflix afforded her, though specifics about budget or studio interference aren’t confirmed in the available evidence. The platform’s global reach also allowed the film to introduce diverse characters like Ngô’s Quynh and Layne’s Nile, a rarity in mainstream action.


What’s Unconfirmed (But Rumored)

  • Sequel Plans: A follow-up, The Old Guard 2, is in development, with Theron, Layne, and Schoenaerts set to return. However, details about Prince-Bythewood’s involvement or a release date aren’t public. - Behind-the-Scenes Tensions: No credible reports suggest conflicts on set, but the lack of on-record anecdotes leaves room for speculation. - Deleted Scenes: While some fans have theorized about cut content, nothing has been officially confirmed.

The Legacy So Far

The Old Guard stands out for its blend of action and pathos, a combination Prince-Bythewood executed with precision. Theron’s performance and the film’s practical stunts earned it a cult following, while its success paved the way for more comic-book adaptations on streaming platforms. Whether it spawns a franchise remains to be seen, but for now, it’s a rare action film that balances spectacle with substance.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.