
Mammootty
Sethurama Iyer

Series of bucket-killing murders happening in the city. Failure to resolve by police, a team of CBI Officers under CBI officer Sethurama Iyer take up the investigation to resolve the never experienced mystery.
I’ve seen CBI 5: The Brain twice now, and both times I’ve left the theater with the same strange sensation: as if I’ve just spent two and a half hours in the company of an old friend who refuses to acknowledge that the world has changed around him. Mammootty’s Sethurama Iyer is still there, still unflappable, still solving murders with the quiet confidence of a man who has never once doubted his own intelligence.
But the city outside his window is different now—faster, louder, less patient. And the film, for all its affectionate callbacks and sturdy craftsmanship, can’t quite decide whether it wants to live in the past or confront the present.
That tension is there from the very first frame. The camera lingers on a close-up of a pacemaker, its digital display counting down in eerie silence. A man collapses.
The screen cuts to black. Then, without warning, we’re in a brightly lit police station, where a room full of officers are debating procedure in rapid-fire Malayalam. The shift is jarring in tone and rhythm.
The opening murder is sleek, almost clinical; the investigation that follows is talky, procedural, and stubbornly old-school. It’s as if the film is trying to straddle two eras of crime storytelling: the taut, visual thrillers of today and the dialogue-driven whodunits of the ’90s, when the CBI series first became a phenomenon.

Mammootty, of course, is the reason this balancing act doesn’t collapse entirely. His Sethurama Iyer displays understated authority. There’s no swagger here, no Sherlockian theatrics—just a man who listens more than he speaks, who moves through the world with the unshakable certainty that the truth is always within reach if you just pay attention.
It’s a performance that feels effortless, but that’s the illusion: watch how he holds a teacup, how his fingers tap against the saucer when he’s thinking, how his eyes flicker with something like amusement when a suspect lies to his face. These are the details that make Iyer feel real, even when the world around him doesn’t.
The problem isn’t Mammootty. The problem is that CBI 5 is so determined to be a CBI film that it forgets to be its own thing. The original series, which ran from 1988 to 2005, was a product of its time: a world where investigations moved at the speed of paperwork, where clues were pieced together in smoky rooms over endless cups of tea, where the killer’s identity was less important than the satisfaction of seeing Iyer outwit everyone in the room.
That formula worked then because it was novel, because it played to the strengths of Malayalam cinema’s golden age of character-driven storytelling. But now? Now it feels like a relic.
Take the pacing. The first hour of CBI 5 is a slog, not because the mystery isn’t intriguing (it is—bucket killings, pacemaker tampering, a trail of bodies that seems to lead nowhere), but because the film insists on showing every single step of the investigation. There are scenes where characters do nothing but sit in offices and recap what we’ve already seen.
There are subplots—so many subplots—that go nowhere. A journalist’s personal vendetta, a corrupt cop’s side hustle, a love triangle that feels like it wandered in from another movie. None of it adds up to much, and by the time the film finally starts to pick up speed, it’s already burned through most of its runtime.

That’s not to say there aren’t pleasures here. The film’s best moments lean into nostalgia for the CBI series and a certain kind of cinema. There’s a scene where Iyer and his team gather in a hotel room, poring over case files under the glow of a single desk lamp, that feels like it could have been lifted from a ’90s thriller.
The dialogue crackles with the kind of wit that used to define Malayalam cinema—sharp, playful, unafraid of a well-placed insult. And then there’s Jagathy Sreekumar, whose brief appearance as Vikram is so charged with emotion that it nearly derails the film’s momentum. His character’s fate is a gut punch, a reminder of how much has changed since the last time we saw these men on screen together.
The mystery itself is clever, at least in theory. The killer’s method is inventive (if not entirely plausible), and the final reveal is satisfying in the way that all well-constructed whodunits are. But the film undermines its own cleverness by overloading the story with red herrings.
By the time the truth comes out, it’s hard to shake the feeling that we’ve been led in circles—not because the clues were subtle, but because the film couldn’t resist throwing in one more twist, one more suspect, one more unnecessary detour. It’s as if the writers were so afraid of being predictable that they forgot to be coherent.
And that, in the end, is the film’s biggest flaw: it’s trying too hard to be everything at once. A love letter to the past. A modern thriller.
A character study. A crowd-pleasing mystery. A vehicle for Mammootty’s star power.
A reunion for fans who grew up with these characters. It’s all of those things, and none of them fully. The result is a film that feels both overstuffed and curiously hollow, like a meal where every dish is competently prepared but nothing quite satisfies.

I keep coming back to that opening shot of the pacemaker. It’s the most modern thing in the entire film—a moment of quiet dread, a promise of something darker, more urgent. But the film never really commits to that tone.
Instead, it retreats into the comfort of the familiar, into the rhythms of a genre that no longer exists in the same way. That’s not a crime, exactly. Nostalgia has its place.
But when a film spends so much time looking backward, it’s hard not to wonder what it’s missing in the present.
Maybe that’s the real mystery here. Not who killed those men with the buckets, but why, after all these years, we still need Sethurama Iyer to solve it for us.
"A nostalgia-heavy fifth CBI outing powered by Mammootty’s presence but dragged down by old-school writing, slow pacing, and an overstuffed plot."
Mammootty’s return as Sethurama Iyer and the familiar investigative setup deliver some satisfying twists and a sense of homecoming for long-time followers of the series. At the same time, the 2.5‑hour runtime, sluggish pacing, cluttered subplots, and thin supporting characters make it feel dated and tiring next to sharper modern thrillers.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
When Sethurama Iyer dusted off his CBI badge after 17 long years, fans expected conspiracy, killers and clever reveals. What they didn’t expect was the off-screen swirl of illness scares, nostalgia-fueled meltdowns, latestnetflix.com argues, cameo rumors and “official leaks” orchestrated by the megastar himself. Let’s crack open the real case file.
Just as CBI 5 was picking up steam, Mammootty tested positive for COVID‑19 in January 2022. The shoot was immediately suspended while he isolated at home, a very 2020s-style plot twist for a franchise that usually deals with old-school murders, not viruses. Production had to wait for their leading man’s all-clear before the brain could get back to work.
Jagathy Sreekumar’s return as Vikram was less “casual casting” and more “miracle event.” After his 2012 accident left him severely injured and largely away from cinema, there was intense speculation about whether he could realistically appear in CBI 5 at all. - To make it possible, parts of his work were arranged around his health – including shooting at or around his own residence, and crafting a brief, carefully placed appearance. Reports emphasized how his cameo was designed as an emotional “moment” rather than a regular role. - The result? Viewers singled out his scene as one of the most important and moving beats in the film, praising the way his character was placed in the story.
There’s no credible report of on-set fights or actual bad blood among Mammootty, K. Madhu, S.N. Swamy or the rest of the ensemble. The drama instead played out online. - On Reddit, one widely shared thread bluntly titled “CBI 5 is likely going to be a bad movie” tore into the project months before release, calling the team outdated and predicting disappointment. - After release, critics echoed some of the fan fears, calling the script old-fashioned and the narration “a big letdown,” even while praising Mammootty’s performance and the nostalgia factor. So the knives weren’t out on set—but they were definitely out in the comments.
In April 2022, actress and classical dance icon Shobana casually dropped by the CBI 5 set. Mammootty shared a video of her visit with the caption: “When Nagavalli came to meet Sethurama Iyer”—a delicious crossover reference between Manichitrathazhu’s Nagavalli and the CBI universe. - Entertainment outlets reported that the visit, plus the video, instantly sparked rumours of a Shobana cameo, with fans hoping the legendary duo would reunite on screen. - She was seen lunching with Mammootty, director K. Madhu and writer S.N. Swamy on set, which only poured more fuel on the speculation. - In the end, no such cameo appears in the film. The “Shobana in CBI 5” storyline remains firmly in the category of “rumor that had everyone fooled”.
Before the real first look was out, fake images claiming to show Mammootty’s CBI 5 avatar started circulating online. Instead of a legal notice or a grumpy press release, the star played it like a pro troll. - He dropped the actual first-look still himself and captioned it “Official Leak! #CBI5 #untitled”, knowingly mocking the fake leak culture while feeding fans exactly what they wanted. - Gossip columns noted that this “leak” was deliberate, a classy little flex to reassert control over his own image after the fakes.
On Reddit, one popular speculation claimed that only Mammootty, director K. Madhu and writer S.N. Swamy knew the real villain’s identity during filming, with other cast and crew supposedly left in the dark by shooting alternative or misdirecting material. - This has never been confirmed by the team; it remains a fan rumor. But given how much the franchise relies on whodunnit twists, audiences loved the idea that the mystery extended off screen too.
The teaser for CBI 5 hinted that Sethurama Iyer’s new case might brush up against the assassinations of Indira Gandhi, Rajiv Gandhi and Sanjay Gandhi. - Entertainment pieces framed it as a “case of national importance” for Iyer, and fans spun wild theories about the film tackling real-world political conspiracies before release. - The final movie doesn’t fully turn into a Gandhi-assassination exposé, but the teaser did its job: it cranked speculation into overdrive.
While reviewers frequently dragged the old-school narration and flabby length, CBI 5 rode a wave of nostalgia and star power to become a commercial success, with strong box office returns and later a solid run on OTT platforms. Some Malayalam outlets specifically highlighted how it trended on Netflix despite “trolls,” proving that the Iyer brand is still very much alive.
In short: no explosive on-set fights, no cheating scandals—but a cocktail of health scares, fan wars, cleverly staged “leaks,” and nostalgia-fueled rumor storms made CBI 5: The Brain’s off-screen story almost as twisty as the basket killings themselves.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.