Skip to main content
Series poster for Don't F**k with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer (2019)

Don't F**k with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer

“A shocking true crime story of online justice gone wrong.”

2019
Ended • 1 Season • 3 Episodes
TV-MA · English
Director: Mark Lewis
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A twisted criminal's gruesome videos drive a group of amateur online sleuths to launch a risky manhunt that pulls them into a dark underworld.

Seasons

1 listed
Status
Ended
Seasons
1 season
Episodes
3 episodes
First aired
Dec 18, 2019
Last aired
Dec 18, 2019
Episode length
62m
Network
Netflix

Latest episode: S1 E3 Closing the Net (Dec 18, 2019)

  1. Miniseries poster

    Miniseries

    3 episodes Dec 18, 2019 7.3

    A group of online justice seekers track down a guy who posted a video of him killing kittens.

    1. 1 Cat and Mouse
    2. 2 Killing for Clicks
    3. 3 Closing the Net

Trailer

Official

Cast

Reviews

4 min read

The Internet’s Dark Mirror: How *Don’t F**k with Cats* Exposes Our Complicity

I’ve watched *Don’t F**k with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer twice now, and both times, I’ve felt the same creeping unease—not just because of the horrors it documents, but because of how skillfully it implicates me*. The series isn’t just about Luka Magnotta, the man who filmed himself killing kittens before murdering a human being. It’s about the way the internet turns us all into voyeurs, armchair detectives, and unwitting accomplices in the spectacle of violence.

And by the end, it doesn’t let any of us off the hook.

The first time I saw the infamous "1 boy 2 kittens" video—described, not shown, in the series—I felt my stomach turn. But I kept watching. That’s the paradox at the heart of *Don’t F**k with Cats*: it’s a documentary that knows it’s part of the problem, yet it can’t resist the pull of its own subject.

Director Mark Lewis leans into this tension, using a "desktop film" aesthetic that mimics the experience of scrolling through forums, zooming in on grainy screenshots, and reconstructing the amateur sleuths’ real-time investigation. The effect is unsettlingly immersive. You’re not just watching a true crime story; you’re participating in it, your cursor hovering over the next clue, the next revelation, the next act of cruelty.

A close-up of a computer screen displaying a forum post, the text blurred but the urgency of the discussion palpable.

The series follows Deanna Thompson (alias Baudi Moovan) and John Green, two ordinary people who became obsessed with tracking Magnotta after his videos went viral. Their story is framed as a digital cat-and-mouse game, with Magnotta taunting his pursuers, leaving breadcrumbs, and even referencing films like Basic Instinct and Catch Me If You Can in his crimes. It’s a chilling reminder of how deeply pop culture shapes real-world violence—and how the internet amplifies it.

Magnotta didn’t just want to kill; he wanted an audience. And he got one.

But here’s where *Don’t F**k with Cats* gets really uncomfortable. The series doesn’t just condemn Magnotta; it implicates the very people who made him infamous. The amateur sleuths, the forum posters, the viewers who clicked on his videos—all of us who gawk at horror from the safety of our screens.

The ending is particularly brutal: Thompson and Green turn to the camera and ask, "Are you complicit?" It’s a moment that’s meant to provoke, but it also feels like a cop-out. The series spends three episodes indulging in the thrill of the hunt, only to wag its finger at the audience in the final minutes. As Stuart Heritage wrote in The Guardian, it’s a "glib" attempt to deflect from the fact that the documentary itself is part of the cycle it claims to critique.

A split-screen showing Luka Magnotta on one side and a forum post about him on the other, the tension between predator and pursuer visually distilled.

That’s not to say the series lacks merit. Ashlie D. Stevens at Salon called it one of the most compelling true crime docuseries on Netflix, praising its "energetic, expertly paced" storytelling.

And it’s true—the editing is razor-sharp, the tension relentless. But the ethical questions linger. The series replays clips of Magnotta’s crimes, including the murder of Lin Jun, while simultaneously trying to position itself as a moral arbiter.

It’s a contradiction that’s hard to reconcile. How do you condemn the exploitation of violence while profiting from it?

There’s also the matter of the South African misdirection. Early in the investigation, the amateur sleuths zeroed in on the wrong man—a young South African who later died by suicide. The series acknowledges this tragedy, but it doesn’t dwell on the culpability of the online mob.

Instead, it moves on, as if the collateral damage of internet vigilantism is just another plot point. It’s a glaring omission, one that undercuts the series’ attempt to grapple with the consequences of its own genre.

And then there’s Anna Yourkin, Magnotta’s mother, who appears in the documentary to defend her son and promote conspiracy theories about a mysterious "Manny." Her inclusion feels exploitative, like the series is mining her grief for drama without offering any real insight. It’s a moment that crystallizes the ethical murkiness of *Don’t F**k with Cats*: is this journalism, or is it just another form of true crime entertainment?

A grainy, distorted image of Luka Magnotta, his face half in shadow, evoking the eerie anonymity of the internet’s darkest corners.

What saves the series, in the end, is its self-awareness—or at least its attempt at it. It knows it’s part of the problem, and it forces the audience to confront that uncomfortable truth. But self-awareness isn’t the same as accountability. *Don’t F**k with Cats* is a gripping, well-crafted thriller, but it’s also a reminder of how easily true crime can become just another form of exploitation.

It doesn’t just document a killer; it mirrors the very culture that created him.

I keep coming back to that final question: Are you complicit? The answer, of course, is yes. We all are. And that’s the real horror of this story—not the crimes themselves, but the way we can’t look away.

Audience Opinions

Audience 7.1/10
"A gripping yet disturbing true-crime documentary that captivates with its real-life detective work but unsettles with its graphic content."

The series is praised for its intense, binge-worthy storytelling and the dedication of the online sleuths who pieced together the killer’s identity. Its graphic depictions of animal cruelty and violence are deeply unsettling, though, making it difficult to watch at times.

What viewers praise
  • Compelling storytelling The narrative structure blends true crime with investigative drama and keeps you engaged.
  • Real-life detective work Online investigators tracking down the killer make for fascinating viewing and show the power of internet communities.
  • Binge-worthy pacing Tight editing maintains tension throughout, making it easy to watch in one sitting.
  • Strong performances Deanna Thompson and John Green, the online detectives at the center, come across as authentic.
Common complaints
  • Graphic content The depiction of animal cruelty and violence is disturbing and may be too intense for some.
  • Emotionally taxing The heavy subject matter can be distressing or overwhelming.
  • Niche appeal Anyone uninterested in true crime may find the series less engaging.
Recommended for
True crime enthusiasts Documentary fans Internet sleuthing followers Gritty crime drama lovers Binge-watchers of short series

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Real-Life Sleuths Behind *Don’t F**k with Cats*—And Why They Risked It All

Netflix’s *Don’t F**k with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer* (2019) isn’t just a true-crime docuseries—it’s a rare glimpse into the obsessive, dangerous world of online vigilantes. The three-part series follows Deanna Thompson and John Green, two amateur investigators who spent years tracking a sadistic killer after he posted videos of animal cruelty online. But behind the gripping narrative lies a story of personal cost, ethical dilemmas, latestnetflix.com maintains, and the blurred line between justice and obsession.

The Internet Detectives Who Wouldn’t Quit

Deanna Thompson, a Las Vegas-based data analyst, and John Green, a Canadian animal rights activist, became unlikely partners in a digital manhunt. Their target? Luka Magnotta, a Montreal man who escalated from torturing cats to murdering and dismembering Chinese international student Jun Lin in 2012. The series reveals how Thompson and Green used forensic techniques—like reverse-image searches, geolocation, and social media deep dives—to piece together Magnotta’s identity long before law enforcement took the case seriously.

In interviews, Thompson has described the toll of the investigation. Speaking on This Morning, she admitted the work consumed her life, straining relationships and even her mental health. "It was like a full-time job," she said, though she stopped short of detailing the extent of the personal fallout. The series itself hints at the psychological weight of their pursuit, with Thompson recalling sleepless nights and the fear of becoming a target.

Why Mark Lewis Took the Risk

Director Mark Lewis, known for provocative documentaries like The Fear of 13, was drawn to the story’s dark irony: a killer who craved infamy was ultimately exposed by his own digital footprint. In a Netflix Brazil interview, Lewis explained his fascination with the case’s "cat-and-mouse" dynamic, where the hunters became the hunted in a psychological game of wits. He also acknowledged the ethical tightrope of glorifying vigilante justice, even when the outcome was undeniably just.

The series doesn’t shy away from the moral ambiguity of Thompson and Green’s methods. While their work led to Magnotta’s arrest, it also raised questions about the dangers of online sleuthing. What if they’d been wrong? What if their interference had tipped off the killer? The docuseries leaves these questions unanswered, focusing instead on the raw, unfiltered reality of their mission.

The Aftermath: Where Are They Now?

Magnotta was convicted of first-degree murder in 2014 and sentenced to life in prison. But for Thompson and Green, the story didn’t end with his arrest. Thompson has since become an advocate for digital privacy and online safety, though she rarely discusses the case publicly. Green, meanwhile, has largely stepped away from the spotlight, though his role in the investigation remains a defining chapter of his life.

The series’ 7.1/10 rating on SensCritique suggests audiences were captivated—but also unsettled—by the story’s real-world stakes. Unlike scripted crime dramas, *Don’t F**k with Cats* forces viewers to confront the messy, often disturbing reality of justice in the digital age.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.