Skip to main content
Movie poster for Best of Enemies (2015)

Best of Enemies

“Buckley vs. Vidal. 2 Men. 10 Debates. Television Would Never Be the Same.”

2015
1h 27m
12 · English
Director: Robert Gordon
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A documentary about the legendary series of nationally televised debates in 1968 between two great public intellectuals, the liberal Gore Vidal and the conservative William F. Buckley Jr. Intended as commentary on the issues of their day, these vitriolic and explosive encounters came to define the modern era of public discourse in the media, marking the big bang moment of our contemporary media landscape when spectacle trumped content and argument replaced substance. Best of Enemies delves into the entangled biographies of these two great thinkers, and luxuriates in the language and the theater of their debates, begging the question, "What has television done to the way we discuss politics in our democracy today?"

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Debate That Broke the Screen

I’ve rewatched the moment a dozen times, and it still feels like watching two men try to strangle each other with words. The camera lingers on William F. Buckley Jr.’s face—jaw clenched, lips pursed—as Gore Vidal calls him a “crypto-Nazi” during their 1968 ABC News debate.

Buckley’s nostrils flare. His voice cracks. “Now listen, you queer,” he snarls, “stop calling me a crypto-Nazi or I’ll sock you in your goddamn face.” The studio audience gasps. The moderator stammers.

And just like that, the pretense of civil discourse collapses into something raw, ugly, and thrillingly real. Best of Enemies, Morgan Neville and Robert Gordon’s 2015 documentary, doesn’t just revisit this exchange—it treats it as the Big Bang of our modern media landscape, the moment when television stopped pretending to be a town square and became a bloodsport arena.

Vidal and Buckley face off in a tense 1968 debate, their expressions sharp with disdain

The film’s genius lies in how it frames this rivalry not as a historical footnote but as a prophecy. Vidal and Buckley weren’t just debating the 1968 conventions; they were performing the future of political media. Their clashes—ten in total, aired during the Republican and Democratic National Conventions—were a ratings gamble by ABC, which was then a distant third in the network race.

The gamble paid off. Audiences tuned in not for policy analysis but for the spectacle of two intellectual heavyweights tearing each other apart. Neville and Gordon’s film captures this shift with surgical precision, using archival footage that crackles with the energy of a live wire.

The debates are intercut with contemporary commentary from journalists and historians, but the real star is the past itself—the grainy, unfiltered footage of Vidal and Buckley locked in combat, their words dripping with venom and wit. What makes Best of Enemies more than just a highlight reel is its refusal to let either man off the hook. Vidal, with his aristocratic sneer and razor-sharp tongue, comes across as a master provocateur, but the film doesn’t shy away from his vanity or his willingness to distort facts for the sake of a zinger.

Buckley, meanwhile, is portrayed as a man whose intellectual rigor is often undermined by his own thin skin. The infamous “crypto-Nazi” moment isn’t just a punchline; it’s a window into Buckley’s fragility, his inability to separate personal insult from ideological critique. The film lingers on his face in that moment—his eyes darting, his mouth twisting—and you can almost see the gears grinding in his head: *How dare he?

How dare he say that on national television?*

A close-up of Buckley’s face, tense and flushed, during the heated exchange

The documentary’s structure mirrors the debates themselves: a series of escalating confrontations that build to an inevitable explosion. Neville and Gordon don’t just show us the fights; they dissect the mechanics of them. The editing is sharp, almost musical in its rhythm, cutting between the debates and the modern-day talking heads with a sense of inevitability.

It feels like a eulogy. And yet, for all its focus on the past, Best of Enemies is unsettlingly relevant. The film was released in 2015, a year before the presidential election that would make “fake news” and “alternative facts” household terms.

Watching it now, it’s impossible not to see the echoes of our current media landscape—where outrage drives clicks, where nuance is a liability, and where the loudest voices often drown out the most thoughtful ones. The film doesn’t explicitly draw these parallels, but it doesn’t need to. The footage speaks for itself.

A wide shot of the 1968 debate stage, with Vidal and Buckley seated across from each other, the tension palpable

What lingers, though, isn’t just the political commentary. It’s the humanity of the two men. Vidal and Buckley were more than just ideological opposites; they were two sides of the same coin, both products of a rarefied world of privilege and intellect.

Their debates were as much about personal animosity as they were about policy. Vidal, who had once been Buckley’s friend, seemed to take a perverse delight in goading him. Buckley, for his part, never quite recovered from the “crypto-Nazi” insult.

In the years that followed, he would write a novel (Getting It Right) in which a thinly veiled version of Vidal is murdered, and he would later describe Vidal as “the devil.” The film doesn’t shy away from this personal dimension, and it’s what makes Best of Enemies more than just a historical document. It’s a tragedy, in the classical sense—a story of two men whose brilliance was ultimately undone by their own egos.

In the end, the film leaves you with a question that feels more urgent now than ever: What happens to a democracy when its public discourse is reduced to a spectator sport? Vidal and Buckley’s debates were a turning point, but they weren’t the end of the story. They were the beginning of something darker, something we’re still living through. Best of Enemies doesn’t offer answers, but it does something just as valuable: it forces us to confront the cost of the media landscape we’ve inherited.

And it does so with a clarity and urgency that few documentaries achieve. Watching it, I couldn’t help but think of something Vidal himself once said: “The four most beautiful words in our common language: I told you so.” He was right. We were warned.

Audience Opinions

Audience 7.8/10
"A riveting documentary that brings Vidal and Buckley's fiery debates to life with sharp editing and lasting relevance."

The film captures the wit, animosity, and intellect of Gore Vidal and William F. Buckley Jr.'s legendary debates. Some want more historical context, but the archival footage and sharp commentary keep it compelling.

What viewers praise
  • Engaging archival footage Original 1968 debate footage adds authenticity and historical value.
  • Sharp intellectual clash Vidal and Buckley's sparring is brilliant and intense.
  • Timely relevance Its themes of political polarization and media spectacle remain strikingly relevant.
  • Strong narration and editing Tight pacing and structure.
  • Insightful commentary Christopher Hitchens and Dick Cavett add perspective.
Common complaints
  • Limited historical context Could give more background on 1968 and its political landscape.
  • Narrow focus The tight focus leaves out other influential voices of the time.
  • Pacing issues Occasional lulls in the middle.
Recommended for
Political history enthusiasts Documentary lovers Debate and rhetoric fans Fans of 1960s American culture Intellectual discourse followers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Fiery Feud That Defined Modern Media: Behind the Scenes of Best of Enemies

The 1968 televised debates between Gore Vidal and William F. Buckley Jr. Weren’t just political sparring—they were a cultural earthquake. The documentary Best of Enemies (2015), directed by Morgan Neville and Robert Gordon, revisits those explosive encounters, revealing how they reshaped public discourse. latestnetflix.com's read is that but what went into making a film about two intellectual heavyweights whose rivalry still stings decades later?

Five Years in the Making

The film didn’t come together overnight. According to the Wikipedia entry, Best of Enemies took five years to complete. That’s a long haul for a documentary, especially one centered on archival footage. The delay suggests the filmmakers faced challenges—whether securing rights to the debates, tracking down rare clips, or piecing together the broader context of 1968’s chaotic political landscape. The film premiered at the 2015 Sundance Film Festival, where it likely drew buzz for its sharp focus on a defining media moment.

The Debates That Went Nuclear

The heart of Best of Enemies is the 10 debates between Vidal and Buckley during the 1968 Republican and Democratic conventions. ABC News, then the underdog network, gambled on the duo as a way to boost ratings. What unfolded was less a civil discussion and more a verbal cage match—culminating in Buckley’s infamous on-air outburst, calling Vidal a "queer" and threatening to "sock [him] in the goddamn face". The film doesn’t just replay the fireworks; it dissects how these clashes foreshadowed today’s polarized media landscape, where outrage often trumps nuance.

A Star-Studded Commentary Track

While Vidal and Buckley are the undisputed leads, Best of Enemies enlists a roster of modern voices to contextualize their feud. The documentary features Kelsey Grammer, John Lithgow, Dick Cavett, Christopher Hitchens, Noam Chomsky, Reid Buckley (William’s brother), Andrew Sullivan, and Todd Gitlin. Their appearances suggest the filmmakers wanted to bridge the gap between 1968 and today, showing how Vidal and Buckley’s war of words still echoes in contemporary punditry. Cavett, a TV legend himself, likely provided insider perspective on the era’s media circus.

Why This Feud Still Matters

The film’s reception hints at its relevance. Roger Ebert’s review called it "extraordinarily fascinating," noting how viewers’ minds would "constantly shuttle between then and now". PBS later aired Best of Enemies as part of its Independent Lens series, signaling its appeal beyond niche documentary circles. Rotten Tomatoes lists it with a solid (though not blockbuster) rating, while a French review site gives it a 6.7/10—modest but respectable for a film built on archival material.

The Unanswered Questions

Despite its depth, Best of Enemies leaves some gaps. The evidence doesn’t reveal how the filmmakers convinced Buckley’s estate or Vidal’s camp to participate, if they did at all. There’s no mention of behind-the-scenes tensions during production, though the five-year timeline suggests it wasn’t smooth sailing. And while the film’s trailer and clips exist online, the snippets don’t spill any juicy secrets—just the debates themselves, which speak loudly enough.

One thing’s clear: Best of Enemies isn’t just a history lesson. It’s a warning about how quickly intellectual combat can devolve into personal destruction—and how that dynamic still dominates our screens.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.