Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Old Guard 2 (2025)

The Old Guard 2

“Eternity has a price.”

2025
1h 47m
R · English
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Andy and her team of immortal warriors fight with renewed purpose as they face a powerful new foe threatening their mission to protect humanity.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

Eternity’s Empty Ledger

I kept waiting for the moment when The Old Guard 2 would finally feel alive. Not the kind of alive that comes from bullets whizzing past or CGI blood splattering across a nuclear reactor’s sterile walls, but the kind that lingers in your chest long after the credits roll—the ache of a story that understands what it means to be human, even when its characters aren’t. The first film had that in spades, a rare superhero-adjacent story that treated its immortals like people first and warriors second.

This sequel? It’s so busy trying to out-mythologize itself that it forgets to feel like anything at all.

The team stands in a dimly lit corridor, their faces half-lit by emergency lighting, the weight of centuries pressing down on them.

Victoria Mahoney steps into Gina Prince-Bythewood’s shoes with a film that’s visually slick but emotionally hollow. The opening raid on a lakeside villa—shot around Lake Como, though the film insists it’s Croatia—is the closest the movie comes to recapturing the first film’s magic. Barry Ackroyd’s camerawork is kinetic, almost tactile, as KiKi Layne’s Nile speeds toward the compound on a boat, her teammates converging from all sides.

For a few minutes, it’s thrilling in the way only a well-choreographed action sequence can be: you can feel the weight of the guns, the snap of the ropes, the way the team moves like a single organism. Then the scene ends, and the rest of the film never quite matches its energy.

The problem isn’t the action itself. Mahoney stages a few set pieces with real flair—the Rome alleyway fight, where the walls seem to peel back through time, is a standout, a rare moment where the film’s visual effects serve something more than spectacle. But too often, the fights devolve into the kind of murky, CGI-heavy brawls that feel like they were assembled in post-production rather than lived in.

The climactic showdown between Charlize Theron’s Andy and Uma Thurman’s Discord, hyped as the sequel’s centerpiece, is a letdown not because the actors don’t bring it, but because the staging is so cluttered with digital debris that it’s hard to tell who’s winning, let alone why we should care.

Andy and Discord face off in a dimly lit, industrial space, their expressions tense with centuries of unresolved conflict.

And that’s the real issue: The Old Guard 2 doesn’t know what it wants to be. The first film was a meditation on the cost of eternity, wrapped in the trappings of a queer found-family action flick. This one wants to be a mythic showdown, a battle between gods who’ve grown tired of their own legends.

The shift isn’t inherently bad—there’s something compelling about watching Andy, now mortal, grapple with the vulnerability of aging, or seeing Veronica Ngô’s Quỳnh return after centuries trapped in an iron maiden, her rage and grief still raw. But the film buries these threads under layers of new lore, new characters, and a plot that feels like it was reverse-engineered from a whiteboard of franchise possibilities rather than an organic story.

Take Discord. Thurman’s casting is a masterstroke on paper—who wouldn’t want to see her square off against Theron in a battle of immortal titans?—but the character is given so little to do beyond monologuing about power and betrayal that she might as well be a hologram. The film teases a Kill Bill redux, but Discord’s motivations are so vague, her presence so underwritten, that her final confrontation with Andy feels like a contractual obligation rather than a reckoning.

(IndieWire’s David Ehrlich put it best: “Discord is never remotely interesting enough as a villain to justify all of the legwork required to make sense of her plot.”) Even Henry Golding’s Tuah, a new immortal with the thankless task of playing historian, is reduced to exposition dumps and a few well-timed quips. The film introduces these characters like it’s setting up a chessboard, but then forgets to play the game.

The returning cast fares better, though not by much. Theron is still magnetic as Andy, her physicality shifting subtly now that she’s mortal—her movements are looser, her reactions quicker, like someone who’s spent centuries bracing for impact and is finally learning to relax. But the script gives her little to do beyond reacting to the plot’s twists, and the emotional beats that made the first film sing (Andy’s guilt over Quỳnh’s fate, her bond with Nile) are either rehashed or sidelined.

KiKi Layne’s Nile, who was the heart of the original, is relegated to the sidelines for long stretches, her arc reduced to a few perfunctory scenes about leadership and legacy. The queer romance between Joe (Marwan Kenzari) and Nicky (Luca Marinelli) is still there, but it’s been stripped of the quiet intimacy that made their relationship feel revolutionary in the first film. A scene where they lie in bed, foreheads touching instead of lips, is the closest the sequel comes to recapturing that magic—and even then, it feels like a concession rather than a choice.

Nile stands in the foreground, her expression a mix of determination and exhaustion, while the rest of the team looms in the background, their faces obscured by shadow.

The most frustrating thing about The Old Guard 2 is how close it comes to working. There are moments—flickers, really—where the film remembers what made the first one special. A quiet scene between Andy and Quỳnh, where Ngô’s performance cracks open the film’s emotional core, is one of the few times the sequel feels like it’s about something more than its own mythology.

The Rome alleyway sequence, with its time-bending visuals, is another. But these moments are drowned out by the film’s relentless need to expand its universe, to set up the next installment, to be more. More lore, more characters, more spectacle.

What it doesn’t seem to want is better.

Mahoney has said this will be her last Old Guard film, even if Netflix moves forward with a third installment. That’s a shame, because there’s a version of this sequel that could’ve been her breakout—a film that balanced the franchise’s mythic ambitions with the emotional intimacy of the original. Instead, we get a movie that’s so busy building its own legend that it forgets to make us feel anything.

Eternity, it turns out, isn’t just a curse for the characters. It’s a trap for the storytellers, too.

Audience Opinions

Audience 4.1/10
"A disappointing sequel that can't recapture the original's magic, weighed down by weak storytelling and uneven execution."

Expectations were high for a follow-up to the first film, but the sequel lacks depth and excitement. The action scenes and returning cast are the highlights, yet the plot feels recycled and adds nothing compelling. It's widely seen as a missed chance to expand the lore or deepen the character arcs.

What viewers praise
  • Returning cast chemistry Charlize Theron and the original team still give strong performances and keep some of the first film's appeal.
  • Action sequences A few well-executed fights and stunts bring brief excitement, though they don’t make up for the weak story.
  • Visual style The film keeps the original’s sleek, stylized look, even if it doesn’t lift the experience.
Common complaints
  • Weak plot The story is repetitive and uninspired, rehashing the first film's themes without adding depth.
  • Underdeveloped new characters Uma Thurman and Henry Golding’s roles are criticized as shallow and poorly integrated with the existing team.
  • Pacing issues The film drags in places, and the uneven pacing makes the runtime feel longer than it is.
  • Lack of originality The sequel plays it too safe, with few fresh ideas to set it apart from the original.
Recommended for
Fans of the first film Charlize Theron action fans Light action movie viewers Superhero genre enthusiasts

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Behind the Scenes of The Old Guard 2: Director Swap, New Faces, and Netflix’s Immortal Sequel

The Old Guard 2 (2025) arrives as one of Netflix’s most anticipated action sequels, but its journey to the screen has been anything but smooth. Directed by Victoria Mahoney—stepping in after Gina Prince-Bythewood’s exit—the film reunites Charlize Theron’s Andy and KiKi Layne’s Nile for another round of high-stakes immortality, now with fresh faces like Uma Thurman and Henry Golding in the mix. The sequel’s production was shrouded in behind-the-scenes shifts, casting surprises, and a director’s vision that promised to deepen the franchise’s mythology. Here’s what we know.


A Director Change and a New Vision

The original The Old Guard (2020) was helmed by Gina Prince-Bythewood, whose work on the first film earned praise for its emotional depth and kinetic action. But when the sequel was greenlit, Prince-Bythewood was no longer at the helm. Instead, Victoria Mahoney—a director known for her work on Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker and Daredevil—took over, bringing a fresh perspective to the immortal warrior saga.

Mahoney’s involvement was confirmed in 2023, but the transition wasn’t without speculation. Reports suggested the change was amicable, though details remained scarce. In a later interview, Mahoney hinted at the sequel’s layered storytelling, teasing “surprises behind the curtain” that would expand the world beyond the first film’s scope. Whether this refers to new characters, lore, or narrative twists remains unclear, but her comments suggest a deliberate shift in tone or focus.


Casting Shake-Ups: Thurman, Golding, and a Rumored Nightmare Shoot

The sequel’s cast was a major talking point. Charlize Theron, KiKi Layne, Matthias Schoenaerts, Marwan Kenzari, Luca Marinelli, and Veronica Ngô all reprised their roles, but the additions of Uma Thurman and Henry Golding stole the spotlight. Thurman, in particular, was a coup—her involvement was announced in 2023, though her character’s role was kept under wraps until the film’s release.

Behind the scenes, however, not everything was smooth sailing. A report from The Direct described the production as a “nightmare,” though specifics were vague. The outlet cited unnamed sources suggesting tensions on set, though it’s unclear whether these were creative disagreements, scheduling conflicts, or something else entirely. Neither Theron nor Mahoney has publicly addressed the claims, leaving the rumors unconfirmed.


What the Reviews Say (So Far)

Early reviews for The Old Guard 2 have been mixed but leaned toward cautious optimism. The Hollywood Reporter called it a “worthy sequel” that delivers on the first film’s promise, praising Theron and Layne’s chemistry while noting the expanded cast’s potential. The action sequences, a hallmark of the franchise, were highlighted as a standout, though some critics felt the story’s emotional core didn’t land as strongly as in the original.

Netflix’s decision to release the film without a traditional theatrical run also sparked debate. The first Old Guard was a streaming hit, and the sequel’s performance on the platform will likely determine whether the franchise continues. As of now, the film has climbed the Netflix charts, suggesting strong audience interest.


The Future of the Franchise

With The Old Guard 2 now out, the question is whether Netflix will greenlight a third installment. The sequel’s script, penned by Greg Rucka (who co-created the original comic) and Sarah L. Walker, leaves room for further exploration, particularly with the introduction of new characters like Thurman’s and Golding’s. If the film performs well, it could pave the way for more stories—perhaps even a spin-off.

For now, fans are left with Mahoney’s vision: a sequel that builds on the first film’s strengths while carving its own path. Whether it’s enough to secure the franchise’s future remains to be seen.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.