
Ryosuke Yamada
Edward Elric / Van Hohenheim (Slave No.23) / Young "Father"

“Hope is Unbreakable”
The Elric brothers’ long and winding journey comes to a close in this epic finale, where they must face off against an unworldly, nationwide threat.
Official
I’ve spent the last two weeks trying to figure out why Fullmetal Alchemist: The Final Alchemy left me so hollow. Not angry, not bored—just hollow, like a crucible that’s been scraped clean of whatever once burned inside it. The film runs 142 minutes, but the runtime feels less like a story unfolding and more like a countdown to a conclusion that never arrives.
This is a finale that forgets to feel final.

The problem isn’t that The Final Alchemy fails to adapt its source material—that’s a given, almost a rite of passage for live-action anime films. The problem is that it fails to adapt itself. Director Fumihiko Sori, who also helmed the 2018 Fullmetal Alchemist and The Revenge of Scar (both released in 2022, though their exact relationship remains frustratingly unclear), seems to have mistaken fidelity for vision.
The film’s alchemy isn’t about transformation; it’s about replication, a photocopy of a photocopy until the edges blur into something unrecognizable. The Elric brothers—Edward (Ryosuke Yamada) and Alphonse (Atomu Mizuishi)—move through the motions of their own story like actors reciting lines from a script they’ve never truly inhabited.
Take the opening act, where the brothers confront a nationwide threat that’s meant to feel apocalyptic. The camera lingers on wide shots of crumbling cities, the kind of CGI spectacle that’s become a shorthand for stakes in modern blockbusters. But the spectacle is weightless.
There’s no tactile sense of danger, no sweat or blood or the kind of physicality that made the anime’s battles feel visceral. In the original, alchemy was a craft—precise, painful, a science of equivalent exchange. Here, it’s just a special effect, a flash of light and a cut to the next scene.
The film’s most crucial moment, the titular "Final Alchemy," is over before it begins, a whimper where there should have been a scream.

The performances don’t help. Yamada and Mizuishi are competent, but competence isn’t enough when the material demands something rawer. Edward Elric is a character defined by his rage—at the world, at the rules of alchemy, at the brother he couldn’t save.
In the anime, his voice actor, Romi Park, made that rage feel like a live wire, dangerous and electric. Yamada’s Edward, by contrast, is all surface. His posture is rigid, his delivery clipped, as if he’s afraid to let the character’s fury spill over.
Alphonse, usually the emotional anchor, fares slightly better, but Mizuishi’s performance is hamstrung by the script’s reluctance to let the brothers talk to each other. Their relationship is the heart of Fullmetal Alchemist, but here, it’s treated like a subplot, something to be checked off before the next action set piece.
This is where the film’s pacing becomes its own kind of betrayal. At 142 minutes, The Final Alchemy has the runtime of an epic, but it moves like a film terrified of lingering too long on any one moment. The anime’s strength was its willingness to sit with its characters—to let them grieve, to let them fail, to let the weight of their choices press down on them.
Here, the emotional beats are rushed, as if the film is afraid the audience might get bored. (Maybe it’s right.) The result is a story that skims the surface of its own themes. Sacrifice, redemption, the cost of power—these aren’t explored so much as they’re name-dropped, like a checklist of "serious fantasy" tropes.

The film’s most glaring omission, though, is its refusal to trust the audience. Fullmetal Alchemist has always been a story about ideas—about the ethics of creation, the limits of human ambition, the way trauma shapes us. The anime didn’t shy away from complexity; it embraced it, weaving philosophy into its action sequences like alchemical runes into the fabric of the world. The Final Alchemy, by contrast, simplifies everything.
The villains are one-dimensional, their motives reduced to generic evil. The military, a nuanced institution in the source material, is flattened into a faceless antagonist. Even the film’s central conflict—the nationwide threat—feels abstract, a vague force of destruction rather than a specific, personal enemy.
This isn’t just a failure of adaptation; it’s a failure of imagination. The live-action Fullmetal Alchemist films have always struggled with the uncanny valley of their own existence. They’re not quite anime, not quite Western blockbuster, not quite faithful enough to please purists, not inventive enough to stand on their own. The Final Alchemy is the most egregious example of this yet.
It’s a film that wants to be a conclusion but doesn’t know how to earn one. The ending, when it finally arrives, is anticlimactic not because it’s bad, but because the film has spent two hours avoiding the emotional payoff it owes its audience.
I keep thinking about the SensCritique score: 4.1 out of 10. It’s a number that feels both too harsh and too kind. Too harsh because the film isn’t actively offensive—it’s just empty.
Too kind because a 4.1 suggests there’s something there to dislike, when in reality, The Final Alchemy is a film that barely exists at all. It’s a placeholder, a footnote, a shrug of a finale.
Maybe that’s the real alchemy here: the way the film turns something beloved into something forgettable. The Elric brothers deserved better. The audience deserved better.
Hell, the actors deserved better. But alchemy, as the story itself reminds us, is about equivalent exchange. And in this case, what we’ve lost is far greater than what we’ve gained.
"A disappointing conclusion to the live-action adaptation, marred by weak storytelling and uninspired execution."
As a finale to the live-action *Fullmetal Alchemist* series, the movie lacks depth and originality. The action sequences and visual effects are underwhelming, and the rushed, convoluted plot misses the emotional weight of the source material. The cast tries hard, but the execution falls flat.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Netflix’s 2022 live-action adaptation Fullmetal Alchemist: The Final Alchemy was supposed to be the climactic chapter of Fumihiko Sori’s film series, wrapping up the saga of the Elric brothers. Instead, it became a lightning rod for fan frustration—earning dismal ratings and sparking debates about whether the franchise should have stayed animated. latestnetflix.com's take is that here’s what we know about the troubled production and reception.
Fumihiko Sori, the director behind The Final Alchemy, has built a career on blending live-action with cutting-edge visual effects. Born in Osaka in 1964, Sori is a self-described "VFX specialist" who rose to prominence with projects like Ping Pong (2002) and Dragon Age: Dawn of the Seeker (2012). His work on Fullmetal Alchemist (2017) and its sequels—The Revenge of Scar (2022) and The Final Alchemy—marked his attempt to bring Hiromu Arakawa’s beloved manga to life.
But Sori’s approach has been polarizing. While his technical prowess is undeniable, critics argue his live-action adaptations struggle to capture the emotional depth of the source material. The Final Alchemy, in particular, faced backlash for its pacing, CGI, and deviations from the original story.
The film stars Ryosuke Yamada as Edward Elric and Atomu Mizuishi as Alphonse Elric, reprising their roles from the 2017 film and The Revenge of Scar. The supporting cast includes Tsubasa Honda (Winry Rockbell), Dean Fujioka (Roy Mustang), and Mackenyu (Scar), all returning for the finale.
Despite the ensemble’s familiarity with the material, fan reactions were lukewarm. Some praised the actors’ commitment, but others criticized the script for sidelining key characters and rushing the climax. The film’s 142-minute runtime —longer than The Revenge of Scar (125 minutes) —did little to quell complaints about pacing.
The Final Alchemy currently holds a 4.1/10 rating on SensCritique, based on 132 votes. That’s slightly lower than The Revenge of Scar (4.3/10) and a far cry from the 2017 film’s 3.6/10 —though the latter had a much larger sample size (1,624 votes).
Critics and fans alike have called out the film’s visual effects as a weak point. While Sori is known for his VFX work, some sequences in The Final Alchemy were criticized for looking dated or overly reliant on green-screen. The YouTube reaction video "Netflix's Fullmetal Alchemist Somehow Got Worse" sums up the sentiment: many felt the live-action adaptations failed to live up to the anime’s legacy.
Several factors may have contributed to the film’s poor reception:
Rumors swirled about behind-the-scenes tensions, but no concrete evidence has emerged to confirm production issues [unconfirmed].
With The Final Alchemy’s underwhelming performance, it’s unclear if Netflix or Sori will revisit the franchise. For now, fans seem content to return to the 2009 anime, which remains the definitive adaptation.
One thing’s certain: The Final Alchemy will be remembered as a cautionary tale about the risks of live-action manga adaptations—no matter how skilled the director.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.