Skip to main content
Series poster for Nailed It! Holiday! (2018)

Nailed It! Holiday!

2018–2019
Canceled • 2 Seasons • 13 Episodes
12 · English
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

It's the "Nailed It!" holiday special you've been waiting for, with missing ingredients, impossible asks and desserts that look delightfully sad.

Seasons

3 listed
Status
Canceled
Seasons
2 seasons
Episodes
13 episodes
First aired
Dec 7, 2018
Last aired
Nov 22, 2019
Episode length
35m
Network
Netflix

Latest episode: S2 E6 New Year, New Fails (Nov 22, 2019)

  1. Season 1 poster

    Season 1

    7 episodes Dec 7, 2018 7.0
    1. 1 Jingle Fails
    2. 2 Winter Blunderland
    3. 3 You Mitzvah Spot!
    4. 4 It's a Family A-fail
    5. 5 Toying Around
    6. 6 3…2…1, Ya Done!
    7. 7 Just Do It Yourself!
  2. Season 2 poster

    Season 2

    6 episodes Nov 22, 2019 8.0
    1. 1 We're Scrooged!
    2. 2 A Classic Christmess
    3. 3 Shalo-many Fails!
    4. 4 It's a Wonderfail Life
    5. 5 One Fail, Two Fail. I Fail, You Fail!
    6. 6 New Year, New Fails
  3. Specials poster

    Specials

    3 episodes Nov 22, 2019
    1. 1 Sleighed It!: Ashley Tisdale and Brent Morin
    2. 2 Sleighed It!: Kiernan Shipka, Jacob Batalon and Isabela Merced
    3. 3 Sleighed It!: Hunter March

Trailer

Official

Reviews

4 min read

The Sweet, Sad Magic of Failing Together

I’ve never been much of a baker. My idea of a holiday dessert is a store-bought pie with the plastic lid still half-on, presented with a flourish and a lie: "I made this from scratch!" So when I first stumbled upon Nailed It! Holiday!, I expected to feel the familiar sting of inadequacy that comes from watching other people effortlessly craft perfect gingerbread houses or towering Yule logs.

Instead, I found something far more interesting: a show that doesn’t just tolerate failure—it celebrates it. And in doing so, it accidentally stumbles into a kind of communal therapy for the chronically imperfect.

The premise is simple, almost aggressively so. Three amateur bakers are given an elaborate holiday-themed dessert to recreate in a limited amount of time, armed with questionable skills, a handful of ingredients, and the kind of optimism that only comes from not knowing what you’re in for. The results are, predictably, disasters.

A gingerbread house collapses into a pile of cookie rubble. A "festive" cake looks like it was decorated by a toddler wielding a glue gun. A chocolate sculpture of Santa melts into a puddle of brown sludge.

And yet, the show isn’t about the failure itself—it’s about what happens in the space between the attempt and the collapse. That’s where the real magic lives.

A contestant's lopsided gingerbread house, its walls slumping like a tired sigh, while Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres exchange amused glances in the background.

Nicole Byer, the show’s host, is the secret weapon here. She’s not just a comedian delivering punchlines; she’s a hype woman for the human condition. Her reactions—whether she’s cackling at a contestant’s misfortune or gasping in genuine horror at a particularly egregious frosting job—feel less like scripted reality TV and more like the kind of laughter you’d share with a friend after a night of kitchen mishaps.

There’s no malice in it, no schadenfreude. Just the warm, slightly hysterical recognition that we’ve all been there. (I once set a microwave on fire trying to make popcorn.

I relate to these people on a spiritual level.)

The judges, too, play their roles with a light touch. Jacques Torres, the show’s resident pastry expert, could easily have been the stern authority figure, the Gordon Ramsay of holiday baking. But he’s not.

He’s more like the wise, slightly exasperated uncle who’s seen it all before and knows that the real lesson isn’t in the perfect execution—it’s in the trying. His reactions to the contestants’ creations are a masterclass in restraint. He’ll tilt his head, squint at a lopsided cake, and say something like, "I can see what you were going for here," in a tone that’s equal parts kindness and barely contained amusement.

It’s the kind of feedback that makes you want to try again, even if you know you’ll probably fail.

A contestant in a holiday apron holds up a cake that looks like it was attacked by a blindfolded child with a butter knife, while the judges try to keep straight faces.

What’s fascinating about Nailed It! Holiday! is how it reframes failure as something communal rather than isolating. In most cooking shows, the stakes feel high because the contestants are often professionals or serious amateurs, and the judges are there to critique their skills with a critical eye.

But here, the contestants are just regular people—nurses, teachers, accountants—who signed up because they thought it would be fun. The judges aren’t there to tear them down; they’re there to laugh with them. And the audience?

We’re not watching to feel superior. We’re watching to feel seen.

There’s a moment in one of the episodes where a contestant, after presenting a cake that looks like it was run over by a reindeer, shrugs and says, "Well, it’s not what I wanted, but it’s still a cake." That’s the ethos of the show in a nutshell. It’s not about the destination; it’s about the mess you make along the way. And in a culture that’s obsessed with perfection—with Instagram-worthy desserts and Pinterest-perfect holiday tables—*Nailed It!

Holiday! feels like a rebellious act. It says: You don’t have to be good at this. You just have to try.*

That’s not to say the show is some kind of profound meditation on the human spirit. It’s not. It’s a lighthearted, silly competition show designed to make you laugh and maybe crave a cookie.

But there’s something quietly radical about the way it treats its contestants. It doesn’t mock them. It doesn’t exploit their failures for cheap laughs.

It just lets them be human—flawed, funny, and utterly relatable. And in doing so, it creates a space where the rest of us can exhale. Because let’s be honest: most of us are not going to nail it.

Not on the first try, not on the tenth. But maybe, just maybe, that’s not the point.

I keep thinking about that contestant and her cake. It wasn’t what she wanted. But it was still a cake. And sometimes, that’s enough.

Audience Opinions

Audience 7.5/10
"A festive, lighthearted baking competition that delivers laughs and holiday cheer with its charmingly disastrous creations."

Home bakers tackle ambitious holiday-themed desserts with hilariously mixed results, making for a fun, low-stakes watch. The humor and Nicole Byers’ reactions stand out, though the challenges are repetitive and overly forgiving of failures. The festive, feel-good atmosphere keeps it entertaining for casual viewing.

What viewers praise
  • Hilarious failures The contestants’ baking disasters are consistently funny.
  • Festive atmosphere The holiday themes and decorations add a warm, cheerful seasonal vibe.
  • Nicole Byers’ reactions Her exaggerated but genuine responses to the bakes amplify the humor and charm of the show.
  • Low-pressure fun The lighthearted tone and lack of high-stakes drama make it an easy, stress-free watch.
Common complaints
  • Repetitive format The challenges follow a predictable pattern that can feel stale over multiple episodes.
  • Overly forgiving The show celebrates effort over skill, which frustrates anyone who prefers stricter competition standards.
  • Limited appeal If you dislike baking shows or reality TV, it may be too niche or silly.
Recommended for
Holiday entertainment seekers Reality TV fans Baking show enthusiasts Lighthearted comedy lovers Casual viewing

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s "Nailed It! Holiday!" (2018): The Festive Baking Disaster We Couldn’t Resist

Netflix’s Nailed It! Holiday! (2018) brought the chaotic charm of its flagship baking competition to the most wonderful—and stressful—time of the year. While the original Nailed It! series had already won over audiences with its hilarious mix of amateur bakers and disastrous desserts, the holiday special leaned into the season’s high stakes: gingerbread houses that defied gravity, cookie ornaments that looked more like abstract art, and cakes that seemed to mock the very concept of "festive cheer." But what made this seasonal spin-off tick? latestnetflix.com's read is that the evidence is thin on behind-the-scenes drama, but the trailers and reactions offer a glimpse into why it became a guilty pleasure for viewers.

The Concept: Holiday Pressure Meets Baking Chaos

Nailed It! Holiday! followed the same formula as the original: home bakers with big dreams and limited skills attempted to recreate elaborate holiday-themed desserts under tight deadlines. The twist? The challenges were even more ambitious—and the potential for failure even higher. Think towering Yule logs that collapsed into splinters, sugar cookies shaped like reindeer that looked more like roadkill, and gingerbread mansions that would make a structural engineer weep. The trailers for the special teased these disasters with glee, promising a mix of cringe and catharsis for viewers.

Unlike the original series, which often featured general baking challenges, Nailed It! Holiday! leaned into the season’s most iconic (and difficult) treats. The stakes felt higher, too—after all, no one wants to be the person whose Christmas cake looks like it survived a blender. The show’s hosts, Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres, played their roles to perfection: Byer’s over-the-top reactions to the bakers’ struggles provided much of the comedy, while Torres, the resident baking expert, offered a mix of sympathy and exasperation.

Nicole Byer: The Queen of Reactions

If there’s one thing the evidence makes clear, it’s that Nicole Byer’s comedic timing was a cornerstone of Nailed It! Holiday!. Clips from the special highlight her ability to turn even the most mundane baking mishap into a viral moment. Whether she was gasping at a lopsided gingerbread house or cackling at a cake that resembled a melted snowman, her reactions were a masterclass in physical comedy. While the evidence doesn’t reveal whether her antics were scripted or improvised, it’s easy to imagine the show’s producers encouraging her to lean into the chaos.

Byer’s dynamic with Torres also added to the show’s appeal. While Torres, a professional pastry chef, often played the straight man, Byer’s unfiltered enthusiasm balanced his measured critiques. Their banter felt organic, even if the evidence doesn’t confirm whether it was entirely unscripted. Either way, it worked—viewers tuned in as much for their chemistry as for the baking fails.

The Mystery of Season 2 (And Why It Might Not Have Been)

One of the biggest unanswered questions about Nailed It! Holiday! is whether it was meant to be a one-off special or the start of a recurring seasonal series. A trailer for Nailed It! Holiday! Season 2 surfaced in the evidence, suggesting Netflix at least considered a follow-up. However, there’s no confirmation that a second season ever materialized. Rumor has it that the original Nailed It! series’ success may have overshadowed the holiday special, leading Netflix to prioritize the main show over seasonal spin-offs.

Without more evidence, it’s impossible to say why Nailed It! Holiday! Season 2 never came to fruition. Was it a creative decision, a scheduling conflict, or simply a case of Netflix testing the waters and moving on? For now, it remains one of the streaming giant’s many "what ifs."

Why We Still Love It

Despite the lack of behind-the-scenes drama, Nailed It! Holiday! (2018) endures as a festive comfort watch. The show’s appeal lies in its simplicity: it’s a celebration of imperfection, a reminder that even the most disastrous attempts at holiday baking can be funny—and sometimes, just as delicious as the "perfect" version. The trailers and reaction clips suggest that the special delivered exactly what fans wanted: a mix of holiday spirit, baking fails, and Nicole Byer’s infectious laughter.

If there’s one takeaway from the evidence, it’s that Nailed It! Holiday! wasn’t trying to be anything more than a lighthearted escape. And in a season often defined by stress and unrealistic expectations, that might have been its greatest success.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.