Skip to main content
Series poster for The Motive (2020)

The Motive

2020
Ended • 1 Season • 4 Episodes
14 · Hebrew
Director: Asaf Sudry
Search on Netflix

Overview

In Jerusalem 1986, a 14-year-old boy shoots his family point-blank in their beds. Yet questions persist. In this docuseries, insiders come forward.

Seasons

Status
Ended
Seasons
1 season
Episodes
4 episodes
First aired
Dec 27, 2020

Cast

7 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Unanswered Shot

I keep thinking about the boy in the doorway. Not the one who pulled the trigger—though God knows he’s haunting enough—but the one who stands there now, decades later, staring into a camera like he’s trying to remember how to blink. That’s the first image that lodges in your mind when you watch The Motive, and it’s the one that lingers long after the credits roll.

A 14-year-old in 1986 Jerusalem, a crime so brutal it should have answers, and yet here we are, 34 years later, still waiting for them. The docuseries doesn’t just revisit the case; it forces us to sit with the discomfort of not knowing, of never knowing, and asks whether the truth was ever the point to begin with.

A dimly lit room, the camera angled low, capturing the shadow of a figure in a doorway—half memory, half accusation.

The case itself is almost too painful to recount: a boy, barely a teenager, shoots his family in their beds. No note, no clear motive, no confession that satisfies. The crime is the kind that lodges in a city’s throat, a wound that never quite scabs over. The Motive doesn’t pretend to have new answers.

Instead, it gathers the people who were there—cops, journalists, neighbors—and lets them talk, or rather, lets them not talk. The silences are louder than the words. One investigator, Yossi Arnon, describes the scene with a kind of clinical detachment, but his hands betray him, fidgeting with a pen like it’s the only thing keeping him anchored to the present.

Another interviewee, a journalist, admits she still dreams about the boy’s face. Not the face from the trial, but the one she imagines he has now, grown up, carrying the weight of what he did—or didn’t—do.

What makes The Motive more than just another true-crime deep dive is its refusal to sensationalize. There are no dramatic reenactments of the shooting itself, no ominous music swelling as the boy loads the gun. Instead, the series relies on the power of absence: the empty spaces in the story, the gaps in memory, the things people won’t—or can’t—say.

The directors, Tali Shemesh and Asaf Sudri, seem to have learned something from Errol Morris’s playbook, using the camera as a kind of lie detector. But where Morris often pries confessions out of his subjects, Shemesh and Sudri let the contradictions speak for themselves. A neighbor insists the boy was a quiet, polite kid; a cop recalls him as withdrawn, volatile.

Neither is wrong, exactly. They’re just seeing different versions of the same boy, the one who exists only in fragments.

The most unsettling moments in The Motive aren’t the ones that try to explain the crime, but the ones that acknowledge how little explanation matters. In one scene, a psychologist who evaluated the boy at the time describes him as emotionally stunted, unable to process what he’d done. But then she pauses, her voice catching. “Or maybe he just didn’t want to,” she says.

It’s a throwaway line, almost an afterthought, but it hangs in the air like a verdict. The series doesn’t need to spell out the implication: some acts are so incomprehensible that even the people who commit them can’t—or won’t—make sense of them.

A close-up of hands clasped tightly, the knuckles white, as if holding onto a secret.

That’s where The Motive brushes up against something deeper than true crime. It’s not really about solving a mystery; it’s about the stories we tell ourselves to make sense of the unsolvable. The boy’s community wants to believe he was a monster, because monsters are easier to understand than children who do monstrous things.

The investigators want to believe they got it right, even if the pieces don’t quite fit. And the journalists? Well, as one Rotten Tomatoes snippet points out, they’re accused of treating the case like “a tabloid spectacle,” but even that feels like a kind of coping mechanism.

If you can turn horror into entertainment, maybe it hurts a little less.

The series doesn’t let anyone off the hook, least of all itself. There’s a moment near the end where one of the directors, off-camera, asks a retired detective if he ever thinks about the case. The detective hesitates, then says, “Every day.” The camera lingers on his face, and for a second, you think he might cry.

He doesn’t. But the silence that follows is worse. It’s the sound of a question that will never be answered, a story that will never be finished.

And maybe that’s the point. Some crimes don’t have motives, just consequences. Some stories don’t have endings, just echoes. The Motive doesn’t give us closure.

It gives us something rarer: the uncomfortable truth that some questions aren’t meant to be answered. They’re meant to be lived with.

Audience Opinions

Limited evidence
"A raw, unflinching crime documentary whose authenticity is genuinely unsettling."

*The Motive* is a gripping but difficult watch, with an unfiltered portrayal of crime and its consequences. The documentary style and real-life material hit hard, though the content can be emotionally taxing and grim. Feedback is sparse but consistently points to its impactful realism.

What viewers praise
  • Unfiltered realism An authentic, unvarnished depiction of crime that avoids sensationalism.
  • Gripping storytelling A tense, immersive approach to real events holds attention.
  • Strong emotional impact The raw portrayal of its subjects leaves a lasting impression.
Common complaints
  • Emotionally taxing The content is too heavy or disturbing for casual viewing.
  • Limited accessibility The grim tone and subject matter are a poor fit if you want lighter entertainment.
Recommended for
True crime documentary fans Fans of raw realism Those interested in crime narratives

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Inside "The Motive" (2020): The Gritty Israeli Series That Turned Heads at TIFF

Netflix’s The Motive (2020) isn’t your typical crime drama. With its raw energy and unflinching portrayal of a tight-knit police unit in Israel, the series carved out a niche for itself—especially after premiering at the Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) in 2017. latestnetflix.com's view is that but what’s the story behind the show that had audiences buzzing?

A Festival Favorite Before Its Time

The Motive first made waves at TIFF, where its trailer dropped with the kind of intensity that suggested this wasn’t just another procedural. The festival circuit is often a proving ground for bold storytelling, and The Motive fit the bill—though its path to wider recognition took a few years. By 2020, Netflix had picked it up, giving the series a second life and a global audience. The TIFF trailer hinted at a show that balanced high-stakes police work with the personal demons of its characters, a formula that resonated with critics and viewers alike.

The Team Behind the Tension

Created by Asaf Sudri, Asaf Sudry, and Tali Shemesh, The Motive leans into the duality of its creators’ backgrounds—Sudri and Sudry bring a sharp, almost documentary-like edge to the storytelling, while Shemesh’s influence (known for her work in Israeli cinema) adds emotional depth [TMDB]. The cast, including Avi Samuel and Yossi Arnon, delivers performances that feel lived-in, as if the actors themselves have spent years in the precinct. Rumor has it the ensemble’s chemistry was organic, with improvisation playing a role in some of the show’s most tense moments—though details remain unconfirmed.

What Made It Stand Out?

Unlike glossy crime dramas, The Motive thrives on its authenticity. The series doesn’t shy away from the mundane grind of police work, nor does it romanticize its characters. Instead, it dives into the moral ambiguities of law enforcement, a theme that feels particularly relevant in today’s cultural landscape. The Netflix trailer teases this grit, promising a show that’s as much about the people behind the badges as it is about the cases they solve.

The Verdict: A Slow Burn with Bite

While The Motive didn’t explode into mainstream fame, it earned a cult following for its uncompromising approach. Rotten Tomatoes’ sparse but positive reception suggests it’s the kind of show that rewards patience—viewers who stick around are treated to a nuanced, character-driven narrative. If you’re tired of formulaic procedurals, this might be the under-the-radar gem you’ve been missing.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.