Skip to main content
Movie poster for Brother (2023)

Brother

2023
2h
15 · English
Director: Clement Virgo
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Sons of Caribbean immigrants, Francis and Michael face questions of masculinity, identity and family amid the pulsing beat of Toronto's early hip-hop scene. A mystery unfolds when escalating tensions set off a series of events which changes the course of the brothers’ lives forever.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Weight of What We Carry

I keep thinking about the hydro towers.

Not the ones you see from the highway—those skeletal giants marching across the landscape, indifferent and utilitarian—but the ones in Brother, the ones Francis and Michael climb as kids in the film’s opening minutes. The camera lingers on their small bodies perched precariously on the metal lattice, the city sprawling beneath them like a promise or a threat. It’s a moment that feels both exhilarating and ominous, a perfect metaphor for the lives these brothers are trying to navigate.

And it’s the first of many times in Clement Virgo’s film that I found myself holding my breath, not because I was afraid of what would happen next, but because I was afraid of what it would mean.

Two brothers climb a hydro tower, their small figures silhouetted against a vast Toronto skyline.

Brother is a film that understands the weight of small moments. It’s set in the early 1990s in Scarborough, a Toronto suburb that exists in the popular imagination as a place of transit—somewhere you pass through on your way to somewhere else. But for Francis (Aaron Pierre) and Michael (Lamar Johnson), it’s home, and Virgo treats it with a kind of reverence.

The film moves between past and present, childhood and adulthood, but it’s not one of those flashy, non-linear narratives that calls attention to its own cleverness. Instead, it unfolds like memory: fragmented, associative, sometimes painful in its clarity. The structure isn’t just a stylistic choice; it’s a way of showing how the past lingers, how it shapes the present in ways we don’t always understand until it’s too late.

This is Virgo’s first feature in over a decade, and it feels like the work of a director who has spent that time thinking deeply about what stories are worth telling—and how to tell them. He’s no stranger to exploring Black Canadian identity; his 1995 debut, Rude, was one of the first films to center the lives of Black Torontonians, and Brother feels like a spiritual successor.

But where Rude was a mosaic of intersecting stories, Brother is more intimate, more focused. It’s a film about family, about the ways we try to protect each other and the ways we fail. And it’s a film about silence—the things we don’t say, the things we can’t.

Take the relationship between Francis and Michael. On the surface, they’re typical brothers: Francis is the older, protective one, the one who carries himself with a quiet authority; Michael is the younger, more impulsive sibling, still figuring out who he is. But their dynamic is complicated by something the film only hints at—Francis’ sexuality.

There’s a scene early on where Francis and his friend Jelly (Lovell Adams-Gray) share a moment of intimacy, but the film never names it. It’s not that Virgo shies away from the subject; it’s that he understands that for Francis, this part of himself is something he can’t yet articulate, even to his brother. The silence isn’t a failure of the film; it’s the point.

How do you put into words something that the world around you refuses to acknowledge?

A close-up of Francis and Michael, their faces half-lit in the dim glow of a streetlamp.

The performances are extraordinary, particularly from Pierre and Johnson. Pierre’s Francis is a study in contained emotion; you can see the weight of responsibility in the way he carries himself, the way his eyes dart away when he’s lying. Johnson’s Michael is more outwardly expressive, but there’s a vulnerability there that makes his moments of anger or defiance feel earned.

And then there’s Marsha Stephanie Blake as Ruth, the boys’ mother. She’s a woman who has spent her life trying to keep her family together, and Blake plays her with a quiet exhaustion that feels heartbreakingly real. There’s a scene where she’s folding laundry, and the way she moves—slow, deliberate, like she’s carrying something heavy in her bones—tells you everything you need to know about her.

But for all its emotional depth, Brother isn’t an easy film to love. Some of that is intentional; Virgo isn’t interested in giving us a neat, uplifting story. Life, as the film reminds us, isn’t like that.

But some of the difficulty comes from the film’s pacing. The non-linear structure works thematically, but it also makes the narrative feel thin at times, like it’s stretching a story that might have been better suited to a shorter runtime. The New York Times put it bluntly: the film’s “ultimately sparse dramatic elements feel more suited to a short film; in a feature-length production, they become too thin to support the big feelings and weighty themes.” I don’t entirely disagree.

There are moments where the film feels like it’s treading water, waiting for the next emotional beat to arrive.

And yet, I can’t shake the feeling that the film’s flaws are part of what makes it work. Brother isn’t a film that wants to tie everything up in a bow. It’s messy, like life is messy. It’s incomplete, like memory is incomplete.

And it’s heartbreaking, like loss is heartbreaking. There’s a scene near the end where Michael is standing in the rain, and the camera holds on him for what feels like an eternity. He’s not doing anything, not saying anything.

He’s just standing there, letting the water soak him through. And in that moment, you understand everything the film has been trying to say about grief, about the things we carry with us long after they’re gone.

Michael stands alone in the rain, his silhouette blurred by the downpour.

I’ve seen Brother compared to Moonlight, and while the comparison is understandable—both films are about Black masculinity, family, and the weight of silence—it’s not entirely fair to either. Moonlight is a film that builds to a moment of catharsis, of release. Brother is something different. It’s a film that lingers in the aftermath, in the quiet spaces between grief and acceptance. It’s not a film that gives you answers; it’s a film that asks you to sit with the questions.

And maybe that’s why I keep coming back to those hydro towers. They’re a symbol of aspiration, of reaching for something just out of grasp. But they’re also a reminder of how precarious life can be, how easily things can fall apart. Brother is a film that understands that duality.

It’s a film about the things we carry, the things we lose, and the things we can never quite let go of. And it’s a film that, for all its flaws, stays with you long after the credits roll.

Audience Opinions

Limited evidence
Audience 7.2/10
"A raw and emotional coming-of-age drama with powerful performances but uneven pacing."

The film is an intense, authentic portrayal of brotherhood, family struggles, and urban life, driven by strong lead performances. The pacing is slow and the narrative occasionally meanders, which dulls the overall impact.

What viewers praise
  • Powerful performances Lamar Johnson and Aaron Pierre give deeply moving, authentic performances that anchor the film's emotional weight.
  • Authentic storytelling Its portrayal of family dynamics and urban struggles feels genuine and heartfelt.
  • Emotional depth The exploration of brotherhood and personal growth leaves a lasting impression.
Common complaints
  • Uneven pacing Some scenes drag, making the film feel longer than necessary and breaking the flow.
  • Thin supporting characters The leads shine, but the supporting cast lacks depth.
Recommended for
Fans of emotional dramas Coming-of-age story lovers Fans of urban family sagas Lamar Johnson admirers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Behind the Scenes of Brother (2023): A Long-Awaited Reunion and Creative Gamble

Clement Virgo’s Brother (2023) isn’t just a drama about family, identity, and loss—it’s also the product of a high-stakes creative reunion. After more than a decade apart, Virgo and producer Damon D’Oliveira teamed up again under their shared banner, Conquering Lion Pictures, to bring David Chariandy’s award-winning novel to the screen. The result? latestnetflix.com's view is that a film that’s as much a labor of love as it is a bold artistic risk.

A 15-Year Gap and a High-Stakes Bet

The last time Virgo and D’Oliveira collaborated on a feature was Poor Boy’s Game (2007), a boxing drama starring Danny Glover. Since then, both have built careers in television and film, but Brother marked their return to the big screen together—and it wasn’t without pressure. D’Oliveira called the project “the embodiment of a huge risk,” though he didn’t specify exactly why. Was it the subject matter? The long hiatus? The challenges of adapting a beloved novel? The snippet doesn’t say, but the stakes were clearly high.

What we do know is that Brother required a leap of faith. The film centers on two Black Canadian brothers, Francis and Michael, navigating masculinity, grief, and belonging in 1990s Toronto’s hip-hop scene. That setting alone—rarely explored in Canadian cinema—made the project stand out. But the real gamble may have been in trusting the material to resonate beyond its niche.

From Page to Screen: Adapting Chariandy’s Novel

David Chariandy’s Brother, the source novel, won critical acclaim for its raw, poetic exploration of Black immigrant life in Scarborough, a Toronto suburb. Virgo, who also wrote the screenplay, stayed close to the book’s emotional core, but adapting it wasn’t just about transposing words to images. The film’s early 1990s Toronto setting—with its burgeoning hip-hop culture and racial tensions—required careful world-building. The snippets don’t reveal how Virgo approached the adaptation, but the result earned praise for its authenticity, particularly in capturing the brothers’ bond.

The cast, led by Lamar Johnson (The Last of Us) and Aaron Pierre (Old), brought the story to life, with Johnson playing Michael, the younger brother, and Pierre as Francis, the protective older sibling. Supporting performances from Marsha Stephanie Blake (When They See Us) and Kiana Madeira (Perfect Addiction) added depth to the family drama. But the real star may have been Toronto itself—a character in its own right, pulsing with the energy of a city on the cusp of change.

Critical Reception and the Weight of Expectations

When Brother premiered, critics took notice. The New York Times called it a “growing up grieving” story, praising its emotional weight and Virgo’s direction. The review didn’t look at specifics, but the film’s ability to balance personal and political themes clearly struck a chord.

The project’s win as English-Language Film of the Year at the 2023 Playback Canadian Film & Television Awards suggests it also resonated with industry insiders. D’Oliveira’s comments about the film being a “risk” imply that success wasn’t guaranteed, making the accolades all the sweeter.

Unanswered Questions and Lingering Mysteries

Despite the buzz, some behind-the-scenes details remain unclear. Why did Virgo and D’Oliveira wait 15 years to collaborate again? What challenges did they face in securing funding or distribution? The snippets don’t say, leaving room for speculation. Rumors about on-set tensions or creative differences? None appear in the evidence—so for now, they’re just that: rumors.

What is confirmed is that Brother was a passion project for Virgo, who not only directed but also produced and adapted the screenplay. That level of involvement suggests a deeply personal connection to the material, though the evidence doesn’t reveal whether his own experiences as a Jamaican-born Canadian influenced the story.

The Bottom Line

Brother (2023) is more than a film—it’s a sign of the power of creative risk-taking. After a long hiatus, Virgo and D’Oliveira reunited to bring a poignant, underrepresented story to life, and the gamble paid off. The film’s critical reception and awards recognition prove that sometimes, the biggest risks yield the most rewarding results.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.